Secret Cubby

Over the Hill and Far Away

2024-05

We stop by this shop whenever we pass through Findley Lake. Shop has many vendors selling a wide range of vintage and antique items. You can easily spend an hour looking and not see everything. Nice place to find a unique gift, home decor or collectibles and worth a look the next time you are in town.

Caroline Sawin

2024-04

I’ve been wanting to check out Secret Cubby since it opened! Finally made it here and absolutely LOVED it! So many things to look at and such a neat and clean atmosphere. Nancy and her Staff were so welcoming and helpful. We’re already planning our next trip back :)

Natalie Herath

2024-04

Absolutely adorable! Multiple vendors and very decent pricing. The coffee shop inside is the perfect pick me up before diving into the treasures!

Vi Nguyen

2020-05

Absolutely love this place and Nancy. We always make sure to stop by this place during our stay in Erie. Everytime we do, there is always something new and interesting. For a couple bucks, you could even get some coffee or tea while you rummage through the goodies. The downside is we usually don't have enough space to bring large items back home with us to Cali.

Beth Smialek

2023-11

Over priced! even the coffee!! and they don't haggle which is half the fun of antiquing! Cute store though with variety. I suppose enjoy it while it's there nothing stays open for long in Findley lake.

Jub's Journey

2023-05

The sweetest little antique shop ever! Staff was kind, friendly, and helpful.

Jody Scott

2023-12

Fun place!!! Great selection and wonderful presentation!! Nice people!!! 5 stars!!

Michelle Shepler

2023-09

Great little antique store that is much bigger than you realize! Has a little bit of everything including a little coffee/beverage shop in the front of the store.

L Bednar

2022-05

Shop is laid out nicely and inventory is sizable. No MCM which is what I wanted. I found prices ran the gamet from reasonable to extraordinarily high, obviously based on different vendors business approach. Found one wooden box out on the porch that had obviously been there quite a while and seller wanted $38. Really? No, thanks.

Thomas Karapantso

2020-05

Pleasant and polite front desk will welcome you with a cheery hello. Clean store and variety of vendors. Two story building with fine wall art leading the way up the stairs. The store seems to be gearing more and more to the female shopper looking for decorator items.

Joe Torres

2018-05

The secret cubby is the place to be for that special thing your looking for , you May not know what your looking for but you'll come home with it because its there. Love this place and I can't wait to come back and the prices are antiques, They greet you the second you open the door like a lost family member.Love Secret Cubby 🤗

Connie Griffith

2019-05

I love Secret Cubby. I never leave there without finding some amazing treasure. Nancy the owner is great and very fun and helpful. Travel all the way from Ohio to visit this wonderful place.🤗😊

Jessica James Hedman

2020-05

I love love love this shop! Did I mention love? Find Dixie Belle Paints & Supplies and Prima RE.Design transfers too!Purple Peacock Candles have one of the strongest throws ever! Better than Yankee Candle. Purple Peacock also have two home decor booths and be sure to also check out a personal fav vendor #78! If youre a shabby chic magnolia farm kind of girl. Check this place out!

Fry Cake

2023-05

This is the best place for antiques I have found in the area. Great prices, great inventory and the owner is very nice. Visit if you get a chance.

Marcia Murphy

2023-05

I bought a used drill today for a project I am working on at home. Love this place and can always find lovely things.

Katrina Richerson

2021-05

I love this place. Nancy, and everyone who works there are wonderful people! There's so much to look at, I never go home empty handed. ❤️

chum chum

2020-05

The place was very nice very clean alot of antiques very expensive especially the tools that are just second hand not antiques had a few coins I was interested in but again very expensive twice as much as eBay or even gold and silver online stores tools were newer and it was actually cheaper to just go buy new ones so I did saved a bunch of money definitely go online and check prices first don't regret it later

Deborah Bovee

2020-05

Antiques, jewelry, collectables with a good cup of coffee and help from smiling Nancy. We love taking our time to look at everything in the many rooms.

Cathy Mason

2021-05

My daughters and I loved this little antique shop. Super cute and well kept. We'll definitely be back

Jackie Wise Wilson

2020-05

What a charming store! Much bigger than it looks. Could have spent all day browsing all of the rooms. Reasonable prices too.

Will L

2022-05

Friendly little spot, full of knick knacks that you can peruse while drinking a hot beverage from the coffee shop.

Frank Gocal

2021-05

Awesome place, never know what you will find, not to mention the awesome people behind the counter

Emily Boozel

2023-05

I always find something I love here and the prices are very reasonable!

Lydia Carey

2019-05

Many wonderful things to see and ponder! I never leave empty handed! Have my eye on a few things displayed at curbside!

Kyle Matsik

2021-05

Here is a table my husband made from pieces we bought at the cubby. Absolutely love this place. THE BEST!!!!!!!

Review Man

2022-05

Stopped here for the first time recently. Really cool place. Lots of stuff to see.

Kyle Hedderick

2023-05

Love love love this amazing find it truly is a secret cubby stuffed with all kinds of treasures

Alex Wenger

2017-05

Absolute lovely place, great things to look and buy and excelent coffe and granolas

ngarcias1

2023-11

Such a cute place!

Rock Dove Cycling Pidge

2021-05

Fun place to browse room by room. Friendly welcoming staff. Coffee too!