Pines Pantry

JC

2023-09

Amazing selection and service. A real gem. Always ask for stuff you don't sew especially at the full service butcher fish counter. Yes it's expensive but all that fresh selection has to come by boat with a fickle crowd. By the time one does stop and shop with freight charges, pain in the neck order, waste from over buying you're probably at even for less quality and buying corporate instead of local.

Erik Johnson

2022-05

Famously has everything. Great meat and seafood department. Decent sandwiches and cold brew on tap.

Nikita Rvachev

2023-09

You can by beer here for a 14 dollars per pack instead of 1 bottle for $9 in the nearest bar.

James Dale

2023-06

The Pines Pantry is a gem in the community, offering a surprisingly well-stocked selection of high-quality groceries, excellent meats, freshly made sandwiches, and delicious baked goods like pies and breads. Their attention to quality and curation of its inventory is evident. The Pantry is the go-to destination for quality food in the Pines and they sell cute Pantry t-shirts with their timeless seventies logo.

Walt Elliot N.

2023-09

I only go here if necessary, TBH the deli is amazing but the prices have always been crazy here. They do have a lot, but your better off doing a Stop & Shop order and grabbing odds and ends here.

John Galluzzi

2023-08

All quality and a lot of variety...Anything you could want to make the dinner you're thinking of preparing. Clean - products displayed well in the store.

Lorelei Ormrod

2022-05

Love their attention and thoughtfulness- well stocked store, run with fine organization and genuine kindness. Today’s delivery person even tucked the ice cream in the freezer for us! Thank you for providing such good service with such care.

Susan Lawrence

2020-05

Great selection. Prices same as a fancy upscale NYC market. I shop here for last minute extras, and ice cream. Fantastic deli bar. They carry organic oat milk 😉

Cyd Zeigler

2018-05

Great sandwiches. The curry chicken salad is great, I always get it with muenster cheese in a wrap. It's always amazing to me that they carry all of the ingredients they have. I have never looked for anything, despite how rare, and not found it here.

G Gotham

2017-05

Its a summer holiday shop so naturally the prices are high, mostly because they have the added cost of ferry everything over from the mainland. But they have a well curated selection of food to bhoose from and the wasabi kale salad and iced coffees are really great. And i love that they carry edwards frozen key lime pie, so good!

Robert Weber

2019-05

Still a mystery to many how they manage to have an amazing selection in a small store. And let's not forget a traditional butcher shop that also makes breakfast, lunch and dinner sandwiches and such to order. And a counter staff second to none.

Rich

2020-05

If you use Pines Pantry your dinner or Events will turn out Fantastic! Our catering firm uses Pines Pantry and we see George for All our events. Excellent quality, best on Fire Island!

James Nunez

2018-05

Where else are you going for food on the island. Small, good selection of stuff. Staff is young and friendly. Check website, hours of operation vary depending on day and season. Liquor store is right behind it.

James MacGibbon

2019-05

Great selection of takeaway gluten free fresh food (eg breakfast and lunch sandwiches and salads) as well as groceries. Friendly staff. Island prices $$.

Aaron Duckworth

2017-05

Great for last minute stuff. Bring the majority with you as this place can get expensive. The young college girls are so nice and put up with all the weekend day trippers

Olivier Cassagnol

2017-05

Certain things are way overpriced (e.g. chicken breasts), but most things aren't that bad. They do have a good variety considering the size of the place.

loola Realpirate

2023-05

Make sure to bring fistfuls of cash ;-)They have it all - and will deliver .

Mike Dallas

2022-05

You can find anything you'd find at a regular supermarket in the United States but for being the only grocery store in the Pines, the prices are not good, especially for booze.

Alex Barillas

2023-09

Peppered Pines !!! YUMPrices are $$$ as expected but fun friendly staff

Baby Yoda

2020-05

Great place to shop. They have the best lobster salad on this planet 🌎

Luiz Colodetti

2017-05

Great selection and friendly staff. They had everything for a good weekend.

John ORSATO

2019-05

Expensive : yes ... Excellent : yes... part of the community and hats off to Clayton who does so much behind the scenes.

Eric Wilson

2018-05

This place has everything you need to start your perfect vacation. And they deliver to your house.

Bryan Glover

2018-05

Finally, I found a place on the island with IPAs. Staff is friendly. Has just about anything you might need.

Christian Dutilh

2016-05

A solid sandwich shop. I was expecting it to be much more expensive since they have to ferry all the food over, but it was pretty reasonable!

Grant Beyleveld

2016-05

Pricey due to the captive market, but incredibly well stocked!

Ben Costa

2017-05

Amazingly well stocked...pretty much everything you need!

Linda Gottlieb

2016-05

Everything is so fresh. Sandwiches and salads,bread delicious.

Mark Okum

2020-05

Great store very high quality food

john brown

2019-05

Best grocer and butcher on all of fire island.