Feed Barn

4.6 (172)

1515 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509
(845) 278-2392

Claimed
Pet supply store

From the business

  • Small business

Service options

  • Delivery

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Suki Hushion

2024-02

Love these guys. Best prices around. Even though we live in Florida now we still stock up on exotic bird food and treats whenever we’re in town visiting the kids. If it’s not on the shelf in the store they have it for me within the week. Products are always clean and fresh. Better than Amazon & Walmart.

Robyn Musicant

2024-03

The best service, great products- and a truly unique selection of gift items. Love this place!

Katie Bates

2023-12

Love the Feed Barn been going here for years, they always have everything I needed, reasonably priced.

Justin Braun

2024-03

Amazing selection, and amazing customer service!

Phil Ferry

2021-05

Employees here are super nice and super helpful. Very rarely do they ever not have whatever it is I'm looking for. As far as pricing goes, things are moderately priced so you won't find the deal of a lifetime here but isn't your animal or animals worth every penny? I live in Connecticut and travel across three towns as well as driving past two different competitor stores that rhyme with "flag day" just to get to the Feed Barn so that definitely should be noted. If you've never been then I highly recommend checking them out.

Scottie Mac

2022-05

The best people. The best prices the most quality products and food. Not to mention the Great service and kindness. Don't bother going anywhere else for your fur family. These folks have it all

Jean Logan

2022-05

Anything I need so far so good I have found it here! When other pet supply stores have fell short, not a grand selection of litter boxes, but has my choice of cat litter and cat food fully stocked when I need it. Other stores it will take 5 days and I’d have to order it special. But cat food, cat litter and cat treats, this place is # 1 on my to go to list! Thank you feed barn for always coming though!

Mama Sheepdog

2019-05

Family owned business. Only 2-3 people working there, none of them are particularly friendly - you're sorta on your own at finding things. The merchandise is not well organized or displayed - dog items are spread out all over the store - not a lot of cat stuff. No special orders on items like dog coats - plus dog coats were sold out before it even got cold and there were no more coming in. I've pretty much stopped going there because they almost never have what I need.

Callum Costello

2013-05

I adopted my cat from here. I haven't been here in a long time but I cant believe the reviews. I work in the pet industry and I have to say that the people working here, that I spoke to, were extremely knowledgeable about animals, especially live stock. The prices are great and the people were nice so I would definitely recommend this place to anyone.

Lisa Vannais

2018-05

The family that runs this is amazing. I would never go any place else. Their prices are excellent but the customer service they give to each and every person who walks through their door cannot be matched. I love this store.

EFK

2019-05

Going here for years. Everything I need for our animal friends. Reasonable prices. Very helpful service. They can bring your purchase to your vehicle. Good local business that i like to support because they are good at what they do !

Debbie Paravati

2019-05

I love the Feed Barn! What a great store! Reasonable prices, good selection of products, and the lovely ladies that work there are the kindest and sweetest people! They are like family to me, and great to talk with every time I go there!

Larry Mintz

2016-05

This is a 1st class pet store that is owned by people who not only really care about animals, but are 1st class people. They are always willing to help and recommend what is best for your pets, not necessarily the most expensive solution. We have 2 Boxers and we spend a lot of money on their food and well being. We drive 25 minutes to the Brewster store and do not think twice about going some place closer.

Jeannine Hannum

2015-05

I buy all my kitty litter, cat food and cat toys at The Feed Barn. They have decent prices and the service is good. I also feel strongly about supporting independent businesses and will always opt for shopping at a nice, humble place such as this one over a big fancy chain store any day!

In My World

2022-05

I like Feed Barn Brewster. Great prices from A-Z. Friendly staff. My go to for a variety of rotating name brand wet foods and some staple brands to feed my finicky cats.

Isabeau France

2016-05

The family and employee's are great ...if they don't have something in they will order it right away. They carry the best quality outside bird food and inside birds ...and now there getting us Island Treat Bird Food it"s made fresh a family business. They make a Garden mix or a Fresh Fruit/Nut mix, yogurt treats and fresh made honey nuts. Package in double bags for freshness! JBW

Patricia Pascale

2017-05

Phenomenal prices for all pet food needs and phenomenal service. Staff always willing to help and order things in if they don't have it. Wouldn't go any place other than this place. Thank you!!

Win G

2020-05

The staff and owners here are always so friendly. They also have a wonderful selection of food and supplies at great prices. Best of all...no mistreated betta fish!

Wonderful Life

2015-05

Staff is unpleasant. Bought an item to store dog food, discovered it was too big, brought it back the next day WITHOUT being used. This was a purchase for almost $40. They wouldn't refund our credit card after a less than 24 hour purchase. They gave a gift certificate back, and even when told that we don't appreciate a refund of a gift certificate because it's forcing the way a person spends his/her money, the person made a comment that since we spend about $200 in the store per month, we shouldn't care. This is POOR customer service in a community where news travels fast. You want business, be respectful. Refund money when a person makes a return. You don't care about losing business? Fine. We don't care about telling people how you treat your customers. We were never informed of this store policy dictating a gift certificate for a return, and after that certificate is used, we will NEVER SHOP AT YOUR STORE AGAIN and we will NEVER have anything nice to say because it's not the first time a person has been nasty at that store. They got their money from our credit card and held onto it. They took OUR money and didn't give it back when we made a return. Unreal...bet the owner wouldn't like someone taking money out of his/her pocket and having someone dictate whether he/she could have it back after returning an unused item. You got your item back, where's my money? I'm forced to shop at a place that I have zero respect for and want to give no further business to - SHOP SOMEWHERE ELSE WITH PEOPLE WHO VALUE YOUR BUSINESS - THIS STORE COULD CARE LESS ABOUT RESPECT, CUSTOMER SERVICE, AND GIVING YOUR MONEY BACK TO YOU! The staff has been repeatedly nasty, and we shopped there because it was convenient, but I have ZERO problems with taking my business to a place that gives a refund when one is due with a staff that can be pleasant to customers and value their business. I hope other customers come to discover what so many of us have witnessed regarding your treatment of people in this community.

Erika Tremblay

2022-05

This is my go to for my favorite cat food and toys. The prices are great but the people are the best around. Easily one of my favorite places in town. 😻

ERA Triano

2019-05

#birdseed and more... Pet food and supplies, cat condos!! Competitive prices, helpful professional staff, carryout service, will load your car even (great for those heavy feed bags). I don't get there nearly enough!

William Cervantes

2022-05

Very friendly staff always have what I'm looking for and if not they can special order it. Fairly priced as well!

Thom4114

2023-05

I love love love this place and the owner's are great people!! Always going above and beyond for their customers. Shop local!!!

Robert Reilly

2020-05

Our pets are well fed and cared for because of The Feed Barn. Very helpful, friendly staff, and quality supplies for the four-legged (or winged) members of your family.

Gary Shultz

2018-05

Best pet supply store in the area. Excellent prices excellent service and if they don't have it they'll get it for you. Everyone there is so knowledgeable and helpful.

Kathy Jankowski

2021-05

Best selection of wild bird food and bird feeders that I have ever seen. Almost any kind of pet food and pet toys you need including rabbits, parrots and chinchillas. Friendly staff.

Gloria Rotunda

2021-05

They're friendly and helpful. And their products, especially dog food, costs less than some other pet stores.

Fran Guertin

2020-05

Very different from most Italian restaurants. We we're a party of 3, all our meals were absolutely great. Service was very good.

Mike “4MOTION” J

2020-05

Good selection wide variety of toys and treats good pricing compared to elsewhere. Just didnt have any dog knuckle bones or anything similar that I was looking for.

Susan Liotta

2019-05

I love this family owned pet store and I love the family too! There pricing is so fair, no better than fair, the pricing is excellent! I love love the Feed Barn!!

Opening Hours

Monday 9:30 AM-7 PM
Tuesday 9:30 AM-7 PM
Wednesday 9:30 AM-7 PM
Thursday 9:30 AM-7 PM
Friday 9:30 AM-7 PM
Saturday 9 AM-6 PM
Sunday 10 AM-5 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet