DeMario's Eatery

Terri Jones

2023-05

Tried Demario’s for the time per someone’s suggestion. Upon walking in a customer was telling us how good everything is. The service was great (we only got baked goods and coffee at counter) but the 2 ladies at the counter were helpful and friends. We ordered $2 cinnamon buns and 2 apple crumb cake slices and a chocolate chip cookie for $20. Then we decided on 2 chai teas to go with them ( those were very good) we took our stuff to chittenango falls to eat and I have to say the cream cheese frosting on the cinnamon bun was very good, the cinnamon bun itself wasn’t anything special and was underdone inside. My 2 year old liked his cookie though it was very soft and fell apart as he tried to eat it. We ate the apple cake later on, its appearance looked very underdone, when eating it the topping was excessive and kind of dry. Barely any apple in it. It was alright, my sister loved it when she tried it and my kids thought it was good. My husband and I could do without next time. But I would try and eat there sometime. The food looked very good and I still want to try a half moon, they looked great!

J M

2024-01

…More

Rich Blouin

2024-04

…More

Tim VanBenschoten

2018-05

My family and I went to DeMario's for dinner and had a great experience. The homemade deli food is delicious and the staff handled 10 of us with no problem. I'll be coming back for a sandwich and a brownie very soon.

John Tresohlavy

2023-11

…More

Susan Napierala

2023-05

I ordered 5 dozen half moon cookies with only two days notice. The cookies were amazing! They provided extra frosting so I could add "90" in a different color for a birthday party. The cookies ALL went and everyone raved about them. Great service and great baked goods!

Christina Centner

2020-05

Delicious burgers, fries, sandwiches and baked goods. Awesome customer service!! Pecan cinnamon rolls yummy!

Mike Rendino

2023-05

Staff were super friendly. The Shrimp Po Boy and assortment of fresh scratch made cookies were incredible. DeMario's will be a regular eatery option for us. And...they have Jamaican Me Crazy Coffee!!! Can't wait to try thier cinnamon rolls on Wednesdays!!!!Parking: Lots of open parking on the side of the building

Comedian CountryboiEfudge Jones

2024-01

…More

Camellia Trotter

2018-05

Really cute little place for excellent lunchtime food. Staff is very friendly and very helpful. The sandwiches are large and the chips are delicious. The French fries are very good as well. The Mac and cheese was a little overdone and on the mushy side, but was still tasty (I mixed in the kettle chips from my sandwich). I wish they did have a few more vegetarian options, but I made due with a grilled cheese which was very tasty. The dining room is nice with a seat yourseld arrangement. Staff brings you your food after ordering and are very friendly in making sure everything was good. Would definitely return!

Kelly Willette

2021-05

I have yet to be able to eat inside there, but I’m sureit’s just as good as all her baked goods are.Last year wanted to try some Xmas cookies,They were amazing.I’ve never cared for almond paste until I had hers.Last week at their window we asked if they were openTake out for now.But I saw these huge cookies, of course I bought some.The sugar cookie had to weigh a few pounds, no doubtThe raspberry/almond, I can’t explain how delicious itWas.Go get some for yourselves, you’ll never be disappointed

Jeffrey Miller

2018-05

Spacious and clean! Good quality meats are used. I eat here once a week and have never had a bad experience. They also have some amazingly delicious home made cookies, brownies and half moons.

Angela R Kirsch

2023-05

Love the food, but it seems like the portions aren't as big and the price has almost doubled. Probably the supply chains fault but over $70 for three lunches (no cookies either) seemed a bit much.

Jessica Lewis

2020-05

Burgers and fries were delicious!

Camille

2017-05

Very calm, welcoming atmosphere. Turkey was amazing, the side of chips were surprisingly tastey. The 1/2 moon cookies are fluffy, chewy and delicious. Highly recommend going here for lunch or dinner if you're craving a sandwich

rebecca brown

2023-11

…More

Lynne Joncas

2023-05

Great food and friendly staff. Take out order ready in time.

Mary Lynne Graham

2020-05

We ordered two pounds of Italian cookies to share with family on Xmas Eve. They were very fresh and delicious! Best we have ever had!!

Alan Williamson

2024-04

…More

Mike Sloan

2023-06

…More

Justin H

2022-05

Great staff and had a delicious filet of fish with some of THE BEST tartar sauce I've ever had. Nice cozy little restaurant

S Fleming

2023-09

…More

James Rasmussen

2018-05

Their interior is very nice hardwood floors well decored their broccoli cheddar soup was SO GOOD Philly steak was fantastic and the wife loved her meatball sub. Plan to have a little extra time or call ahead because they had non stop traffic thru during our meal. A great addition to the real food options in the Chittenango area!

McKenzie Allen

2022-05

Demario’s has always been a favorite since they’ve opened. They have a very friendly environment and staff and they have amazing food!! Always a top choice for lunch/dinner

Nick Casso

2022-05

In the area for family vacation. Was recommended this place from staff at the wild animal park. This place is amazing! Home made bread,home made crisps. Everything was delicious.

Liz Warner

2018-05

DELICIOUS!! Will pretty much make whatever kind of sub/sandwich you want, as long as they have the ingredients. Their food is always fresh and consistent, you'll always know what you are getting, every time. Definitely recommend and a must try. P.S. you have to try the pistachio cannolis!

erin gilbert

2019-05

Always fresh clean and quaint. My Pop's and I go on the regular. The staff friendly and amazing. Definitely a great soup salad and sandwich shop.

H.A. Burhans

2021-05

I absolutely love this place because on top of great food that they serve they also do their own baked goods The cookies and other things that they prepare are absolutely delicious there are credit to the community of Chittenango and they are a very nice bunch of people

TODD RUSS

2024-03

…More

Randall Sanderson

2020-05

This was tthe first time my wife and i had been in DeMarios and honestly we are glad we went in. From the amazing greeting we got as soon as we walked in, the continued hospitality, the delicious meals, and the affordable prices, and dont even get me started on the amazing homemade pastries....this restaurant has a home town feel that we will definitely be going back.