Andy's Sub Shop

CHET LOWE

2023-10

…More

Jacob Pope

2024-05

…More

Sharie Nisbet

2023-06

Unfortunately, I was not impressed with the Andy's sub I received. The "whole sub" was only 10" long. It wasn't even big enough to share with my husband. I basically paid $12 for a half sub! The roll wasn't very soft at all. I was told the roast beef was med rare, and as you can see it was anything but. There was hardly any meat on it at all also.As anyone from this area knows, Andy's has had a reputation for years in Hornell for the best subs! Unfortunately, the new owners haven't quite lived up to the reputation. I'll definitely be trying them again after giving them time to work it out.

The Blue Whale

2023-06

Absolutely delicious! This is a HUGE upgrade from their last location. Andy's staff are very kind and accommodating. If you wan a real, quality sub, forget Subway or Wegmans. Andy's Sub Shop is the place to go!Vegetarian options: On request.Dietary restrictions: AccommodatedParking: Parking located in front lot and on side street.Kid-friendliness: This is a great location for a family night out.Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible ♿️

Brady Bowles

2024-05

Listen the sandwiches are good. But they will ALWAYS get your sandwhich wrong. Every time. I promise. Sometimes twice. LolNow that doesn't mean they aren't good. They are. As long as you don't want exactly whay you ordered.

Michelle W.

2022-06

The best subs around....still, after so many years! It's just the perfect combo- the tasty bread, the delicious meat, and the pepper relish. I was back in town visiting and I'm so glad it's still the same here. It was a pleasure to chat with Connie!

Natassjia

2024-05

…More

Rob Barrett

2024-05

…More

Melissa Storm

2021-06

Andy's is always a very clean and friendly environment!!! The staff is excellent!! They can take your orders 3 subs at a time and get all 3 correct!! They are fast and efficient. I would, have and will again strongly suggest and recommend Andy's Sub Shop for excellent food in the Hornell Area!!

Neeko H.

2022-06

I have not been in this sub shop in about 12-13 years. I went this past weeking as I was passing through Hornell. I saw the hours were a bit weird, but it was open around 4pm. I had to stop with my wife. I ordered a BLT like I always have. It was very good, the roll was so Soft as it always is. The Brownies are to die for!If you are EVER passing through Little Hornell NY, make sure to stop in. Great place, but make sure to bring Cash!

Dan F

2023-06

…More

Josh Carstens

2019-06

It's very uncommon I feel like leaving reviews on Google Maps, but it felt like it would be a disservice for me to not leave a review here. This was the nicest, cutest little sub shop I've ever been to, I've never had customer service like this at any other establishment, and on top of that, the sub itself was delicious. One of the best I've had in a while, besides DiBella's. While DiBella's or Wegmans might have the advantage of top of the line ingredients, being big businesses, I'd probably order from here 3/4s of the time. And also, hot sauce on your sub.

Callie Lathrop

2022-06

The best taco salad I've ever had, hands down. The brownies are to die for....Very cost effective, )) I've never had a more wonderful experience..than ANDY'S....

Robert Cady

2022-06

great service. awesome subs...will be going back for sure ....big soft rolls and a pepper relish that is to die for ...highly recommend this place to anyone that enjoys a great hardy sub

Thomas Morey

2023-06

…More

Cor Cor

2018-06

Hornell's Best place for Subs..and the Nice, Friendly Staff is a Big Plus, especially when you are Starving!! They are Really Quick and Precise with your order. I LOVE that they don't play a 'Guessing~Game' when making your food..if they aren't quite sure, they Ask you, that's Big in my world as I am a definitely a 'picky~eater' and Will Not eat Fat willingly, lol..One Staff that I know her name is: Mary..She's Right On & Really Helpful & Nice..Great Customer Service Every Time I get Subs for dinner..Thanks Andy's for being here for So Many Years..don't know what Hornell would do without their Famous Sub Home..

Dak Lowery

2023-06

Hornells best sub shop! I love my daily lunch subs. Awesome management and great staff.

Bonnie Rice-Wall

2018-06

Love Andy's.. The staff are great, kind, small town people who care and make great food.. The meatball subs are homemade meatballs, the brownies are to DIE FOR, and they always have a sub special.

Jeremy Lloyd

2020-06

What a treasure of a sub shop in Hornell, NY. Amazing atmosphere from start finish. The rolls were perfect and the overall flavors are really memorable.

Ruthie Manges

2023-06

Love the food here. Absolutely delicious and the old and new owners are the best ppl ever

Denise Axtell

2018-06

Best subs ever! Traveled from South Carolina just to get one. Guys working at Corning, Inc. Used to come over for lunch at Andys.

J D

2019-06

One of the beat sub shops in the country. The Italian sub is the best. Every time we come to western NY we go there several times. I

Monica Froggers

2021-06

I was super excited to try their roast beef, they had no mayo, bread, or beef (on a friday)! Total bummer! I'll attempt again in the future!

Stephanie Booth

2022-06

Andys has the best sub's anywhere! They are always polite and the food is consistently great!

J Mac

2018-06

Love the subs here, the taco salad is amazing, and if you need a sugar fix, their brownies are perfection!

Fran Sharp

2022-06

They make the best subs!!Reasonably priced!!Great service!!Highly recommend!!

Len Liss

2020-06

I live in florida, and visit Hornell once a year. Getting a sub. Is a must each year.Best subs. anywhere in the country.

Erin Betts

2019-06

The cold subs were good, but they are a little heavy on the mayo.Don't get the cheese steak. The steak is terrible!

Jeffrey Brundage

2020-06

We have been eating the ham and roast beef subs from here for years and they are always good.

Lindsey's videos Czworka

2019-06

They have some pretty good subs and taco salads!!! 😍😛😍😛 their subs are pretty decently priced too!! 😊😀