New York Bagel

eva michelucci

2024-04

i’ve gone here twice and gotten the açaí bowl both times haha. every bowl has the same base but you pick the toppings. they’re really good! if you ask for nutella, they put quite a lot of it. lots of granola in the açaí too. good quality fruit toppings. very filling! no complaints!Vegetarian options: They have a lot of sandwiches with meat but also plenty of food with none.Parking: usually enough room right in front of the cafe to park for free. i guess unless it’s extremely busy.

Richie Fellows

2024-05

This place is fantastic not only are the bagels delicious, but the staff is so amazing I went in on a Sunday morning to get bagels for myself and my co workers I ordered 18 bagels with a pint of cream cheese and they were so amazing and nice they went the extra mile and made them fresh for us!! These bagels are the closest you are going to get to a NYC bagel. What a great little shop! I will for sure be going back again!!

Nick B

2023-11

As good if not better than downstate (nyc) bagels. Great atmosphere and super fast and friendly service.Recommend the Vanderbilt sandwich and coffee is excellent as well!

Kaitlyn

2024-02

I get the gluten free bagel sandwiches and the acia bowl. The food and service is phenomenal!Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free and dairy free options

Breck Aspinwall

2024-02

…More

Nicholas DeLessio

2023-09

Food was good. Bagels were decent for the area and the coffee was excellent. The location/atmosphere seems to be nice as well.On the other hand, the service was slow. I think maybe they just needed to make a fresh pot of coffee, but they didn't tell us this up front. We were waiting for 15-20 minutes for just bagels and coffee with no indication as to why. It's not a problem if you have to put on more coffee, I'll wait for that no problem, but just a friendly heads-up would be appreciated.

Riya Acharya

2019-05

They have few very nice bagels. The space has a good spot with road side view. My kids favorite there is hot chocolate. The staff is young and active. A good bagel and coffee place in the town just at the main street.

Theodore Vogel

2024-01

…More

Maddie D

2024-03

…More

Melissa Fraley

2023-08

We loved it here. There are many options from breakfast to lunch (and bonus breakfast all day!! My favorite!) We came here twice and both times the food was really good, cooked quickly and the staff were very friendly. The bagels were tasty and warm and we'd definitely stop by here again next time we're in town.

The Three Edged Sword

2024-01

…More

Thomas Aukett

2024-03

…More

Amanda Pereira

2019-05

So glad we decided to come here on a whim. They have Açaí bowls served all day that are very delicious and bagel sandwiches made to order. I had a hard time deciding what I wanted because everything looked so yummy! Service was very prompt and kind in waiting/helping me decide what I wanted. Hope I can come back here soon for a bagel!

Scott Conroe

2023-05

I have coffee here almost every day. Great bagels made with Long Island water, good sandwiches and baked goods, friendly owner.

chickie haute

2023-08

Delicious gluten free bagels. Pet friendly. Good Sammy for less than $10. Supportive of local university and clean building. 10 stars if I could!

Kathryn Swartout

2023-05

I love NY Bagel and have been going since I moved to Cortland. Recently I've been having issues with my coffee orders. I ordered a cappuccino off of their 'Specials' list and I received it scorching hot, I burned the tips of the three fingers holding the hot coffee cup, the milk wasn't foamy like a cappuccino, it was just a burnt latte, and when I opened the cup, there was a thick film from the milk on top of the drink, not appetizing. Please train your baristas behind the counter correctly. This isn't the only time it's happened.

Richard Schafer

2023-06

We moved into western NY six years ago. We only get good bagels and hard rolls when we visit or people bring them. New York bagel has a decent deal so I ordered.We got them yesterday. Toasted up a Cinn/Raison today. OMG Im back home. Thank you NY Bagel.

Dean O

2023-07

Under construction so seemed a bit dark. Had a Begal with butter on one side cream cheese on the other. Definitely was lacking but I guess I wouldn't have expected them put back together.. was disappointed in the bagelUpdate... construction done! Still lots of noise from behind the counter.. made the meeting I was at hard to hear.. food about the same but seemed fresher this time

Frank Miller

2023-05

Came here on a Saturday for a quick breakfast. Ordered a breakfast burrito. There is an open kitchen so I could see my breakfast being made. The worker used the wrong dressing so the owner comes over and uses a brown paper towel to smear off that dressing from the egg and veggies and then throws the right dressing on and rolls the burrito back together... It was flat and not filling, not stuffed the way a burrito should be. Went somewhere else for an actual breakfast sandwich. never again.

Barbie Bex

2022-05

Placed a catering order on very short notice for 16 people. The manager was so friendly and more than happy to help out getting this order together. The sandwiches and bagel chips were amazing. They do more than just bagels. The sandwiches are upscale and simply phenomenal. Delicious!

Evan Czimback

2024-03

…More

Amy Schenck

2022-05

We came here on a whim after another local shop had a really long line and were pleasantly surprised! The coffee was delicious and they had a ton of different flavors. The breakfast sandwich was a generous size and very tasty. We saw about 5 other things on the menu that we talked about coming back to try. Will definitely return!

Michaela D

2023-10

Best place for a true bacon, egg & cheese. Breakfast burritos are amazing as well. Always delicious.

A. Mowry

2023-05

Coffee was amazing, breakfast sandwich was meh. Sandwich had frozen sausage, overcooked egg, bagel barely toasted so it didn't hold together well at all. Bf got some bottled grape juice that was very nearly wine, but had no expiration date on the bottle. Staff was curt and didn't give welcoming vibes. Waited 40 minutes for our order. Haven't tried the lunch or dinner options. The bagels we're great and the cream cheese was good. We'll probably try again another day.Tldr: but the bagels with cream cheese or the coffee. Avoid the breakfast sandwiches.

oconaddify

2023-05

Friendly staff and laid back atmosphere. They weren’t too busy when I went so that was nice. I got a tuna club on an everything bagel. It was tasty!

Meghan Slack

2021-05

Great place to grab breakfast or lunch. Their breakfast and lunch wraps are very yummy. The bagels aren’t the best in my opinion because they are kind of on the dry side, Price Chopper makes a better fresher bagel than NY bagel does. Overall though it’s a good place to get food. The customer service is always friendly!

R.J. Calale

2023-05

Best at everything! Real authentic New York bagels! Great sandwiches! Awesome coffee! Very friendly staff and owner. Locally owned, please support!

Jack Furlong

2023-05

New York bagel is a good spot to go to in a pinch but I would recommend other spots around Cortland before New York Bagel. I will say they do have great brownies if you wanted a sweet treat.

Nathanael Katsiane

2021-05

The staff are super friendly, they play good music, the bagels are good, they got good orange juice that's not from concentrate, and they got coffee mania coffee which is really good. I got a bagel w garlic & herb cream cheese, capers, lox, spinach and red onion. It was great! Thanks New York Bagel!

Ayden Smith

2022-05

Great bagels, plus they have cool funky flavors. Not only good service and bagels but smoothies and more stuff. This place loads the cream cheese up in the bagel just like you are hoping for, trust me.