All That Glitters Is Old

Tialisa Whipple

2023-05

I am absolutely in love with this store!!! Located right on Main Street in Hurleyville All That Glitters is Old is unlike the vintage stores here in Sullivan County that tend to target the Woodstock era. All that Glitters panders to us Gen Xers as well. Vintage jean jackets, concert tees and incredible tunes were like the Mother Ship calling me home. Don't be fooled by the "thrift store" moniker. This is an elegantly designed shop that is sure to please the masses. Shoes to die for, jeans that flatter and fun quirky knick-knacks are just part of the decor that will turn any space in your home into a conversation starter. I love this store!!!

Shoshana Ritzler

2023-12

All That Glitters is Old is such a unique shopping experience. It’s a gold mine full of one of a kind vintage treasures that you can’t find anywhere else. Every time I visit, there is always something new and special I find which I absolutely need to buy. Customer service is exceptional and the owner has so much knowledge about all of the inventory. It’s truly a one of kind experience! I’ll definitely be headed back there next time I’m in the area. Until then, I’ll be shopping the store online for sure!

Victor Jung

2023-05

Stumbled into this store while in quaint little Hurleyville while fueling up at the gas station. Amazing thrift shop. Soho meets Upstate. Deals galore. Band tees, vinyls, shoes, and of course the bespoke jackets. Going to have to stop by again for my vintage tees, Kaws artwork, and classic rock vinyls.

Emily Greenheim

2023-05

All That Glitters is Old in Hurleyville, NY is a must-visit consignment thrift store for anyone looking for unique vintage finds. The store is impeccably organized and curated, making it easy to browse and discover something new.With a rotating inventory of vintage and retro pieces, there's always something exciting to uncover. Plus, the friendly and knowledgeable staff are always on hand to offer styling advice or help you find that perfect statement piece.If you're a vintage fashion lover, All That Glitters is Old should be at the top of your list. From everyday wardrobe staples to one-of-a-kind statement pieces, this store has it all. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in Hurleyville, NY.

Andrew Liff

2023-05

WOW! How incredible of a store is All That Glitters is Old! From the second you walk in you are immersed in such an eclectic collection of vintage items you’d think you just got off the bus to woodstock. Not only can you build out an entire vintage wardrobe (moroccan rug included) but mix in a few modern styles as well. They definitely had a motif in mind and nailed it. Reasonably priced with friendly staff and great music, I honestly didn't want to leave.