Bayville Seafood

4.9 (56)

18 Ludlam Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
(516) 628-0328

Claim this business

Seafood market

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Bill A. Aucone

2024-01

Perfect experience every time. The fish is always fresh and the jumbo shrimp is amazing. The prepared dishes are tasty and perfectly prepared.

Rich Cutler

2023-05

The absolute freshest seafood around. they are friendly, accommodating, and full-service. It is run by a great local family. We are so lucky to have them in our town. I have used them for catering and for my home.

Dorota Huczek

2024-04

Amazing food, great people and service! Really such a great experience.

robert meshechok

2024-01

Nestled along the shimmering shores of Bayville, Bayville Seafood stands as a beacon of gastronomic excellence, inviting patrons on a captivating journey through the depths of culinary brilliance. As a devout lover of seafood, I recently had the privilege of immersing myself in the symphony of flavors orchestrated by this extraordinary establishment.From the moment I crossed the threshold, I was enveloped in an ambiance that seamlessly blended sophistication with a relaxed coastal charm. The soft hum of ocean waves, meticulously curated decor reminiscent of a chic seaside retreat, and an attentive staff that embodied warmth and professionalism—all conspired to create an atmosphere that felt both refined and inviting.Now, let's delve into the pièce de résistance—the cuisine. Each dish presented bore testament to the restaurant's commitment to sourcing only the finest, freshest catches from the ocean's bounty. The seafood, undoubtedly the star of the show, was prepared with an artistry that showcased both respect for the ingredients and an unwavering dedication to culinary innovation.The oysters, served on a bed of crushed ice, were a testament to the restaurant's unwavering commitment to freshness. Each shell housed a briny morsel of oceanic perfection, a testament to the chef's meticulous selection process. The lobster bisque, a velvety elixir that caressed the palate, revealed a depth of flavor that could only be achieved through a delicate dance of spices and an abundance of succulent lobster meat.The menu, a well-crafted symphony of flavors, offered a diverse array of seafood options, ensuring that every palate found its muse. From the delicate, buttery tenderness of perfectly seared scallops to the robust, charred aroma of grilled octopus, every dish was a revelation—a testament to the kitchen's prowess in marrying tradition with contemporary culinary flair.Service was nothing short of exceptional. The staff's passion for their craft shone through as they guided us, offering insightful recommendations and ensuring our every need was met with a smile. Their genuine enthusiasm for the culinary artistry being presented added an extra layer of delight to the dining experience.In conclusion, Bayville Seafood stands as a beacon of culinary excellence, a temple where the ocean's treasures are transformed into symphonies of flavor that dance upon the taste buds. From the impeccable service to the masterfully crafted dishes, every facet of this establishment reflects a commitment to excellence that elevates it to a realm of its own. For anyone seeking an unparalleled seafood dining experience, Bayville Seafood is nothing short of a culinary haven—one that leaves an indelible mark on the palate and a lasting memory in the heart.

Meghin Rooney

2023-05

The salesman who helped me was very friendly and easygoing. He was happy to adjust my shrimp weight and asked about different fish cuts I was looking for. Ultimately they didn’t have the exact cut I wanted but I was pleased with the service. Their fish selection is not huge, but perfect for just picking something up for dinner. If you’re looking for something in particular I’d try giving them a call ahead of time before driving over.

Andrew Ross

2020-05

We ordered cooked Lobsters for Mother's Day. They were ready on time and cooked perfectly! Highly recommend all their seafood. Friendly and conscientious service, ask for Rick.

Walter Gahagan

2022-05

I have been eating lobster my whole life. Lobster is one of my favorite meals. The stuffed lobster that I had tonight is the best lobster I have ever had. I will be going back soon

Dan Farren

2023-05

Fresh fish always.friendly staff.... lucky to have in our seaside community

john simon

2022-05

My go to place for fresh fish. Great jumbo shrimp, lobster tails and whole lobsters Clean and sharp crew. Fish for fry up.

Magda Lena

2022-05

The best - I say the best seafood place in the area. Always fresh abs delicious - great pricing and just amazing. Highly highly recommended!!

thomas garrett

2020-05

We have had several parties this summer and got baked clams and cooked jumbo shrimp they are unbelievably. They make every party a success.

anonymous

2022-05

Fish is always fresh and the price is very reasonable. Would highly recommend. Also very nice people too.

Dat Ash

2020-05

This is a must stop if in Bayville. Such great service and even better food. Absolutely enjoyed the oysters and shrimp.

Charles Murphy

2024-02

fresh seafood and really knowledgeable guys

Jeffrey Unger

2022-05

Friendly service, wide variety of fresh sea food at good prices.

Joe Foley

2020-05

What a nice place to shop. .Small family owned business that works real hard to make sure you are real satisfied

john conroy

2021-05

Best baked clams. Call and order for pickup. Fantastic

Jen Jones

2021-05

Fresh, quality seafood and great customer service.

Coleen Morgan

2017-05

Absolutely the freshest seafood and friendliest service

Heather Sturges

2019-05

Great selection and high quality. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable

Bobby

2019-05

Freshest seafood you'll get good quality

Vito Labbate

2023-05

Great fish great service

Tom Fletcher

2021-05

Great fresh seafood. Worth the drive

dee Hunnicott

2020-05

Best Seaford around, Fresh reasonably priced

Peter Silverman

2023-10

Always great!

Courtney McCathern

2016-05

Freshest seafood and great service!

Jim DeNatale

2018-05

Fresh and delicious every time.

jacqueline McTaggart

2018-05

Always courteous and helpful service.

Costa Mats

2019-05

Great place. Fresh seafood.

Bill Albert

2023-05

Good fresh seafood!

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 9 AM-5 PM
Thursday 9 AM-5 PM
Friday 9 AM-5 PM
Saturday 9 AM-5 PM
Sunday 9 AM-5 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet