Keuka Creamery

Kasey S

2023-08

Yum! Looking for coffee on the way to the lake and found this all for one. They have a drive through and the coffee was great. Coconut oatmilk latte, lemonade, and a razzledazzle refresher.

Michael Grove

2024-04

…More

Christopher Ekimoff

2023-09

We frequent Keuka Lake every August, and a visit to the Creamery is always on our list of things to do! The ice cream hits the spot, the service is exceptional, and the environment is a great place to share an afternoon with friends and family. We will definitely be back again on this trip and all the lake visits in the future.

Chad Alfano

2023-10

This place is a must go too! The staff is very friendly. But their food is even more friendly. With prices you can afford,and desserts you cant afford to miss. This is a must go to shop that you won't regret stopping, and will make a must go from now on if you already haven't!

Dave “Oink” Mason

2023-05

Nice place for an ice cream or shake. Just wished that it was sourced from a local creamery although if you are going commercial, Hershey's is a good option. Shakes were very good and had real fruit in them. Service was excellent and quick. No dine in option, but plenty of picnic tables.

BTC

2023-09

Good ice cream, nice selection, and a handy drive-thru. Be sure to bring cash or your Venmo app, as they don't take a card.

Sandra thatcher

2023-05

prices are much higher than other ice cream places we've been to and servings are small. We can get an entire meal at subway for $9 less than what we paid for our icecream. Very good ice cream though.

Bridgett V

2022-05

Great ice cream. Good service. Prices about thr same as other ice cream places.

James Smith

2023-05

Lovely establishment; guick service and tables to sit outside; clean and a menu posted outside for all the ice cream you want you can even order a hot dog. They also have a drive through.

Heather Carbone

2023-09

Good value! It's too bad it's cash only, but tax is included in prices, so you know what you'll be paying.

Dan F

2023-06

Keuka Creamery is one of our favorite ice cream destinations. Always good service and ice cream. Huge selection of flavors and combinations. Smoothest soft vanilla around!

Kell Tainer

2023-05

Giant scoops, great selection of flavors, Dole whip flavors for lactos-intolerant. Cash or Venmo, which I really appreciate!11/10, will ice cream again!

Melissa Barth

2022-05

Good selection of hard serve ice cream (Hershey's, so not homemade). Friendly wait staff. Lots of seating in a graveled picnic area near the parking lot.

Stephen Haar

2021-05

Menu was slightly misleading as my daughter ordered a cyclon and by the photo next to far from the vanilla ice cream in a waffle cone that she received. The upside bannana split i got was the beat of the year. Also the 1st as well.

Steve Woodhouse

2023-05

Lots of Hershey flavors. Reasonable priced. Hard and soft ice cream as well as sundaes and shakes.

Jan Kline

2022-05

I don't remember what flavor Ice cream I had, brown butter something but it was very good. I like that they have childs sizes. That's just right for me.

Tara Mizerak

2022-05

Great choices.prices are high but you get what you pay for choices galore.bath ice-cream drive up could learn a lot from this pleasant people well run place.

Lisa Smith

2023-06

The Ice cream is good, but small portions for the price.

Margaret Kennedy

2022-05

Even though they were busy the service was fast! Delicious ice cream and shakes, wide variety and reasonable prices.

Amy Terry

2022-05

I love that this little ice cream shop has no sugar added ice cream for those of us watching our intake. Great service and great flavors!

Lyn Batt

2023-05

Fast service especially for how busy they were! Great icecream choices also !

kareena hoyt

2022-05

The drive thru is so convenient. Great portions and prices, this place is a regular stop for my family!

Edward Kropp

2023-05

Stopped for a drink and something to eat while on the road. Pre made sandwiches were fairly good.

Debbie Hogan

2022-05

Great ice cream but alittle bit of a wait for your tasty frozen treat.

Jay Green

2022-05

Great ice cream. A local staple. My family goes there several times a week during the summer.

Craig Rowles

2023-05

They serve Hershey's, and dont show the things they run out of, so its a little hit or miss (edited - I recalled incorrectly a different brand)

Rob

2023-08

Good ice cream and great selection

Where The Wild Wenzels Are

2023-05

Great soft serve and sundaes. Worth a stop if you are in the area

Kareena Hoyt

2022-05

Drive thru is so convenient and they have so many options! Payments accepted cash or venmo, which is very convenient.

Raj T

2023-05

Neat and clean. Staff is really friendly and ice cream us superb