Bagels and Cakes by Club 86

JoeLynn L

2024-02

I absolutely love this place. I live about 15 minutes away, I've never stayed to dine in, I usually order cakes haha. Their strawberry layer cake is absolutely to die for. The prices are amazing for a cake in general. It's always fresh, looks beautiful and of course their icing is the absolute best. Highly recommend stopping here and getting a slice but you'll definitely want a whole cake 😅

C P

2024-04

I cannot say enough great things about Bagels and Cakes! My son had to spend Easter at school and I wanted to send him something to eat that was a bit special. He loves this place and I've had really good success ordering from them in the past. So, very last minute (as in after they were closed Sat night!), I ordered breakfast. lunch and dinner to be delivered this morning, Easter Sunday. I was surprised that they were able to do this on a holiday. But, at 11am sharp, they showed up at my son's frat house and delivered his food. My son was so happy! Thank you so very much for making this a special day after all. HIGHLY recommend them for the quality of their food and exceptional service!

Paul Vanasse

2023-05

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 - 476 Hamilton St., Geneva, NYThis is review is solely based on the service and Bagels. Both are excellent.I went on two days; Day 1 was an Everything Bagel with olive and pimento cream cheese and Day 2 was an Onion Bagel with Chive and Garlic cream cheese. They were toasted just right (I like it very crisp), and they were delicious.The place was busy for both visits, but the friendly staff were able to deliver orders quickly. Stop in for a bagel if you are in town!

Heatheranna

2024-01

This place is pretty consistent. Sometimes I get something that I think is either way too big of a portion or just not made the way I would like it. For instance, the avocado toast is too huge thick slices of toast that remain soft. Even though they are toasted. Then they have so much avocado that I was almost gagging. However, it was a great value. I often get a salad and they give you quite a bit. The service is pretty decent. The food is pretty consistent. If you like something. It's usually prepared the way you like it over and over again which is really important. I like the atmosphere but it can be a little chilly in there and the layout is a little awkward, especially the table where you get the condiments.Vegetarian options: Although this is not centered on vegetarian options, there's definitely food for a vegetarian.

Erik Stoneham

2023-07

Such an amazing little cafe. Great bagels , cookies and sandwiches as well as, just plain good coffee. If you ship your coffee beans , I need them!Staff were friendly and it had a great local crowd.Worth a stop for breakfast if you're in the area

Chunky DaReal Monkey

2024-04

…More

ben secor

2023-06

Let me start by saying I have enjoyed the food here and was a frequent customer up until about 2 months ago. My wife and I would order at least once a week. We stopped ordering from Bagels and Cakes as the service was becoming worse. Well this week we decided to give it another shot. I called and was first put on hold for 10 minutes so I'm assuming they just forgot to pick the call up. So instead I drove in and ordered a buffalo chicken wrap. I waited for my order then drove home. After I opened my order I realized it was a regular ranch chicken wrap. I called the restaurant and let them know what happened as I understand mistakes do happen and orders do get messed up. Instead of offering to fix the problem I was transferred to who I was told was the cook. The cook asked me the problem, I explained and then heard him yell to someone else if they made a Buffalo chicken wrap or another type. He told me the other cook made the correct wrap and he him self witnessed it being made. I assured him it wasn't correct and I would bring it back to show him. At this point I could tell he was irritated because he said "sorry we will talk to you later" and told me to bring it back if I had a problem with it. I wasn’t looking to debate with a chef just making them aware, so I drove back another 15 minutes later and met with the manager who then looked at the order confirmed it was wrong and did refund me for the wrap portion of the order. Well I appreciate the refund that's not what I drove back for. I live over 12 miles from this restaurant so it wouldn't make sense to drive back for a 12 dollar refund. They just couldn't grasp the concept of owing the mistake and trying to fix it. Instead nothing but excuses from the manger and saying it happens over and over. This was really not a review I wanted to write as I was a long time customer but at this point it's the only way I can see getting the word to the owners to make some improvements . I don't know if it's training, staffing problems or just entitled young people running a business with know guidance but I hope they can turn it around. Ambiance would be that of a high school cafeteria with the students running the kitchen.

