Frewsburger Pizza Shop

Jamie B

2023-09

Definitely a nice place to stop for food pizza and wings. Super busy on a Saturday with walk-ins and call-ins but theybwere busting it out! We waited about 15 minutes for dine in.Dietary restrictions: They have a gluten free pizzaKid-friendliness: It's pizza!

Heather Heald

2024-04

I called and asked for extra mild wings. I told them that their mild wings were too hot for me. Mind you, I get mild wings at many other places in the area and don’t have a problem. When I received my “mild wings” they we NOT mild wings. I called and said they were not mild wings. They told me to bring them back so they could judge if the wing were mild or not cuz wings are expensive!!! I understand wings are expensive, but I ordered 1 lg pizza with cheese, 1 lg meat lovers and 20 wings. 10 EXTRA mild and 10 gold fever (rush). We order from them often as we live in Frewsburg. As I stated when I ordered, your mild wings are too hot! Apparently repeat customers are not good enough for the Frewsburger. I guess they are always right. I guess I’ll stop what I am doing and bring them back so they can judge. Restaurants never make mistakes!

LJ Metzger

2024-02

We tried it because none of us had ever tried it and it was right across from the bowling alley we spent a few hours at.I ordered a Buffalo chicken tender sub with extra ranch, provelone cheese, Buffalo sauce, no onion, no tomatoes. I got no Buffalo sauce at all. Extremely light ranch. Extremely overcooked hard dry gross chicken. Tomatoes. Over toasted dry bun. I got up and asked for a cup of Buffalo sauce and a cup of ranch. I was given ranch and just a cup of hot sauce not Buffalo. I just took it because obviously I was somehow asking way too much of the place. Nothing saved it. I threw more than half of the sub away it way dry hard and gross.The Hawaiian was okay not good not bad. We'd get it again in a pinch, but wouldn't go out of our way.Torn older plastic table clothes. Carvings in the wooden walls.Talking to a few locals at the gas station kitty corner to the pizza shop about it being a lack luster experience they agreed that the chicken finger sub sucks. They said they only get wings there 90% of the time rarely ever pizza.All three locals in the gas station said the honey mustard wings and medium wings are their best things on the menu. We might try them again to see if the wings are okay. All 3 of us were very unimpressed.

Loonarie

2023-06

All locals know this place and they know they know their locals. If you are from out of town, stop here. Starting with slices at lunch, including cupped pepperoni that get a nice char, there is a solid range of pizza shop standards where the pizza ovens work tirelessly. From pizza, sandwiches, Stromboli, and wings, they twist the normal pizza shop menu with "fat bellie" sandwiches, which use pizza dough instead of bread. They have the normal regional sides like pizza logs, but throw in curves with sidewinder fries and a jumbo pretzel.Parking: Right in front or across the street, the parking seems to turn over pretty often.

Chris Ellis

2023-07

…More

Christopher Larson

2024-04

…More

Rebeccanne Dannels

2023-08

Frewsburger Pizza Shop in New York has won my heart as a go-to destination for mouthwatering pizza that never fails to impress. With its exceptional quality, flavorful toppings, and friendly service, Frewsburger Pizza Shop is a true gem for pizza enthusiasts.From the moment you step into Frewsburger Pizza Shop, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza engulfs you, instantly igniting your appetite. The cozy and welcoming atmosphere, coupled with the friendly staff, creates a delightful dining experience for both locals and visitors alike.The pizzas at Frewsburger Pizza Shop are a testament to their commitment to excellence. Each slice is a masterpiece of flavors and textures. The crust is perfectly baked—crispy on the outside, yet delightfully soft and chewy on the inside. The generous toppings are fresh and carefully chosen, creating a harmonious combination of flavors that will leave you craving more.

Susanna Hummel

2024-03

…More

Jay HoL

2020-05

Good pizza and wings. Gold Rush pizza is really good. The regular red sauce is very sweet.

TS

2023-05

The crust is pretty good. I think the veggie pizza is the best. The red sauce on the pizza is too sweet and they always put way more than they need to put on. If they didn’t make the sauce so sweet and didn’t drown the pizza in sauce it’d probably be pretty good. Even when you say go light on the sauce they drown the pie. Come on guys.

Ed Kurtz

2023-07

My daughter had a gift certificate here for a large pizza so we chose to check them out. Place was busy and the owner was training a new cashier at the same time. He talked her through in ringing up everyone's order and did keep the line moving efficiently.I ordered a large pizza and a single order of wings. Said about 20-25 minutes. Food was ready at the earlier end of approximate time.So, get home and open everything. Pizza had plenty of pepperoni, sauce was good and light on cheese (wife is a cheese lover). Sliced all the thru and even size pieces. The aroma of the wings was awesome from carrying it out the store all the way thru opening at home! Perfectly sauced and cooked wings.Would try again!Everything was perfect and the only star I did knock off was the pizza was light on cheese.Recommend.

Cory Boutelle

2023-07

…More

Douglas Lawson

2023-11

…More

Shannon Johnson

2023-07

…More

Joey Hall-Palmer

2023-08

…More

Major Man

2023-05

Absolutely love the pizza and portions. If you like a sweeter sauce this is a good place to be.

Mark Peterson

2019-05

Bowling at alley across the street with Friends. The meal we had was great. Wonderful pizzas! Wife and I had a strombole which would have fed four. Only 12.99$. Yup, we'll be back there soon. Service good too.

Paddy

2023-08

…More

Brad Turner

2023-05

Awesome food. The pizza is always fantastic and the chicken gold strombolis are insanely good! Online ordering is very convenient, and the staff is always pleasant. Highly recommended!

Heather G

2022-05

First I ordered my food online an hour and a half before I was to be there to pick it up. Just a chicken finger sub and fries…. Then I get there at my time slot (a little early understood it’s wasn’t done yet) to grab my food and told it will be a little while longer. The ladies working the register were so rude and she had a nasty attitude. I only ordered from here because I wasn’t arriving until 8pm and Turtle Pit (best place for subs) closes at 8pm. I won’t make that mistake again.

Bradley Smith

2022-05

Under new management? Just had the worst pizza in years. No crust, doe was thick in middle, always get well done, except this time, just couldn't finish this undone mess. Next time I will keep my change instead of putting in tip jar.

Joshua Campbell

2018-05

I really enjoy Frewsburger pizza. Their sauce is sweeter than most other pizza joint's sauce. The crust is soft and lightly seasoned. The cheese is plentiful as are the.toppings. The overall experience is really good! I often find myself eating "just 1 more slice" than I should solely on the perfect texture and taste of the pizza. -- And to add to this review, I just tried the new Hawaiian style pizza. I am pleased to say.it is very good as well! The sweetness of the sauce compliments the ham, bacon, and pineapple.Keep up the good work Frewsburger!

T Morris

2020-05

Their friend dough delicious but badly leaking oil. Their Golden pizza sorely lacking sauce. The service was sub par and the tables sticky... no sign to seat yourself, no welcome and definitely not fast.... usually not fast means better quality food... not here. Lastly, I sorely hope that the giant pad of paper that was being used to take orders was just a fluke. Definitely not green in any way.

Pixie the Bug

2020-05

Pizza sauce wasn't that good. Food was fantastic other then that. When we first walked in the man at the counter warned us about the long wait, which I appreciated. It was still frustrating to sit there for 45 mins and see people get food that had come in after us. Otherwise they are friendly, courteous and gave warm, fresh food.

jen lynch

2022-05

We had plans on eating at the erlandson overlook after a small wedding there but it was to windy and cold so we went to Frewsburger Pizza. We had never been there before and we had a large group of people. They were very nice and helpful. The food was very good.

Parry Redeye-Jacobs

2019-05

Excellent food! Great service!The young men in there were working their butts off. I did have to wait a lil longer for my order to be ready, but it was worth the wait and I left a nice tip.Keep up the good work, guys; and ignore the rolling eyes and heaving sighs from some of your other customers. I know that you guys were doing the best you could as fast as you could.You got yourselves a new regular customer as far as I'm concerned. 😊🖒✌🖒

Todd Koningisor

2023-05

This is my hometown pizza place. Everybody thinks their local pizza place is the best, but they're most certainly wrong. I've had pizza from many different places and haven't found a place that makes a better pie than here.

Joanne Johnson

2023-10

…More

Michael Briggs

2020-05

I ordered a pizza sub tonight. They were EXTREMELY busy the phone was off the hook so busy but i went in and ordered and they all worked well together and got my sub out in a timely manner. Overall i was very satisfied as always with this place. They have the best food around

Jen Knight

2021-05

Last 2 experiences have been negative ones here. We usually get decent food here but last 2 times our food orders were messed up and needed fixed. They did replace the food and apologized for their error but caused us an additional half hour wait and a return trip to get the new order :(