Fly Creek General Store

4.5 (70)

6212 NY-28, Fly Creek, NY 13337
(607) 547-7274

Claim this business

Gas station

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible restroom

Amenities

  • Restroom

Payments

  • Debit cards

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

MrJcassell

2024-01

We are lucky to have this corner gas station in our town ! Thank you Tom for keeping it open !

Bruce A Munson Sr

2024-03

Out dated product on their shelf. Every pastrie I got was stale.

Tim Yerdon

2023-11

Never found anything that I got there that I didn't love they serve very good food

Adrienne Baker-Vennen

2023-05

Great shop! Yummy food luke toasted bagels w/ cream cheese and wraps with delicious chicken salad. German chocolates and friendly staff. Love this spot!

Emily Yandell

2022-05

Small little general store. Staff is friendly and helpful. Variety of beverages and snacks. Do have alcohol and tobacco if you are in a pinch and don't want to drive into town. Overall they have some unique items that you won't find at many other places. Gives you that little town country feeling I loved from when I was a kid.

A P

2024-02

Every town should have a general store like this!

Delaven Brown

2021-05

All covid guidelines are clearly being kept. Mask must be warm, social distancing asked to be fallowed, limited number of costumers in store at one time, dividers at check out. Definitely in the top list of places to get a breakfast sandwich in the Cooperstown NY area.I hope this is helpful and your experience is as good as our families. Our 4 and 6 year olds loved there food!! Please like and fallow as "The Browns" are always on the move...

Robin Walrath

2021-05

Nice hometown feel store with homemade goods that are delicious 😋 This place has a little of everything, deli counter homemade soups and specials, coffee to go,gas for the car, post cards/occation cards, t-shirts. This store has been here forever!

Robert Wayne Goodman-Burdette

2023-05

We come up twice a year. And get the delicious macaroni and cheeseAnd the apple cider is The best tasting I've ever had

Brendon Harris

2022-05

Great local fuel and deli store. Daughter loves their subs and the quality is excellent. Great baked goods and other convenience items.

Jim Brogan

2020-05

Way over priced. A cup of cold coffee and a donut was 5 bucks. Cold coffee and when it was conveyed to the counter lady, we were ignored. Go a few minutes farther to Cooperstown. You’ll be happy you did

Sharon Platt

2021-05

Great cider, if you go, get there early, the line to get in is very long. Great variety of items in the store. Go through the store first to receive 10% discount at the cafe.

Charlie Reynolds

2021-05

Don't get gas here. They Will hold $100 on your card for 24 hours(at least they are saying it will be back in 24 hours). All without AUTHORIZATION. I didn't find out til I checked my bank.

timothy walker

2022-05

Great food. It's small but has everything you need. I recommend going for lunch.

Kathy Coleman

2022-05

Super delicious baked items and the lady in the store was really friendly (maybe she's the owner...not sure).

Norman Smith

2022-05

Tom the owner is a good friend of mine,he doing well, he has it going, he has about anything you want in his store, he is not far from the base ball hall of fame stop in he has things you have never seen before.

Chris Dennis

2023-05

Always a great place to stop for a bite to eat and some gas..

Ryan

2022-05

They shut off the pump as I was getting gas. It only went to 4¢ and they charged my card $1. Scam!

david beckley

2022-05

Awesome food awesome owner who does please his customers

Peggy Bergen-Pavelka

2021-05

Food gifts cards deli. Local syrup and honey. Lottery. Coffees

Orion Palmer

2017-05

Great food, and ornery help. My kind of place! Feels like family.

Joe Pagillo

2021-05

This is a quaint little store, worth a pop in for a coffee and to check it out

Dezarae Yother

2023-05

Amazing customer service and food was out of this world

Michael Davis

2022-05

Small country store, had 90 octane non ethanol gas.

michael pietschker

2020-05

Nice little place to stop and grab a bite to eat or .drink.

Clifton Grant

2020-05

Great food and staff was extremely nice.

Bradford Buonasera

2021-05

Great Apple cider and kids will have fun

Brad Marcus

2023-05

Great food, great people!

Justin Badore

2021-05

Always great French toast sandwiches!

Adem Arifaj

2022-05

Good spot to grab a sandwich or coffee.

Opening Hours

Monday 7 AM-8 PM
Tuesday 7 AM-8 PM
Wednesday 7 AM-8 PM
Thursday 7 AM-8 PM
Friday 7 AM-8 PM
Saturday 7 AM-8 PM
Sunday 7 AM-6 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet