Toad's Too Ice Cream Oasis

Amber Phelps

2024-04

My girls and I love toads too!! We go any time we have a hankering for ice cream, great place for a pick-me-up, the owner is always so sweet and wonderful and gives my kiddos and I appropriate dollops of ice cream!

Vex Intersectional

2024-04

The perfect little ice cream place! Large servings for fair prices are absolutely worth the short drive from Ithaca.

Angelique Marie

2023-05

Toads never disappoints! It's one of the best ice cream places I've ever been to and my husband and I look forward to it all year long!

Erica Gardner

2021-05

Toad's Too is the best ice cream parlor EVER! So many options and you get so much ice cream for so little money. This was a small and it was only $2.50, whereas yesterday at Purity I got a very small junior scoop for $3. They are friendly and deciphering the grammar of the name makes for great conversation!!!

Nikkie Scofield

2023-08

Last night my 18 yr old daughter went there. She ordered her ice cream, but apparently Kathy the owner didn't like how she ordered. Kathy gave my daughter her change and said "now be gone"! Seriously?! You are the owner and that's how you talk to someone who has gone there for 18 years? Never again!! We will gladly give our business to the frost cow or the creamery!

Bentley Parker

2023-12

…More

Dan

2023-05

Been coming here since I was a child (21 now) and man I love this place. It is such a treat to come every time, the staff are super nice, the ice cream and the options are amazing as well. Prices are amazing too, when they increased their prices on some of their items I was still very happy to pay that amount. Very worth the money and the experience every time. Love this place, and always will come here when I can!

Vic Krue

2023-05

It's been over twenty years since we've ve been to this little joint, but my wife and I were treated like royalty and enjoyed every minute of our stay. The custard cone, Byrne dairy, was absolutely outstanding.We have not forgotten you folks.

James Jensen

2022-05

My favorite ice cream stand. Great ice cream, great prices. Lots of options. Excellent service.

Cindy Snow

2022-05

I love this ice cream shop. I always know when Spring is here or about here because the ice cream shop is open. The owner knows my order by ❤... When someone is stressed they may go get a alcoholic drink, well I go to get my large milkshake. The owner is so nice and personable. One of my favorite places... 😘

Anthony Tuttle

2022-05

Do you like small town feeling with great service and affordable prices? Do you like a sweet treat once in a while? Toads is the place for Great people, great prices, and the best ice cream around. This is the place to go for a cold sweet treat anytime you get the hankering. You will always see great people providing top notch service, and amazing choices and variety.They have more than just ice cream too, so check it out and take the whole family!

Madi Kebrdle

2022-05

This local ice cream shop has such a great atmosphere due to the friendly customer service, charming decor, and plenty of seating inside the toad themed garden as well as tables and chairs outside. I love that there is a wide assortment of hard and soft ice cream flavors, as well as specialty desserts and even warm food. We will definitely go here again!

Amy Schenck

2022-05

We love Toads!They have a huge variety of ice cream flavors and sundaes. The people who own it are super sweet and hard working. We always look forward to going here and love the fact that they are the first in the area to open for the season.

Amanda Bindhammer

2023-10

It was great. The lady was very sweet and the kids were happy we found a place still open!!! They were very happy 😊

Stacy Verbeck

2021-05

Best all around place for ice cream! They have the most amazing flavors by Gifford's, and the most unique and delicious sundaes! Prices are also very reasonable! Cute little frog pond, and some coin horses for the kids to ride on.

Melody Young

2023-05

The choices of ice cream flavors for both Soft and Hard was unbelievable Then on top of that were the sundaes and more!! The prices were amazing!! I highly recommend this place!!

Freya Ryd

2021-05

Every time I go the employees are really nice. They have a ridiculous selection of flavors and you can even make your own soft serve flavor by mixing flavors. It’s super fast great prices and a really cute stand with toad and frog decor. Definitely my favorite place to get soft serve

caitlin spry

2023-05

It's always a great sundae when you go here. Not badly priced either. Everything taste great and fresh. The lady is always kind as well.

Derek Matthews

2021-05

Very slow. Like 3 ice creams handed out in 15 minutes slow. I don't know if it has to do with the amount of flavors, but we were waiting in line for 20 minutes with only two small groups of people in front of us. Unfortunately we were on a time crunch and had to leave before even trying any. I'd give this a lower rating, but I don't like tearing down local businesses. Something needed to be said though.

Jena Jones

2018-05

The woman that served us, I believe she was the owner, was extremely rude and yelled at us, the prices are slightly high for the amount of ice cream you get, toppings are an extra charge and you don't get many toppings for how much they charge. They didn't even fill the cones or the bowls-the middle was hollow. This place used to be better but now it's not worth it.

Kristine

2022-05

We were passing through and decided to stop. OMGoodness.. I wish I got a medium instead. Idk why but that ice cream was BOMB 👀👀🤤🤤🤤 they even had a little dish for our pup 🐶They had a great selection for hard and even had the Dole twists! such a cute little seating area as well, mosquitoes were horrible though so we jetted.

makeup4mimi

2022-05

This place is absolutely awesome. If you're looking for great ice cream and retro atmosphere...look no further. You can't beat the prices, the service, or the ice cream choices.

Grace

2022-05

Tasty ice cream! Lots and lots of flavors both soft serve and regular. There’s hiking trails near by and Toad’s is the perfect stop after a hike. Also dog friendly.

Philo Krnotch

2021-05

Little our of my way but was on a visit and stopped. Ice cream was typical and good. However the cautionary procedures were impressive. Mask a must, distance a must, and as we did, one person took the order and the rest stayed in car.

Andrew Harmon

2018-05

I love Giffords ice cream! The prices are low, the servings are extra large, the service is friendly, and the quality is great. I am not sure what else you want out of an ice cream store.

Christopher Parzyck

2020-05

The soft serve is phenomenal and the small cone for $2 is a great bargain. One of the best ice cream stands in the Thompkins county. Great for an after dinner treat.

KS Brook

2023-08

They always have a nice variety of flavors. They also have vegan options.

Jerry Lee Cornwell

2022-05

Excellent quality ice cream, quick service! This place looks grungy but don't be put off by exterior appearance, it is first rate!

Jonathan Spencer

2022-05

Great selection, very reasonable prices. Leisurely service so be prepared for a line. Cute little garden could use a few hours' TLC.

Shawn Willis

2023-05

Great staff for many years like family almost try to shop local good prices very friendly even after there husband/father passed they managed to stay open and even after hours they will still serve you