Nina's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Sydney Bennett

2024-03

…More

Barbara Pine

2023-10

My husband and I went to Nina's for my birthday. We started with mozzarella sticks and bruschetta. Marty had chicken parm and I had ravioli with a meatball. Bread and salad was served with all dinners. The food was good and plentiful. I took half of the bruschetta home. Prices were reasonable, service good. They do a booming business with takeout. Would go there again.

Sarah Marcellus

2024-02

…More

Wolfy Games

2023-11

We stopped in passing through the area . We requested lots of cheese on our pizza and the staff was super friendly and accommodating. Loved the small mom and pop feeling . There were tvs so we could watch college football and nice nostalgic music playing softly in the background. The pizza was great and so were the wings . Many staff members asked if we were happy . It was very relaxed and the food was fresh and delicious. I’m glad we found Nina’s! Definitely give it a try.Parking: Saturday night and not many cars in front of the building . We parked right outside the entrance.

Steve Stansbury

2024-04

Best pizza in Chittenango!Wings are good too, and I had a pizza roll last time.Looking forward to trying their Friday haddock fish fry!Friendly even when swamped with people!Reasonable prices. Get there early parking can be rough. But well worth the wait!!!A+++

Lucas Harrington

2024-05

…More

Michael Cutro

2023-11

…More

Joe Phelps

2024-04

…More

Frank Bumbolo

2024-01

Small dining area, very congested when you first walk in, people picking up orders, people waiting to be seated all together. We found a table and were promptly greeted by our server. The drinks and meal arrived promply. We seemed rushed as people were waiting to sit down, but our server never hurried us. Good food fair prices, and excellent service. Very limited parking.

Ryan REYNOLDS

2024-04

Ordered a pepperoni pizza for take out, said they'd have it ready in 20 mins told em i was about an hour out so make it for an hour from then. Exactly 1 hour and 5 mins later i showed up to pick up my food, and proceeded to wait another 45 mins, they never actually made it. The next time I ordered a calzone no ricotta got given a pretzel roll. When i called with concern that I may have recieved someone else's order, I was promptly informed that a calzone without ricotta isn't a calzone and that the pretzel roll was what I meant to order ... no refund no nothing, and finally had a ninas gift certificate decided to take my folks out to dinner. Only to be told they would not accept the gift certificate because it was more than half the bill. Blown away by this I left the 50$ gift certificate one the table with two 20s and I'll never go back. You want good pizza and service go to chittenango pizza instead of this trap.

Christopher Graham

2021-05

Stopped on way through. Got speciality slice, slice cheese, drink and roll or whatever they called it. Taste of specialty was really good. 6.2 on that. Cheese slice 4.6 and roll 5.9 cost $19.00 expensive I think. Sauce on regular slice and to dip in wasn't that great but ok overall. Just can't believe cost that much to eat there.

Stan Deminski

2024-05

…More

J J

2020-05

Taste great, the best pizza in town. Service is great, friendly and quick. Interior design is good. Small dining area. Bathroom is clean.

Jeanne Albrecht

2024-03

…More

Karl Anderson

2024-01

…More

Shawn G

2023-10

…More

Charlie McDonald

2023-11

I tried taking my girlfriend to Nina’s for the first time based on a recommendation from a friend. We arrived and the space was small, and there was no organization on where to wait. There was a high-school aged worker who looked like they were doing the job of a server, host, and bus-person. They were finally ready to seat people, and before I could even speak up to point out a couple who arrived before us, the woman working behind the counter was incredibly rude and snarky. She exclaimed that we weren’t there first (which we knew we just had no idea where to stand in the small space). We took our business elsewhere and had an incredible dinner regardless. Would not recommend going to Nina’s for dinner.

Ronald Verwij

2022-05

Service was quick and friendly. Nice selection of pizza slices. Got some wings with it. Wings are nice and crispy and sauce is not too hot.

Rose Bowers

2023-11

…More

Crystal Trostle

2023-06

My daughter and I stopped in for a quick lunch after going the wild. We just got slices but the pizza tastes amazing. The staff was friendly and it's a nice little restaurant, we plan to go back next week sometime. And she grabbed a piece of chocolate cake which we ended up bring home it's delicious.

Shirley Volk

2023-08

Am I surprised? We are just here in the summer time and have eaten here several times but usually have ordered pizza but tonight I order the special, spaghetti and meatballs. Oh my heavens. There are two Italian Restaurants I love. One in Florida, Italian Cousin in Sebastian, amazing food and here is Spaghetti Factory at Silvan Beach. Both are incredible Italian food but here we are not 2 miles from Nina’s and I have to say their spaghetti and meatballs are absolutely beyond delicious. My Mom had their cheese filled tortellini with Alfredo sauce. SUBERB ! My husband had the haddock in a marinara sauce. He loved it. Had very reasonable bottles of wine. Needless to say we have leftovers for dinner tomorrow night. Could not believe the portions My new favorite Italian restaurant. Our waiter is on the ball. Very accommodating. Service was slow but not waiter fault. Also most of food is fresh made so the wait is worth it.

Holly Mann

2023-10

…More

Gerald Martin

2023-11

…More

Ronald Singleton

2023-12

…More

Ashley Hansen

2023-05

Good food but awful planning management. We ordered days in advance for our daughters birthday party. We arrived for pickup time and it had not even been started. With such a big order at the time we were looking for it we were stuck waiting with no other options. We quoted 8 minutes and ended up waiting closer to 20. We got a very insincere apology and a huge bill for undercooked pizza that made us late. If they were at the very least honest about the wait time I would have made alternative arrangements. Very disappointed, we have been loyal customers for years.

Marina Roman

2023-08

We ordered a pizza pie with half pepperoni, when it got to the table it was a whole pie with pepperoni so I had to pick off the pepperoni for my kids. Ordered a side of spaghetti with meatballs, it came with 1 meatball and cost the same as a full entree. The worst was the pizza… the cheese was so thick it wasn’t edible along with the floppy crust. The sauce was delicious I must say. Garlic knots were good.Our waiter was great.

Matthew Young

2023-05

Very delicious food and generous portions! The linguini pesto was amazing!

Blossom Farmhouse

2023-05

…More

Jordan Sgroi

2023-05

The pizza itself was pretty good. There was a delay on the pickup of my order. When I came in to get the food, I noticed they had just put my pizza in the oven. Maybe they forgot about the order? Not sure, but I had to wait 20 minutes when I showed up after the time they said it would take to complete the order.I thought the pizza was pretty good, will order again, hopefully won't have to wait around as long the next time.

Abdoulaye Halilou

2023-05

Sausage & shrooms for takeout. Tastes good.. I'll try their other pizzas soon