Mill Creek Cafe

Alyssa

2024-02

…More

Aaron Peterson

2024-02

…More

Cristin Wheat

2024-03

…More

Andrea Baxter

2024-02

…More

Kelk70

2019-05

Had an Awesome breakfast here! Blueberry stuffed pancakes were So Yummy!Breakfast sandwich was fresh & not greasy like some places have! Excellent home fries!Our server was friendly & prompt. We will definitely be back!

Hank Chinaski

2024-03

Ordered a fried chicken sandwich and a bulldog burger for takeout. The chicken sandwich was chicken and cheese on a roll, no mayo, lettuce or tomato. The burger wasn't bad but lacked any seasoning and had very little sauce. We didn't receive pickles with either meal. I know this place just reopened so hopefully it's just a few kinks that need to be worked out but I fear that the honeoye restaurant curse is alive and well, subpar food offerings that people seem to accept. I'm a local so I hate to write this review but unfortunately it's the truth. The chai was fantastic however so there's that.

Ben S

2022-05

We love this place! Service is friendly and genuine. The food is great, so much so that the most popular dishes sometimes sell out, but we appreciate a place that makes food fresh and goes through it in a day. We had the fried chicken, fried fish, fried shrimp and a cheeseburger and all of it was spot-on. Whoever runs the fryer knows his/her stuff... Our server, Zack was great - even our children mentioned how 'cool' he was. This place is a destination in its own right, and we're lucky to have it here in town...

Stan&Diane Friesen

2023-06

So glad the Mill Creek Ice Cream Shop is open! Friendly, courteous service- now including boba!

Ronie B

2022-05

Fresh tasting food! Great service ! Make reservations you will not be disappointed.

Sarrah Lombardo

2019-05

This was my first time here, however my aunt and Grandmother come here often. This fish fry- both beer battered and panko, were delicious! The dinner portion was enough for 2 people or leftovers. The sweet potato fries, homemade tartar, and Woodstead sauce made this dish even better. I cannot wait to be back in the area to dine here again! ***Picture of my plate was after I had devoured most of it.

Kaleigh

2024-02

…More

Mary Alexander

2024-02

…More

Kurt Krueger

2023-05

High quality food prepared with care in a lovely space. Can’t wait to come back for more. Added bonus is the pet friendly outdoor dinning.

David Lortscher

2024-02

…More

Kevin B. Leigh

2019-05

What a pleasant surprise. we’re here on vacationAnd we’re just driving around looking for a coffee shop, discovered the Mill Creek. From the one the moment we walked in the front door we were welcomed with delicious smells, wonderful service, and a cozy environment.The prices were reasonable, food was delicious, service was exceptional.A real gem in the Honeoye Lake community.

Charles Ciggia

2021-05

Awesome food, many healthy alternatives vs the norm. Service was second to none. We will be back soon!

Brett Mccue

2019-05

Food was delicious. Caleb our server was very knowledgeable and attentative. Local craft beer on tap a plus

Tamitha Browning

2020-05

Great service and amazing food options. Ordered the Black and Bleu wrap and freshly made lemonade.

William DeBottis

2022-05

My wife and I stopped for lunch today. The food was awesome. Everything was homemade , the sauces were. The shrimp was great ,best I've had in a long time. Service was friendly and fast. Well worth checking out.

Lorenzo Napolitano

2022-05

Amazing place! We stopped in on a busy Friday night with no reservations but we were still accommodated. The staff was very friendly and provided excellent service. Great beer selection and tasty food! The staff even went above and beyond and entertained our kids! I would recommend reservations on a busy day. Dine here, you won’t regret it.

Bruce Hennings

2022-05

We had an exceptional dinner tonight. Blackened steak which was delicious. The gentleman who served us was very professional but also funny, had a very positive attitude and he could be a male model. We will definitely go back. I also bought our neighbors a gift certificate from Mill Creek. I would give the place 10 stars and the waiter an 11.

Guy Ward

2024-02

…More

Joe Jech

2023-05

Two of us had lunch. Friendly atmosphere and staff. One of us had a great harvest salad, the other a delicious Tuscan chicken sandwich with a mound of sweet potato fries. All very good. We will be back.

J. D.

2022-05

Stopped at the Mill Creek Cafe with my kids for some ice cream in March. It was a little early in the season so they didn't have their outside stand open, but the staff welcomed us inside to sit down for a couple bowls of ice cream. My kids loved it and me and my daughter had fun trying to spot all of the ducks they had hidden in the cafe. When we were all done, I asked for the check and the owner told us that it was on the house. I couldn't believe it. So incredibly kind and generous. I will be coming back time and time again. My only regret is that I only had 2 dollars in my wallet to leave for a tip.

Elizabeth Prusinowski

2023-05

We are so fortunate to have Mill Creek Cafe in our hometown! The food is exceptional with a wide selection of drinks from area breweries and cideries. The staff is incredible and provides excellent, friendly service. For those of you that live outside of Honeoye, it is definitely worth the trip. Be sure to make a reservation due to popularity.

William Schlegel

2022-05

WOW! Blown away with this place. Amazing food, great owners and staff. Highly recommend checking it out. Definitely gonna want reservations if you're going on Friday night.

dmasci

2020-05

This place is awesome. The food is creative, fresh and delicious! It is small but always bustling. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. They often greet guests by name with a handshake or a hug.The atmosphere is surprising. The outside is very simple but the interior is full of beautiful sculptures and other artwork. The music is fun and relaxing. They have outdoor seating and live music in the warmer months. It is an unexpected gem in a small town.*they have the best gluten free, cauliflower pizza/flatbread crust ever!

Michael Lyons

2019-05

We picked this spot for a quick lunch and were quite pleased. Doesn't look like much from the outside, but it was worth it. There's outdoor seating available. The service was good. The food was quick and tasted good. I had a burger with house made chips and my guest had a grilled chicken salad. I have no complaints, so this place gets 5 stars.

Kimberly Jenkins

2019-05

Always great food and great service here! I was sad to see that their broth Bowl was not on the menu this time when I went. The chef told me though that they are adding it back for the winter months! Their selection of hot tea is also wonderful. The housemaid chips are seasoned perfectly. Great job guys!

Mary JO Madigan

2024-03

…More