Willy Nilly Trading Company

Arlene Crandall

2024-01

Such a beautiful store! So many unique things, great for finding gifts. And the Christmas store! You have a fantastic buyer who has elegant taste. Such fun doing my Christmas shopping!

Patrick Beckley

2021-05

If you are a Long Islander, you're need to visit this unique shop to look at all of the Island specific gifts they have. This quaint local store had an expansive inventory that also offers Irish ceramics, spiritual gifts, baby items and this year they have opened a new Christmas shop. You can browse for hours. Every customer is asked to sanitize their hands upon entry for safety.

Rita Markowitz

2023-09

I can’t say enough about Willy Nilly. I shop there so often that your staff knows me by my name. It feels like they handpick their staff. They are the most friendliness and welcoming people. Their products are unique and aboveboard. I always find something to purchase. If you need a gift this is your place or just treat yourself.

C M

2024-01

Varied selection of jewelry, clothing, gifts, etc. I go here every time I need a gift for someone. A must visit!!

Brynn VS

2019-05

Very cute stuff. Great for gift ideas. Much bigger than I thought! Will be back

Virginia Angione

2023-05

My husband and I love this store. There are so many unique items for everyone. The staff is friendly and very helpful. They have something for everyone! They have clothing, knick knacks, paintings, decorations, yard items, jewelry, purses, slipper, sandals, etc. I recommend that everyone just stop there once to see their fabulous items. I am sure you will be hooked on shopping at this store after your first visit. When they open their Christmas shop which is right next to their main store you have to go see it. So many beautiful and unique Christmas and Hanukkah items. You won't be disappointed! You can also visit their Facebook page which often has coupons.

Ellen Talisman

2021-05

My shopping experiences at Willy Nilly in the past few years has been totally relaxing and enjoyable. The merchandise is exquisite and elegant and presented magnificently. Any presents I have purchased from Willy Nilly were received with rave reviews. The staff is knowledgeable, professional and wonderful to interact with. It is one of my favorite boutiques to shop in and look forward to my next visit. Happy Holidays to Willy Nilly staff! Stay safe and healthy.

Ginger Beane

2022-05

Great shop in Bay shore!! The staff is so friendly and helpful!!You can different things there for the person on your list! And don't forget the Christmas Shop a couple of doors down! Also so nice! Some things are a little pricey but somethings are not! Still you have check it out!!

Adm2 Arkhm

2019-05

This is the cute store. Everyone should go and check it out at least once! Lots of home decor, conversation pieces and unique gifts. I bought a Long Island travel cup here and was so happy with it. And the place is BIG. Most stores like this are small but this place has 3 or 4 huge rooms! 3 stars due to price(it's expensive), but I guess to run a mom and pop store on Long Island you kinda have to be pricey, because their rent must be astronomical.

Michele Combs

2020-05

My go to place-I am completely addicted to this store!! They have so many beautiful things you need to take your time and see all they have to offer; from jewelry to clothing, from home accessories to food, there is something for everyone here. And Christmas time? My goodness you need to come see how beautifully the store is decorated and while you're there say hi to Santa!

Melissa Adlin

2019-05

I truly love this store. I've been in this store before and love going during the holiday season when it's decorated so beautifully. They have very unique items and you really could spend a couple of hours just browsing. The management really cares about their customers.

nicolle jacobia

2019-05

Hello, let me start by saying I loved your store. My mom and I have been loyal customers for years. But recently I've been a little disheartened when I come to visit and shop with you guys.I never really took notice of your "wedding gifts" section before because for the first time in my 34 years of existence, I found the love of my life, and I am a bride to be. The last few times I've visited i started to take notice of all the unique and lovely engagement/wedding gifts and decor items in your store and have left feeling more invisible and depressed than I have in years. You see, I am a lesbian. So yes I am marrying a woman. And every time I come back I look high and low for anything that says Mrs and Mrs or Mr and Mr to no avail. I don't know if it's a vendor/supplier issue; a oversight by your staff or you guys just don't want those items in your store.As a whole, all of your staff has always made myself and anyone I was with feel welcome. That's not my issue.My issue is that it is 2019, gay and lesbian couples exist and we do get married. And when I walk in and see nothing for us, it's a little disheartening, considering you guys a a major hometown store, that usually has something for EVERYONE. I decided to bring this to your attention because maybe it is an oversight and you just didn't realize.I can say, however, until this issue is resolved, I'll send my friends and family elsewhere to buy us engagement presents/wedding gifts.

Heather Miller

2018-05

It was a very nice store. I'm only giving it 4 out of 5 stars because it is not the cheapest store out there.. It's not super expensive but it's not cheap either. I saw one adorable little 'bling' purse for $50. The employees were friendly and most importantly, they were friendly to all races.

Laura Laveglia

2023-05

Such beautiful merchandise! I love to go and browse and come back to buy an item or two I saved up to make that special purchaseThank you Willy NillyThe lady with the pink dog carriage with the black little dog Amira

Joan Riley

2020-05

Absolutely wonderful. All of the associates are very helpful and it always feels like a family reunion when I go there. Their merchandise is fantastic. Things you don't see any where else. Kudos to all‼

Christine Earls

2021-05

Love it. Unique items one of a kinds. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. They have everything from dragonfly earrings to beach themed decor. It's a must stop you will be happy you did.

Shavon Berthold

2019-05

Something for every girl,lady, mom sister daughter grandma. So many adorable beachy themed gifts accessories jewelry clothes household items candles frames!Could never go there and not find something special! Great place for gifts!

joe balestra

2023-05

A store for just about anyone. Such unique apparel and nic nacs. Decent pricing. Really enjoyed shopping in there.

Steven Perry

2022-05

Store is large, deceptive from the outside. Huge selection of long island merchandise. Some very unique items, recommend giving them a visit. Something for everyone.

Mark Tocci

2023-05

Our favorite gift shop on the planet, as their merchandise is unique and wonderful. Staff are fantastic, to say the least!

Darasue Lyons

2019-05

Today was my first trip to The Willy Nilly Trading Co. Where do I begin? Content, fell in love with almost everything in the store! Employees, the most helpful, kindest people I’ve had the pleasure of coming into contact with. Purchased, rings, ring holder, bracelet, nativity set, and cookies. Return? You bet I will!!!

Sherice Dobson

2019-05

First time here. Loved the store. Lots of unique items. Some reasonably priced, others pricey. Friendly staff. Store is big and items are beautifully displayed.

Cindy C

2024-02

Lovely selection of gifts.

Jenna Masucci-Gardino

2023-05

One of our favorite places to go shopping! Always find a little something for myself and get fabulous gift here!

C. Almond

2023-11

Very nice shop on Main St.

Tina Marie Russell

2018-05

Very personable! The customer serivice is wonderful! Fell in love with the store as soon as I walked in! Just very wonderfully set up! The workers even gift wrapped my popcorn!!! Just beautiful 😍

Amy Meachum

2018-05

I love this place. They have clothing, jewelry, handbags, make-up, home goods and lots of seasonal holiday items. Very friendly staff. Parking behind the store.

Andrew Alloy

2022-05

The very friendly and knowledgeable staff assists in selling a myriad of notions, clothing, Christmas decorations, etc. Fun to shop here.

Denise Kraska

2020-05

This store is so unique! I truly urge every woman to experience it! I guarantee you will walk out with something in your hand. A must see!

Regina Sferrazza

2023-05

Great service. Awesome items. Fun to browse.