Frosty Treat

Ryan B

2024-05

What a great little ice cream shop. There is a literal TON of different choices. From their famous combo cups which could be anything from ice cream with strawberry shortcake to butterfingers to banana splits to slushee drinks, milkshakes etc etc the list goes on and on! Make sure you look at all sides of the glass windows as there are many different combo cups to be tried!

Vince Fazzari

2024-05

Love the look and feel of this place ! We come from Canada to enjoy it. Feels like you’re a kid when you go!Amazing ice cream and shakes

Mary Kowalik

2023-10

Absolutely love this place! It's been around forever and the quality hasn't changed, it's delicious! 3 generations of my family have ate here. Prices are reasonable. Located close to the beach. Perfect way to end your day while there!

Punk 3858

2024-05

…More

Smile more

2024-05

…More

Diane Tyma

2023-05

❤🍦Frosty Treat has the best ice cream in Western New York!🍨❤ Always enjoy our stops here.

Dustin Long

2023-09

If you go to Frosty Treat and leave unsatisfied, that is your fault! What makes it unique (besides the great prices) is all of the special choices they have. My wife and I love the "Buried Treasure". It's a tall cup with Reese's pieces at the bottom, complete with peanut butter sauce, ice cream, and hot fudge. There are healthier options with yogurt as well, and traditional choices like shakes and cones. There is something for everyone here! A WNY must-visit!

Michelle Deland

2021-05

I went but the line was so long I left..I'll be back..they have the best mixes of ice cream and all the goodies to go with it.. went today few days later..got a watchamacallit .. so good..had peanut butter, caramel, chocolate pieces, ice cream, hot fudge, and candy bars in it!! So good.. again forgot to get the ice cream pic lol but here is the end results.. the soft serve special was mango..I wanted that too.. 😂 next time..

Kari Wendel

2023-05

They have the best selection of sundaes, something for everyone. They also have a weekly sundae special- follow them on Facebook so you don't miss out. As of June 2022, they are cash only. It's an old fashioned walk-up service at the window. They added a picnic table out back. You won't be disappointed!

Kent Lawrence-Brown

2023-05

Great place for ice cream. There is sometimes a fairly long line but their Sundays are Worth the wait. All the staff are in their golden years, rather than the usual phone addicted teens.

Donna Dutchess

2024-04

…More

Simon Cox

2023-05

This place is truly legendary! My wife has been going since she was a kid and now we're getting to build the tradition with our 4 boys every time we're back in town to visit family! The staff is always so friendly and the menu certainly does not disappoint.

Bonnielee Mikula

2023-05

Super ice cream shop that has other items to chow down on, eat in or take out. My issue is the parking but they are accommodating and eager to make you smile when you leave. I need to say a small cone is rather huge!!! So, I asked for a kiddie cone which is a small. So now I ask for just a taste and I am more than delighted to eat all of my ice cream and not waste the deliousness. Thank you for the wonderful service and yummy ice cream

DARYL WILLIAM POST

2023-09

Great staff great customer service better choices then any other ice cream place

Erin Doner

2022-05

One of the best ice cream shops in the area.

Chris Lampman

2023-05

Same ice cream shop different season. Always good service and great ice-cream. My son and I love to stop for custom creations.

Patti & John Veres

2023-05

Whole Lotta ice cream for sure. Next time I'm going to order a medium as the large was tremendous. Even DQ doesn't give that much in a large. We got a Hot Fudge Sundae.price was reasonable considering it was large. Made just the way I like and with alot of fudge. Fast Friendly service too!

Tara Irish

2023-06

Fabulous selection of specialty sundaes and ice cream creations. Always something new to try. Best ice cream stand around. Hands down!!

The ogre

2023-06

They make their stuff to look like the picture.....did not let us down! Hands down the best ice cream spot in the area

James Strainer

2020-05

Love this place when we visit the Grandparents. Great place to spoil your kids or yourself. Excellent icecream for a very reasonable price. So many fun and tasty choices. The line goes fast so don't panic and enjoy the happy people getting deliciousness!

Brenda Prigg

2023-08

Best iceream! They are always nice, best ice ever.7/2023 the prices are always great. People are always super friendly and helpful. The best ice cream. I can't say enough about how good it is and how great the people are.

LJ Metzger

2020-05

Oh my goodness! The best sundae around. So many amazing options. Big size and great value. High quality ingredients and craftsmanship. Do yourself a favor and let them be a great summer memory.

Danisha

2022-05

Nice ice cream place. Takes cash only so we had to dig through the car to make sure we had enough for our order. Interesting weekly flavors and damn is this place popular. Stood in line for about 20 mins but worth the wait.

Mike Carroll

2023-05

Great selection of ice cream / sundaes, incredibly reasonable prices, and fast & friendly service every time. Definitely a “must have” every time I’m around Sunset Bay.

Josh Westfall

2023-05

Unfortunately my experience was tainted quickly. I waited in a long line and even ordered for my 2 kids, wife and me... when handing my bank card to the worker she refused it by almost rudely pointing out an old weathered hand written post it size note at the corner of the window stating "cash only" for that, and the embaressment I was subjected to I will never return and my review is regrettably a 1 as I wish I could rate 0.

Adam Blocher

2018-05

This little ice cream shop is a 25 minute drive away, but I will continue to make that commute past several other ice cream destinations because this one is by far the most exceptional in the area. You get far more than you pay for from the considerate staff and they have notably the best sundaes of any ice cream shop I've been to.

Douglas McEwen

2023-05

Amazing creative sundae choices to satisfy anyone's sweet tooth. On hot days the line is long but moves quickly.

Stephen Pokoj

2019-05

Great service and quality quantity and price. They opened today for the season and this is the line 20 minutes later

Bruce Galbraith

2023-08

Always lots of choices for a nice treat. Our dog always has a pup cup with a milk bone in it.

Panimus

2021-05

Best place to get ice cream of any flavor you want. Ice cream of the day is amazing everyday! Milkshakes are better than any other place you could find. Nothing better than Frosty Treat! Always come here for your ice cream wants or needs! ❤😋