4.6 (699)
55 Public Square, Holley, NY 14470
(585) 638-8722
samsdiner.com
Service options
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Dana Jessmer
2024-01
…More
M. Travels
2022-06
Finished off our hike in Holley at this awesome little diner. Parking is in front of the diner which is located in a postcard perfect town that looks like a movie set. We were offered lunch and breakfast menus in the afternoon which is nice to have choices.I ordered the tuna club which was really good with fresh tuna salad and crispy toast. My lunch companion got the Monte Cristo which the waitress suggested he eat with syrup. I've never seen him finish a sandwich before his fries before. That's really saying something because this place honestly has the best fries. Crispy and maybe battered and seasoned? Not sure but they're the best.Friendly service and great prices round out this dining experience. Definitely will be back.
Charlie McNeely
2023-11
…More
David A.J. Sockett (Andrew Sockett)
2022-06
My wife and I stoped by Sam’s Dinner for lunch. The had a lot of different choices, it was hard to decide what to pick. Both of us where surprised how tasty everything was. Great prices and great food. The place was clean, nice atmosphere and friendly customer service! If you in town and looking for a place to grab a bite to eat then I would recommend Sam’s Dinner!
Jeff Levesque
2024-02
…More
Shannon Balmer
2024-02
…More
Greg Cass
2024-01
…More
Rebekah Wheeler-Smith
2024-04
…More
Melissa Kirchgessner
2022-06
Stopped here on a bike ride on canal for breakfast. Good service and food. Mediterranean breakfast wrap was delicious as were eggs, bacon and homefeies.
John Mchugh
2024-02
…More
Kathy Malboeuf
2023-11
The food was soooo delicious !Nice menu ! Professional staff.Great place to go for breakfast/ lunch . The soup is homemade. We were very pleased !!!!!Vegetarian options: My sister and I both love veggies , so we had a grilled veggie wrap. Loaded with veggies. It was amazing. I also had the homemade chicken with rice soup. It was scrumptious!Parking: Hugh parking lot .
Jaci
2023-11
…More
Connie Moore
2023-09
This place is a Diner in the truest and best sense of the word. Real food - not frozen - cooked in the kitchen after you ordered it! Real potato mashed potatoes. Great service and fantastic prices.Vegetarian options: Good selection of vegetarian/pescatarian options.Parking: Easy from the looks of it but we were on bikes.Kid-friendliness: Great kids (Little People) menu!
Leon Smith
2023-12
…More
Bruce B
2021-06
Very good food with large portions. Great services friendly girls. A++ the pic is chicken parmesan with spaghetti
Crystal Yingling
2023-06
…More
Harold Schultz
2023-11
…More
Shelby Anne
2023-06
We enjoy Sam's so much!The prices are very family friendly and the portions are large. Everything always comes out fresh and hot.Our go to is the Fish Fry on Fridays and we really enjoy coming for breakfast. The omelets are great!
Cheryl Murray-Ditzel
2023-06
Service was Great. The Menu is Huge!! Prices are Reasonable. The Food was Awesome with the Portions being Plentiful .Definitely will go back to try other plates and I can only imagine how good their Breakfast is.
Steve “Doc” Thompson
2023-08
…More
Southern Lightning
2023-07
…More
Roz Smith
2023-06
When ever we stop at Sam's, we get good food, good prices, and great service. There was only one waitress on this day, and she didn't miss a beat!! I had a Ruben sandwich, and it was terrific, corned beef was tasty and tender. Fries were served hot too.
Tyson Klinkbeil
2023-06
…More
Jason Parker
2023-09
…More
Jerry LeFrois
2023-08
A favorite place for the locals....and out-of-towners like my self. Breakfast is my meal and Sam's has a good variety to chose from.Prior to the pandemic, Sam's was open 8am to 9pm every day. But now with only one chef, the hours are 8am-3pm Saturday and Sunday and 11am-9pm week days. When Sam's is back to the original pre-covid hours, then I'll give 5 stars.One more thing....Great Fish Fry every Friday evening.
Amanda Acito
2022-06
We discovered this hidden gem two summers ago when looking for the site where our favorite band was performing. Sam's is mostly populated with older locals..and the place looks like it hasn't changed since the 50s...but the lemon pepper broiled fish is the BEST around, and the ravioli is the best I've ever eaten. Staff is friendly and efficient and prices are very good. It may be a bit of a drive, but you won't be disappointed with the menu. Highly recommended.
Keirstan Thompson
2023-06
…More
William Smith
2023-06
Very good food at great prices! The portions are very generous and always hot! I have tried almost everything on their menu and all is good! Servers all do a fantastic job! Highly recommended!
Bob Kilroy
2020-06
Excellent!Both the food and the service here are above average.The service here is always friendly and the waitstaff make you feel like family. (the best kind ☺)The food is fantastic, especially the breakfast menu (which is served all day).The portions are so large, it's hard to eat it all.And of course the prices are very reasonable.If you haven't eaten here, you don't know what you're missing!By the way, I travel a lot, and this diner is one of my favorite places to eat.
Shannon Chamberlain
2023-08
…More
Pet Stores in the USA
Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.
Broswe by Population