Judy Andolina

2024-03

…More

Mandy Hawkins

2023-12

When we walked in and went up to the counter we were greeted by the cashier who did not seem to really want to be there. When we told her it was our first time at the establishment she did not have any suggestions she just stood there quietly. We finally ordered a Swiss and mushroom burger and a Swiss and mushroom chicken both with fries. The Swiss and mushroom burger was undercooked and cold fries, does swiss and chicken sandwich was very dry but at least the good part he had warm fries. When I went up to say something they were very happy to remake my sandwich and fries but when I decided to finally walk back up to find out where it was it was made wrong I did not order a bacon cheeseburger little different if you ask my opinion. When I told them I just want a refund one of them said okay the rest just argued with me like we were back in high school. So if you would like to go to an establishment that you feel like you're back in high school it might be a great place for you. But if you actually want hot fully cooked food don't go there

Amber J

2023-05

Had a Apple Orchard salad and substituted the chicken for steak. The food was excellent and atmosphere was nice. The person taking my order was super accommodating with my request

Starfish Seastar

2024-01

Wow what the heck guys? My bagle sandwich was a disaster, assembled completely ridiculously, cut unevenly, and unable to even eat it as a sandwich, I had to deconstruct it and eat it in pieces. Y'all charge way too much for sub-McDonalds level quality. It'll definitely be a while before we consider coming back. This is just unacceptable. Have photos to post but can't add them to this review. The bagel sandwich as a sandwich is inedible. It wasn't busy or crowded, this is just lazy and poor quality.

tobin shepherd

2023-05

This is a phenomenal restaurant! It's worthy of not only breakfast that we came back for lunch! Both meals were outstanding. ....and Fish Fry Friday is very delicious!Local hint: try the lemon sugar cookie!

Anna V

2023-05

Food here was so delicious! We tried the salads and the coffee. The salads are huge and very good! They come with lots of toppings and tasted very fresh. The coffee was also just as good. We’ll definitely be back and would love to try the desserts next time!

Amy Perl

2023-12

I really don't like to leave reviews but I feel like it is necessary.First our orders were not right. My friend had her fixed but im not one to really complain. The burger I got was very good but I ordered medium and definitely got raw because the blood just dripped out.Before we left I wanted to get some bake goods to bring home. Now I don't live near by, 2 1/2 hrs away. I had ordered 2 scones along with other bake goods. Got home to put things away and no scones. I dont know what happened. Looked at my receipt and I was charged for them. After the fact I wish we would of just ordered coffee and kept on the road.On the positive...quaint little place and the bagel and strawberry cream cheese was great.

Kristen Noelle

2024-02

…More

Mallory Meli

2024-04

…More

Chuck Mundry

2021-05

We had greens and beans, rigatoni with meatballs, a chicken and bowtie pasta soup, and roast beef swiss pesto pannini

Claudio Vargas

2024-03

…More

Alana Roberts

2024-01

…More

Lorraine Rizzotto

2024-01

This place is always a banger! Fresh food, coffee is superb and the staff are SO nice! I just wish that I lived closer to go more often 🖤Parking: Make sure to go before their peak times because parking can get a bit cramped, but it's worth it!

Eric Lyon

2024-03

…More

Vincenzo “Enzo Imperial Limo” Raffaele-Addamo

2023-12

…More

John Kerner

2024-03

…More

Sam T

2021-05

Food was fresh and delicious. Really enjoyed our breakfast here. Try the bagels and homefries!!

suzanne redonnet

2023-08

The Black and Blue salad is excellent. They also make the best cake on the planet. Everything is good. It's a nice informal atmosphere with outdoor seating available. I bring out of town guest here all the time and they are always impressed.

Kristen McNicholas

2024-01

…More

Bonnie Miller

2023-05

I recommend this place offen, but this experience was not a good one. I waited an hour and 45 minutes for a burger that was supposed to be well done. It is almost raw, a total waste of my money I can't even eat it

Ken Yott

2023-05

Our largish group of parents & gymnasts stopped here for our lunch on our way home after a meet last weekend. This establishment serves breakfast and lunch and the menu is extensive. I guarantee you'll have a difficult time deciding what to order! The food and service is excellent. The staff was very friendly and happy to talk. I had a wonderful veggie Reuben and a raspberry crumb bar for dessert. It was all delicious and we all had a wonderful experience. Our young gymnasts enjoyed everything from pancakes to greens & beans. I highly recommend this hidden gem if you're ever in Geneva, NY!

Mike Preston

2024-04

…More

Rachel Rumpff

2023-12

…More