Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Joaunna Bixby

2024-01

I ordered 4 subs and an order of fries and they charged me for all. However once I got my order home I discovered an entire sub was missing from my order. This isn’t the first time it’s happened to me from this place either. I think their $10 Thursday sub deals are excellent but when I have to go back because a sub is missing it kind of ruins the family dining together. Their staff definitely needs to pay attention to their job.

BT

2024-05

Absolutely unorganized and way over priced. I have ordered from there 3 time and everytime my order has been wrong. The kids that work there have no clue. The last order I got all the way home and it wasn't even my order. Took the pizza back there was several people standing in line I hope to god they did not give that pizza to someone after it was in my hands. This place is not going to last long. Get your act together or get out of town.

Brent Knapp

2024-01

Unfortunately this is another business that won’t make it in Hilton. I have been to many Salvatore locations and this by far is the worst. The first time I went, I ordered 2 subs on a Wednesday night. Myself and my girlfriend waited 45 minutes and then asked for an update on our order. We were told 5 more minutes. 20 minutes after that, I asked again. I was told that they didn’t even see my order. The girl at the desk proceeded to dig through the garbage to find it. She found it and then told me it should be ready in 20 minutes. An hour and a half we waited in the restaurant for only 2 subs. Cold subs by the way. Today, we tried again. Two subs, fries and pickle chips. Timing wasn’t bad. We ordered online this time. I called 30 minutes after ordering to verify that the food was ready. I was told 15 more minutes. No big deal, it’s a Friday night. I go to pick up the order and we are missing the pickle chips. Not fried pickles but pickle slices on the side for our subs. I was told that they don’t do that there and they could credit us the $2.00 in the next couple days. Really? You put pickles in a cup and take my $2.00, it can’t be much easier. I’m done with this location. The subs are ok but the management or lack of, is terrible and the employees need to be trained. I give it 1 more year max if the business stays run like this.

Terrance Ray Trybus

2023-05

…More

Nicole Muscarella

2023-05

We were excited to try Salvatore’s since it took so long to open, wait time for a large pizza was 45 minutes - 1 hour on a Wednesday. The dough seemed to have been sitting out for hours because it was extremely dry and inedible. Barely any sauce and the cheese was dark. With the over saturation of pizza joints in Hilton, we will not be returning for pizza.

Tim Williams

2023-12

…More

Patrick78

2023-09

…More

Bailey Pittman

2024-04

…More

Caryn A

2024-01

It's ok pizza. There is no shortage of pizza choices in Hilton, and the only thing that makes this one stand out is the outdoor seating and beer.

Susan Spaulding

2024-03

…More

Moc’s RC

2023-11

Many times have we ordered for delivery and it is constantly late. People who answer the phones rarely know how to do anything and never know what's going on with the food until the ask someone. It seems like it's ran by teenagers. Writing this review after being to 35 to 45 minutes and now being told deliveries are taking 1.5 hours. Tonight was probably my last order from here which is unfortunate because salvatores is usually my favorite pizza place.

Josephine DiPisa

2023-08

…More

Erich Shipman

2023-12

…More

Dan Z

2023-12

Took my son there today to pick up a pizza. He asked to eat there instead so we sat down and they brought us plates without us even asking. It's not often you see that kind of service anymore.That being said, several subsequent orders have not been right and the pizza isn't the best.

Kellylee Kelly

2023-08

I had ordered Salvatore's version of a garbage plate. Italian sausage and all mac salad. The mac salad was literally a liquid, of which I'm wearing alot of it. Called pizza place and was told this was normal. I disagreed. I will not be ordering from them again.Have a pic but no place to add it.

Salvatore Strauss

2024-03

Have tried multiple subs from there. Always terrible and seems the bread and toppings aren't fresh and thrown together.

Lisa Williams

2023-11

…More

Grace Romig

2023-05

A wide variety of delicious comfort-foods.We had the $10 Daily Deal; baked penne pasta. It came with a whole loaf of cheesy garlic bread. The single order was plenty enough for two.Dine-in is small, but the friendly staff is efficient and promotes a clean and fun atmosphere.

Don Wenzel

2023-05

Had some Hilton Salvatores pizza at a friends house for super bowl. It wasn't bad so when we were looking for some takeout last week we thought we would try one of their $10.00 specials. I ordered a calzone. Mozz., Ham and Pineapple. Ya I'm a pineapple guy. We picked up to eliminate the $6.00 delivery fee and tip. Go home with it only to find that it was 75% Pineapple with a minimal amount of ham. There was a ridiculous amount of dough also. I threw out about 25% of it as just dough. It had obviously been sitting for a while too (cold) even though we waited exactly 45 minutes as the web site suggested. So my $10.00 calzone wasn't so special after all. I'm not the kind of person that says I will never try again but at this point Carriglios, Carbones and Pontillo's are looking pretty safe. Got some room for improvement guys.

Garrett Oliver

2023-06

Ordered banna peppers, olives and onion with pepperoni and extra cheese. The cheese was not extra. There was 7 banana peppers total. 15 olives. And a sprinkle of diced onion. And they charge for the toppings. Unimpressed.Place is nice though.

CARLO DIPISA

2023-08

…More

Michael Boyd

2023-10

…More

Samantha Schubbe

2023-12

…More

JRS

2023-05

No matter where you go to, the problem with 99 percent of Rochester area pizza stores is that they think pizza is dough and cheese, with sauce as a topping. You have to tell them to use double or triple the sauce and half or less cheese. All because they get tax breaks from feds for using lots of cheese......Disgusting! 🤮

Kelly Sevor

2023-08

Decided to try their food. Was not impressed. Staff was rude. Order was wrong. I did not bring up that my order was wrong because their was another customer there complaining about his order being wrong. Disaster zone!

James White

2024-02

…More

Dick Flynn

2023-05

Love the new location. Clean and friendly staff. Great having Salvatore's classic pizza nearby. Also love their juicy steak sandwiches!

Daniel Delamarter

2023-05

…More

Joe Burress Jr

2023-06

…More

jojo g

2023-05

Definitely not up to the standards of other salvatores, slow, over priced and tiny cold cut portions on subs. We've tried 3 times and tonight will be the last.