Alexander's

Ivy Velazquez

2023-09

It was really nice and the place was beautiful. The only negative thing was that the food took an hour and 10 minutes to be served. There were only two other people so it seemed to be a bit long but the food was great and the desert was amazing. So just go and be prepared to wait for a whileThe food is worth the wait

Tracy Maurer

2023-11

Chill restaurant right by the water. I was impressed by the variety of good quality food but mostly I was impressed with the allergy menu. I have egg and wheat allergy and was able to find a handful of options to choose from.The chef even came out to talk allergies to make sure I was good.Highly recommend the Baked Buffalo Shrimp Mac (gluten free)Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options

Andrew Eaglen

2023-09

Stopped in and had the Mac and cheese (regular) and the pretzel appetizer.The mac had good flavor, it was a bit thin and didn’t have that great cheesy ‘pull’ (my kid still gave it a thumbs up).Pretzel sticks were soft and cheese dip was good.Good location, sat outside on the deck with a view of the lake.

Michelle Shepler

2023-09

…More

Carmela H

2022-05

We drove 1 hour 20 minutes to check this place out and we were not disappointed! The pulled pork Mac n cheese alone was worth the drive! Pizza was really good something for everyone on the menu good portions, friendly staff, nice outdoor seating with a view of Findley Lake. We plan to revisit this restaurant in the future and try some of there other food.

Jacob Roth

2024-03

Very nice place. Been there a few times. The only problem is the water. I'm not sure what's going on with the tap, but it tastes a little murky and cloudy. The food though has always been superb. Decent service. I'd keep going back.

Ashlyn Hazlett

2023-07

…More

Barry LaCastro

2023-08

…More

Nelson Brodhead

2024-04

…More

Ca Leb

2024-01

I worked here over two months ago and still haven't received my paycheck. It makes sense now, why someone called during my interview, asking about a paycheck. I should've taken that as a red flag, along with the person that gave me my interview. He lied straight to my face about the job posting and then gaslighted me to try and pay me less.I'm currently waiting for the NYS Department of Labor to open up, so I can call to report wage theft by this establishment.All food is already prepared, they just warm it up for you. Sauces come from cans, ordered from their wholesalers. They make most of their own wing sauces, though. I have to give them that much credit, at least. Practically Nothing is made from scratch. They pride themselves on their markup system to make extra money at the expense of customers.

Heather LaGuardia

2020-05

Quaint rustic restaurant off main street on shadyside drive in findlay lake.Overlooking the lake with dirt lot parking that was plentiful. Upon entry to can find a seat at a regular take a higher table with barstool seats or the bar. We went for the cinco de mayo specials. The cheese dip was fantastic and very filling. Bring a large group as the portions are huge. Waitress was friendly and came to table to check in and make sure we didnt need a top up on the drinks a few times.Very nice spot. It was charming

Shirley Dougherty

2022-05

Great experience! Was traveling through the small town and decided to stop, for the best live music I’ve heard in a long time! Wonderful staff and outdoor seating. Reasonable prices!

Elisabeth Nicewonger

2018-05

Excellent, excellent, excellent! Wonderful service, and amazing food! Their tomato soup was the BEST I have ever had, and their grilled cheese blew my mind! They took something simple and turned it into food art. Amazing! Even the fries were good. It's pricey, but it's delicious. 10/10! Try them for their lunch specials!

Cosmic Fitness, LLC

2023-11

Gluten and soy-free diner here. My wife, stepson, and I had dinner at Alexander's this evening, and we had a great meal! I knew that they had several gluten-free options on their menu, but I needed to ask our server, Mimi, if their cheese contained soy because I wanted to try the Findley Lake Stacker. She checked with their chef, and he confirmed that their cheese did contain soy. Therefore, I just ordered the Finley Lake Stacker without any cheese on a gluten-free bun, and the double Angus burger was cooked to perfection! Thank you once again Mimi, for checking with the chef, and we will be back, sooner rather than later!

Jay Miller

2023-11

I love chicken wings, but more specifically the sauces. This place has one of the best I’ve had. They call it Mount Rushmore. It’s got a little heat and a lot of flavor. It’s not as hot as I normally go for but any hotter and you’d lose something with this one. So tasty that I had to ask for extra to take home. I don’t live in the area but I’ll be back the next time I’m through.

Hoss Hubler

2022-05

Great food, beer, service and atmosphere. Good selection of drinks and draft beers. I highly recommend the mac n cheese.

Jake Jones

2023-08

…More

Custom Audio

2020-05

We stopped by for a quick bite and were pleasantly surprised. Atmosphere is comfortable and clean, the service was great. We had a burger and the stir-fry with chicken. Def will be back!

jenna arthur

2023-05

…More

Laura Peters

2023-09

…More

Aeterna Nox

2023-10

…More

Kendra Cole

2023-10

…More

Elissa Twigg

2023-12

…More

Dave B

2022-05

One of our favorite places to have lunch, sitting on the deck over looking the lake. Good food n friendly people.

Casey Meyer

2023-07

…More

Cassidy Brosious

2022-05

My husband and I decided on a small wedding this fall. Alexander’s was so accommodating to us! We changed our outdoor ceremony plans last minute to indoors on their heated porch, with dinner to follow. It was the perfect amount of space for our close family. They made us the perfect meal, cheese cake for dessert 😋 🏼We couldn’t have asked for a better place to have this celebration.Thank you so much Alexander’s!

Melena DeBoe

2023-05

Best reuben sandwich in the county hands down! Great atmosphere and friendly staff!

Julia Ahl

2023-07

I ate at Alexander’s on June 6th, and had an AMAZING experience. Memi, Melissa, and Molly were terrific. Ryann was OUTSTANDING, made the entire table laugh and have a fantastic evening. I would come back just for her again. I will definitely be dining her again, and bringing my family with me again. The fish bowls are outstanding !

Foodie Couple716

2023-10

Went here as a recommendation while attending the Harvest Festival. Drinks were great as well as service but the food- never again. We ordered the :Veggie Flatbread -Butter & garlic sauce, tomatoes, onions, mushrooms, and red peppers (note that ALL other flatbread stated they came with cheese. This did not which is why I order it.)Chicken Quesadilla -Served with lettuce, pico de gallo, and sour cream on the side. Topped with spicy aioli.Flatbread came out with heavy cheese, and the veggies looked like frozen particles.The Quesadilla was good enough until hubby dives into the Pico on the side and we both see a long black hair.Hubby is brown and I'm blonde. I sent my dish back back not requesting another and my husband's dish back after showing the waitress the black hair which she quoted "gross".We sent that away and asked for the bill. My dish got taken off as the menu as it does misrepresent the toppings and hubby got a whopping 15% off his dish which came out to less than $2 after a hair was found in it.I wouldn't have minded paying for the 4 drinks as they were great, but both dishes should have been taken off. Especially finding hair in the food.View of Findley Lake was great but there were no precautions to the massive amounts of yellowjackets which left us and other patrons, batting them away.The food trucks were better the next day than this.

Deborah Dean

2023-07

Menu described steak & cheese sandwich as Sliced steak. Steak was actually large chunks and extremely chewy and tough and over done. Would have been much easier to eat if the steak would have been thinly Sliced as described. The French fries were over done as well. The other dish that was served was a shrimp quesadilla which was great!