Cave's Delicatessen

4.1 (52)

5 Main St, Forestville, NY 14062
(716) 965-2931
caves-food-center.yeeq.io

Claimed
Deli
Gas station

Service options

  • In-store pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Beth Peart

2024-01

An unusual convenience store with an in-store pizza place, and deli. The pizza is amazing! Try "The Godfather." Loved it.It gets one star for atmosphere as it is a convenience store with grimy, worn, old tile floors and no decor to speak of. It's not the atmosphere that sets it apart, it's the food.

Theresa

2024-04

Really miss y'all already. Great ppl if ya get to know them. Can be cranky but def a good place an ppl xoxo Lava. Esp Phil in the liquor store :)Kid-friendliness: I def would say kids are safe here ;)Wheelchair accessibility: A ramp that helps

Cindy

2022-05

I really like caves now with the new owner! The food is great!!! Not everyone is perfect and people make mistakes sometimes and THATS OK. I know some may have issues with the deli but how is that the owners fault? It’s hard to have reliable employees that actually want to work now a days. The store looks better than it has in the last 5 years! I truly enjoy Caves and the people there

John Miller

2022-05

I have to say over the past year the food is a lot better now but the service in the morning is extremely poor & yes the store is dirtier than it use to be. My biggest issue now is the service in the deli. The new owners seem like good people. Prices seem lower than in the past. Food is better. Just need better customer service in the mornings.

Raw Meat

2023-11

…More

Sara Miland

2019-05

Morning, I have to say it was such a pleasant change to call in my order lastnight & be greated so kindly on the phone. When I came into the store to pick up my order the older lady on the cash register was so sweet greeting myself & my hubby, when we got to the deli these two young men greeted us in away that was so kind & pleasant that we felt like we were their only order that mattered to them. The overall vibe of the store was upbeat & positive. I’ve never ever felt that before in this store. Such a wonderful change of atmosphere there. Hopefully it will stay that way. Plus the food was amazing & worth every penny we spent. I have heard people complain about the prices going up but the prices aren’t that bad at all & if we keep getting the service like we got lastnight it’s worth it. Thank you to the young men that made our night & May the Lord God Bless you both. :)

Breanna Smith

2024-03

…More

knightnrmer

2022-05

They have their relatives give them 5 star reviews .... They should erase the previous owners ratings and have a true rated version of their own . If you want a good sub I would suggest you don't go there . Hopefully they get better . 1 star .

Nichole Taylor

2024-02

…More

Mark Pitts

2023-10

Great store , look small on the outside but bigger than it looks!

Carolee Kilburn

2023-05

Wendy Love needs a twin. Steak sub I got tonight was pretty dry. Wendy rocks!

Teresa test

2023-07

Pizza was good! Prices on everything else was absurd!

nathan carpenter

2022-05

It used to be good but eversense the new owner the last 4 times I have ordered my food has been messed up in some way and not very good very disappointed

Patrick Till

2022-05

I've been coming here for years, and their subs are the best in the area. Friendly staff will greet you by name!

Ashley Buelow

2023-05

Amazing subs from there deff worth the 45 min drive there ..

Rodney Haskins Jr

2023-05

A small country store/gas station with a deli and sub/pizza shop. Friendly staff and great breakfast sandwiches.

Jeff Knoop

2024-02

…More

Porscha Seeley

2023-12

…More

Catherine Tooley

2019-05

Great food! Best pizza and subs for miles!! Trust me, I've looked.

Mr. Covert

2022-05

This place has everything. Deli has delicious food served with a smile.

joe vitale

2018-05

Food is evenly priced for area. Sandwiches and salads were fresh.

Cr Ln

2023-10

Outdate food. Over priced.

Kevin Altman

2016-05

Has the best food for a great price!

Brady Gib

2018-05

Good pizza and subs fair price

James Webber

2018-05

Their hours suck and they are over priced

Joe Gelencser

2023-10

Nice

J Bently

2023-07

Very great place

Ama Lame

2022-05

Best food in town

Chris Barber

2023-05

Price gouging at its finest

Opening Hours

Monday 6 AM-10 PM
Tuesday 6 AM-10 PM
Wednesday 6 AM-10 PM
Thursday 6 AM-11 PM
Friday 6 AM-11 PM
Saturday 7 AM-11 PM
Sunday 7 AM-10 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet