Guppy's Restaurant & Tavern

Michelle Arroyo

2024-04

…More

Kay P

2024-04

We stopped here for dinner during our eclipse road trip and we were very impressed! Everyone was so nice and they gave us glasses. Their eclipse drinks were great also. Their fish fry though was one of the best I’ve had! Crab dip was also very good! They also gave my husband his meal for free because he is military which is so sweet!

Etta Miller

2023-11

…More

Alex Cheng

2023-05

Came here for Father’s Day, and at first glance it was very busy but they had a beautiful outside bar and large tent for people to sit under and wait for their table. Although it was a holiday, it was definitely a really long wait to be seated, then to order, and lastly to wait for the food.I appreciate the owners of the business trying to be transparent about inflation and rising prices where they have this giant yellow sign on every page of the menu about rising costs. For a bar/tavern kind of vibe restaurant (since the dining area is surrounded on both sides by a bar), the prices were still more than I expected especially given the taste of the food.However, I thought the food would match it but unfortunately I had the really long named menu item “Roasted Red Pepper & Tomato Pesto with Chicken”. There was no red nor tomato tasted in this dish or pepper, and I was told that its a homemade sauce which really surprised me. I’ve actually had this sort of sauce in a different style of cooking and I definitely don’t think it should go into this kind of dish and it was really heavy/oily when the “sauce” was separated from the penne home noodles.The sea crab dip did cost the same as an entrée but they definitely nailed it with the large-sized, crispy and soft chips.The service and waitresses were phenomenal and even asked about switching out the dish I had for something else. This would’ve been a better experience if I had chosen a different dish in the beginning.

Thomas Sniadecki

2024-04

Absolutely our favorite spot to stop on our way to salmon fish on lake Ontario. We have gotten to know the owners and they never disappoint, they treat us like family and food is off the charts good. Highly recommend giving Guppys a try. See you guys in July, can't wait !!!Parking: Front and back parking.

Sally Truong

2023-08

…More

Wes Howell

2024-04

…More

Dylan Craven

2024-02

Here from out of town for a snow trip, the food and service was absolute phenomenal, even though they were packed they killed it.Back to the food, we got the hawg wings. Best dang thing I've ever had in my life. Literally fall off the bone perfect. This will be our new go to spot when we're in for the winter.

J B

2023-05

The best place to eat in town. Delicious food and fun drinks. Service is quick but you should get there as close to opening as possible if you don’t want to wait. Weekends are busy! Pizza is great. Highly recommend!

D O

2024-03

…More

Aimee Young

2024-01

…More

Laura Rudnicki

2024-04

…More

Aaron Haug

2023-06

…More

Paul Ditrich

2023-05

What an absolute gem of a place! I was searching for a new place to eat that I never been to and this place caught my eye. When you arrive at this tucked in location, you're greated with a big smile and friendly staff. Intrigued by the ski gondola, we took a table in on of these. What a fun experience! It's private and unique. Decorated with cool stickers, blinky lights and your own Bluetooth speaker, it was so unique and we absolutely loved the experience. I would say it would fit 4 adults comfortably. They are a bit tight to get in and out but not too bad. Our drinks where great (with bobas!) And the food was absolutely fantastic. Besides the gondolas, there were tables for larger groups. It was a fun date night and we will be returning. Kudos to the owners for being a little unique and maintaining a high level of quality. We will be back.

Jeff Depew (JD)

2023-05

…More

Julie Krone

2023-09

…More

Jason Buitrago

2023-05

Started with some of the best mussels I've ever had. Absolutely delicious! Then, ordered the Buffalo Chicken Salad because I had been craving it for several weeks and per usual it didn't disappoint. Loved the texture, flavor, and the entire combination. The Western NY'er in me was very happy. Literally the best salad I've ever had! Our server/bartender Lauren was awesome and super attentive despite having a full house! Can't wait to go back!

Matthew Covert

2023-05

…More

Alice Francis

2023-10

…More

send info

2022-05

Super great place! Service was great! Food was great! A totally great experience! The gondola was really cool for wife & I to eat in.Thre loaded nachos were quote good yummy and quite large! Wife had a calzone and I had the dag wood. Both were also quite good!

Bobbie Paterniti

2024-01

…More

Dale VanVlack

2024-03

…More

Peter Adler

2024-04

…More

jessica radtke

2023-08

My husband and I were staying nearby and needed somewhere to eat dinner. We happen to come across Guppy's and couldn't have had a better experience. Even in the middle of a storm, the staff did an excellent job checking on us in the gondola. The food and drinks were all amazing (loved the fish tacos & Guppy bowl!) and we were so impressed by the overall atmosphere! We can't wait to come back when we are in the area!

Jessica James Hedman

2023-10

I used to come here all the time when I was a younger kid in the summer when we went to the lake house. (30 years ago)Decided to take a drive out randomly tonight and we are so glad we did.The owner is one of a kind. Took care of us from the outside waiting area when there were no tables and an hour wait. She got us apps and water and she was absolutely fantastic. We didn’t get to stay for dinner since the baby was getting fussy but we were absolutely thrilled with the service we received while we were there. Short staffed and they still were excellent to us! Highly recommending this place!

Jennifer Davis

2024-04

First timers went for our "date night" It was nice having someone else cook. The food and drinks were great. Service was good. My husband had the rib special and loved it. I had a grilled Buffalo chicken sandwich that was great too. It was on garlic bread, which was amazing.Went back again. Was good. Tried out the ski gondula, that was fun. The pizza is amazing 😍Parking: Tight but enoughKid-friendliness: Sure

Tom Sniadecki

2024-02

…More

Gail Zachary

2023-10

My husband had the best beer battered fish fry and I had the :"To die for" Crispy Asian Wrap. All the staff were friendly and efficient. Ou can tell they're treated well. The owner had a smile on her face throughout the evening and sne knows what people want...good food, plenty of it and at an affordable price. The owner is amazing! Atmosphere is home town. We WILL be back!

Stacey Harris

2022-05

UPDATE: Guppy's Restaurant & Tavern owners Doug & Christy reached out and apologized for the poor experience my husband and I had on March 12. They sent us a gift card as well. Hopefully we’ll be able to get back to NY soon!I’ve been going to Guppy's Restaurant & Tavern since I was a kid. Every summer my family would rent a cabin in Chautauqua, NY and inevitably we’d end up at Guppy’s for dinner one night. I’ve passed this tradition down to my sons, who have enjoyed their fair share of Guppy’s Stromboli. So imagine my disappointment when my husband and I visited this past Saturday (March 12) for lunch only to be seated and ignored for 20 minutes. We watched two tables arrive AFTER us and be SERVED. No waitress ever looked our way. We didn’t even get glasses of water. No the restaurant wasn’t swamped. We arrived shortly after they opened that afternoon. We walked out and took our business elsewhere. Disappointed & heartbroken. Guppy’s used to be our “go to” when we were in town. I’ll think twice next time.

Dan Williams

2024-05

…More