Good As New

4.6 (148)

5499 US-62, Conewango Valley, NY 14726
(716) 287-2196

Claimed
Antique store

From the business

  • Small business

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Mike Miller

2023-09

Really enjoyed this place for antiques. Lots of variety overall. It's a close layout, so be careful moving around and with kids. Plenty of tools, signs, glassware, fishing, and hunting to choose from. The staff was helpful and will hold items for you if needed. I would highly recommend stopping by if you are in the area for a great antique experience.

Tara Grzasko

2021-05

This is the cutest little Antique shop! And its HUGE! Very reasonably priced! I got a miniature oil lamp that im in love with! I didn't have time to see everything I will definitely be back!

nick emery

2024-05

Place was amazing. Fairly priced stuff

Jeff Granger (Ranger Granger)

2023-08

We got a couple of things. Nicely sized place with dozens of dealers. Went on a hot day and it was a little steamy, but not unpleasant.Store is right on Rte 62 just off Rte 83. 20 minutes south of Fredonia or 20 minutes north of Jamestown. Worth the trip.

Jamie B

2023-05

AMAZING! Went in to browse, walked out $100 bucks poorer 😂 WORTH IT! My wife and I had an amazing time browsing.

R

2024-04

Nice little shop. Found some good deals. Almost always find something to buy

Kansas Ceasr

2023-07

Great little antique store here! Wonderful items, jammed packed with good finds at great prices! Worth a drive any day of the week! Sometimes on Saturdays they have a local garage sale/flea market,tho small worth it also. And I only live a half hour away, would drive here more!! ':)

Mike Greeley

2024-01

Wonderful visit today. Everyone found something that they wanted.

Amy Bly

2023-05

I love to browse in here. I find things that I have not seen in years. I usually add to my collection. And find unique gifts for friends!

Jay HoL

2022-05

More than 75 booths set up. A lot of tools, glass, old toys, fishing stuff, john degrees and other miscellaneous things.

4 Me

2022-05

I went to check this place out. It was ok. My only gripe was I cut out before going through the whole place. The 2 ladies at the counter were so loud. EVERY single person who walked out of the door they had a bad comment about and gossipped about the minute they walked out. You couldn't not hear what they were saying no matter what part of the building they were in.

denise L

2023-05

I just LOVE this place...GREAT prices and BETTER then Salamanca Antique Mall..staff are VERY FRIENDLY and NICE as well...their items changes constantly...You can go there twice a month and see something NEW each time....keep up the GREAT job 👍👍👍👍

Mark Langham

2023-05

Very knowledgeable friendy personal willing to help you locate items as well as give great suggestions.Prices are very reasonable !A wonderful place to experience...

Debra Bowman

2021-05

In Amish Country, we love to visit this antique store because of the size of it we end up spending literally, hours here. You must come here, you will find lots of treasures like we have. 🙂

Michelle Ford

2023-11

My boyfriend and I go there I get great deals lot of nice stuff antiques affordable

Tracy Shelanskey

2024-02

Cool second hand store 👍

Ash Britt (Hotpantz)

2021-05

This place is amazing! I could spend all day there! You can pretty much find anything! Staff is awesome !

Cathy Dietrich

2021-05

This place is loaded! Very organized with things old and new! Don't forget to look up and down, there's something in every nook and cranny!!

Bill Ellis

2020-05

Love the store!! Awesome prices, awesome staff. A ton of stuff you just can't find anywhere else!!!

Vivi Elstone

2021-05

Ok, folks, make sure you give yourself some time for this one, because it's stock full of stuff! Surely you'll find something you didn't know you needed here. Friendly staff, many vendors, lots of antiques, some not, amish interest, a great diversion.

Marie Clendening

2022-05

The place was fantastic, clean,neat bright and the 2 people working were so nice!! Will definitely go back,!

Susan Bradigan

2023-05

Fun place.nice people.

Cindy Joneson

2021-05

I love this place. All sorts of treasures. And the prices are fab!! Facebook. GOOD AS NEW CONEWANGO VALLEY

Gerald Hecker

2023-06

Large selection of unique finds at reasonable prices.

Klayton Peterson

2022-05

Excellent variety!!...with many local antiques ...Amazing Locsl Family Run Business....

Wally Eaton

2021-05

Friendly folks. Loved getting to talk to the one knife dealer. Will be coming back to shop some more.

Jamie Baldwin

2019-05

Awesome store! Lots of fun and unique items that are priced right!

Ralph Hammond

2021-05

I go there slot, since it has new owners,it seems like it has more to offer,nice place

Jennifer Crandall

2018-05

Excellent selection of gently used merchandise and antiques! Definitely worth checking out!

John Stoll

2019-05

The best a 5 star all the way lots of goodies top notch management friendly atmosphere

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 10 AM-5 PM
Wednesday 10 AM-5 PM
Thursday 10 AM-5 PM
Friday 10 AM-5 PM
Saturday 10 AM-5 PM
Sunday 12-5 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet