Brooklyn Pet Supply

Stuart Davis

2024-03

We get crickets for our gecko here. The staff are awesome; always a pleasure to see (even when the crickets didn't work). All of the employees are great--particularly the younger guy with the metal band t-shirts. You can also tell that the animals in the store are very well-treated.

Andrea Metivier

2024-05

The staff here are wonderful, I had a lovely conversation about my new crested gecko that put my anxieties at ease and answered some questions I had. They have a great selection for pets other than dogs and cats, though of course there’s lots of that too. They also carry live insects and even springtails and isopods for bioactive tanks.

Debra Coppola

2024-04

Staff was very knowledgeable about Betta fish and very welcoming. Had Betta fish in glass bowls and they looked ver healthy. My Betta fish I bought there is doing fine and looks very healthy . Would buy from them again

Jade J

2024-01

Literally one of the best local pet stores. The shop is small but mighty as they carry so many things. Extremely kind and friendly staff, very knowledgeable and ready to help. New go to spot!

Samin Kandoth

2023-05

Very friendly and helpful people. Helped me build a home for my Betta fish. Quite a lot of items here are cheaper than Petco. Definitely coming back.

Saida . . .

2023-05

One of the workers there gave me and my friend an amazing experience at the Brooklyn Pet Shop. My friend was looking to buy a pet rat and he allowed us to feed them and pet the rat. He let us hold a Bearded Dragon as well as showed us how to and what to feed it. I went back to buy food for my cats and I definitely recommend going here.

Rich Jagusiak

2024-02

Small place but packed with plenty of stock. Helpful too

Kim Friedman

2022-05

The staff has been so helpful in advising us on our fish, and we've been really happy with the new fish we purchased. They've gone out of their way to demonstrate how to clean our tank and acclimate a new fish. So grateful to have this local shop with knowledgeable and friendly staff, it's a rare occurrence these days.

Emma Diaz

2023-05

This place is amazing! The staff are obviously very experienced and educated, and they are so helpful. They have helped me with my young ball python so many times, they never fail to do so. Always come here for anything I need pet related.

Sami Ahmad

2023-05

So I want to preface that this review is in no way an attack on those who work at the store. They were misinformed and genuinely upset about the situation. I purchased a Cockatiel, and the Bird was around 500+ dollars. Now you would expect a bird in that price range to be very young, and the employees there were told that the Bird was young. Sadly after two months, the Bird was acting very strange, and I had to rush it to the emergency room vet clinic, and the shocking news I found was the Bird was born in 1993, THATS 29 YEARS OLD! I was, of course, dumbfounded by this discovery. The vet discovered many issues with the Bird, failing organs, chronic breathing infection, and many other problems. Sadly, the Bird was on its way out, so we had to euthanize him. I wanted a refund because you don't sell a dying bird for 500+ dollars. The employees at the time were very nice and genuinely understood my situation and wanted to help, but the manager was the main issue in all of this. Not only did he not want to provide a refund, but he also began shifting the blame to the people who gave them the Bird and said that because it's been two months, I wouldn't be given a refund. I was utterly dumbfounded. How does a manager of a PET STORE not know where their PETS are coming from?? I left upset, and now not only did I lose 500 dollars, but I have an empty 400-dollar cage and a broken family who grew attached to this bird.

Leah Fogelson

2023-05

One of the workers was very nice as he had offered me and my friend to pet and hold some of the animals. Also there are a lot of different kinds of animals as well as very nice supplies for the animals.

T Shells

2023-05

Great neighborhood pet shop. For such a small space, it carries a surprisingly large variety of pet foods and various supplies. Staff is consistently attentive and helpful. 👍

Siobhan Odonnell

2023-11

Great variety of products for all pets. Knowledge staff.

Isabelle Caffero

2020-05

My absolute favorite pet shop in Brooklyn! Out of all the shops I’ve been to, I’ve never met a more helpful and kind group of employees! I go here whenever I’ve got any issue with my goldfish and not only do they help me solve the problem, they do so with genuine care and concern. A wonderful little establishment that I recommend to any pet owner.

jfornasar

2021-05

I bought a large school (55 !!! ) of Cardinal Tetras and five juvenile Discus... all doing great.

Joseph Mullaney

2022-05

I have always considered this former Petland, as the best pet store in the neighborhood, as far as selection of dry goods, for dogs and cats, but what is unique and impressive is their selection of small mammal supplies, and reptile/amphibian food and supplies. Most pet stores throughout the city are 99% cat and dog centric, so as a reptile enthusiast, I'm very happy that they have the selection that they do in Bay Ridge. If they weren't there I'd have to drive to petco or petsmart almost every day!!

Aidan Barreto

2023-06

We were being followed from the moment we entered then once we started looking for something our bird needs this one lady built like a ostrich told us not to steal when we weren’t and used inappropriate language we are minors and had a little kid of 10 who got scared

Thomas Wilkinson

2020-05

Wow! Brooklyn Pet Supply is certainly a cut above the rest! Now I come here for all my pet needs! The staff makes you feel like family. Definitely the best pet store in Brooklyn!

Taso Aquariums

2020-05

long term establishment with a new owner and a smile, up & coming freshwater fish with some rare gems. Feeders, crickets & live foods... dog / cat/ bird / reptile supplies. will special order. nice store.

Leonard Crispino

2020-05

Great ! well stocked pet store with good prices , owners and staff treat you like family and take a genuine interest in their customers . . Best pet shop around , always look forward to going there . . .

Patricia Murakami

2021-05

I’ve ordered three tags from Brooklyn Pet Supply now and I’ve never been disappointed. They have the highest quality engraved tags at the lowest price.

Jason Portney

2022-05

Great shop with knowledgeable employees. They took the time to really help me understand what I needed for my new reptile pet!

Laura Esquivel

2023-06

Nice store bought fish food at a good price. They have pets in the back.

J. C.

2022-05

I like this place..Sure there are bigger pet stores but not in the neighborhood and they pretty much have what you're looking for.. Staff is great and knowledgeable.

Rico

2021-05

Good prices, friendly staff...only issue I'm surprised that they are holding fish NOT FOR SALE (Corecats). I understand stand holding a fish or two but a bunch of them 15 or more of them...Come On.....

Madeline Husmann

2021-05

I impulsively bought a bird from them, only to realize that having it in the same enviornment as my cat was a horrible idea. They were way nicer about the situation than they needed to be, and gave me a full refund.

Ruhma Ahmed

2020-05

Very nice! staff are very nice, kind and personable! Lovely environment with awesome products. Excellent pet store!

tony batistano

2023-05

Great shop with great people. I love coming here and enjoy being a regular.

Anastasios “Taso” Theodosiadis

2024-04

Bad vibes

Antonio Pullano

2020-05

Amazing store, knowledgeable staff, welcoming environment. I'm so happy that they're still going strong in the neighborhood 😁