Reese's Dairy Bar

Brett Hamilton

2024-04

…More

Nicole Gabriel

2023-06

They have ample parking.Went here again today and got the loaded Texas tots and a Texas hot dog. My daughter got the tenders combo. It was ok. The meat sauce on the Texas hot and tots had a strong tomato taste. Which I didn't care too much for. It was raining and the staff was really nice and brought our order out too our car for us..I've had the ice cream here before and it is always really good. That's what we usually go for. Thought we would try something different today though. I definitely recommend stopping in and giving the ice cream a try .I also believe they still have old cars here on Friday nights too check out.

Tayler Tanner

2024-05

We got take out for dinner from Reeses tonight, qIt was amazing and reasonable priced for what we got!! They were so sweet and nice when walking in to pay! Answered questions we had as well! We also got a container of the ice cream cookie sandwiches- all I can say is RUN, RUN VERY FAST! That was the best ice cream cookie sandwich I have ever had!100/10!! Locals, visitors - I would definitely check them out!!

Justine Phillips Heiner

2024-04

…More

N P

2023-08

Nice selection of in-house made ice cream flavors. Reasonable prices for food and ice cream. Fast and friendly service.

Emily Knuuti

2023-07

Amazing ice cream! I've never seen an ice cream and sorbet twist before, and it was super good. My coworker tried the Reeses Golden Anniversary, and he said it was very light and delicious. Prices were the cherry on top, very reasonable for the high quality. Will definitely be coming back!

Larry Santee

2024-04

…More

Justina Webb

2023-09

Best ice cream place I have been to! The service is great and the ice cream is even better. All of there ice cream is homemade. Delicious! 🤤🤩They also have normal foods if you are looking for a quick bite of regular food before you get some ice cream. 10/10, will be going here again. 😊

JoAnn Strapach

2023-05

It was really chilly and damp, as we'd just had a week of cool weather and rain. We had been out to dinner about 1/2 hour away, had to wait an hour to be seated, and had a 3 year old with us, trying hard to be patient. We were celebrating his Daddy's birthday. It was late by the time we were seated and eaten. All Daddy wanted was ice cream at Reese's. Not sure if we could make it before closing, but we would try. We got there in time and Daddy had his ice cream. It was nice and warm inside. What a perfect way to end our day!

Mariya Hamilton

2023-09

Great ice cream friendly staff … for the most part

Tina B

2020-05

Food was good, came out quickly. Love the ice cream choices. Only down fall was the bathroom sink. Didn't exactly make me feel like my hands would be clean when I was done.

Jesse Leubner

2023-05

Delicious ice creams for every taste! Always fast friendly service! They even had a delicious lactose free option! Thank you Reese’s for always making my dessert dreams a reality!

Karrie Damm-Stewart

2023-05

We tried the Ice Cream flights and were thrilled we did, because it’s hard to choose just one flavor to try! Recommend highly to everyone!

Deanna Poole

2023-06

I absolutely love the French Vanilla Custard ice cream! I have been going here for that flavor for 40 years now, and I am glad they still sell it! I take my girls here and we will continue to support them!

Jennifer

2023-06

I've been here twice since I've been here. I love their maple walnut ice cream. I hope I get a chance to stop in again before heading home. The staff is also very friendly and prices are fairly reasonable.

Adam Schneider

2022-05

If I could give 10 stars I would! The food side was hit after a softball game today and still had other steady customers. In the chaos our order was misplaced, but was recognized and recovered, along with a little treat for us in having to wait. Owner was absolutely amazing, everyone there working very hard, and very courteous. Food was delicious and served up hot. Of course the ice cream was also great! Great job team...keep up the hard work!!! Certainly a great stop to eat!

Gary Wurstner

2023-09

Great ice cream stand outside of Auburn. Their scoops are good sized and priced about the same as other places in the upper Finger Lakes that we have been to

Jody

2023-05

Delicious Ice cream. I read it was home made by the former owners. Taken over not too long ago by new owners. Not sure if it's still home made but delicious all the same. Prices are a tad more than other places but still won't break the bank. Lots of places to sit and eat. Overall a good place to go.

Scott Walowsky

2023-06

The ice cream was good. Service was ok. Couldn't find a clean table, but the staff cleaned them when we asked. Kitchen closed at 730pm, so be aware of that.

Louise Marie

2021-05

Customer service is great, really enjoyed chatting with Keirstan at the window . Pumpkin hard scoop was AWESOME!

Chris Rossi

2021-05

Superb ice cream! Had the milkshake and my wife had one scoop each of vanilla and cinnamon bun cone. Both were delicious. Place was busy but not overly so, and they also offer food, which I plan on trying my next visit. Definitely a must try for anyone in the area. Also, very convenient location off 5 and 20 with ample parking.

Tony Karras

2023-08

One of the best Ice Cream places I’ve ever been to! Keep up the great work and God Bless.

Thai Guy Pong

2023-05

Same great ice cream as in past years, but half the swirl. The size of their soft-serve cones has shrunk quite a lot. I guess times are tough. A manager tried to tell me that they had to decrease the size because they received too many complaints that it was too much. Could this be true? Do people actually complain about too much ice cream? Perhaps, but I call BS. Still good ice cream though.

Katrina Banas

2023-08

Lots of different flavors, nice that’s it’s not that same old icecream sold everywhere! Very friendly, will be back!

Marjorie Sanpietro

2022-05

A favorite ice cream place - you must try Very Berry twist - I always want to break away and do something new but it calls to me (because it's delicious)! My husband gets their Monster sized shakes and my kids get their ice cream exactly how they like it. Very friendly service and their food is good too.

Leon Mumford

2023-06

Prices are right about average service is real good young girls high school kids I guess but they I asked for Hot Pot Sunday and I got exactly what I asked for no offense about it very good service I will go back

biggiy2c

2023-09

Always the best experience always costs less than a pint, always friendly faces at the window, if I could give more stars I would.

Lynsey Mandela

2022-05

We enjoy supporting local businesses and just tried this ice cream bar last weekend.We ordered two one scoop cones and a kid cone for my 4 year old of the hard ice cream.My husband and I were very disappointed. The scoop was seriously miniscule especially for the price. But my 3 year old got a full scoop, which she didn't need that much and we asked for a smaller amount. Then not to mention my cinnamon bun flavor just tasted like vanilla. There was only one patch of cinnamon and none of the Graham crackers promised in the description. Not sure we would buy hard ice cream here again.

Helen W

2020-05

Stopped in for a couple cones. Have a good selection of flavors. I tried a waffle cone. Comes in one size. It was a hefty cone that I could not finish. 4 scoops I'd say. They have food items to. Good place for families of all ages.

Jenn Woodhams

2019-05

The ice cream was good and it was nice to have plenty of seating. They have a nice variety of flavors for both hard and soft serve. Unfortunately for them, there is the smell of "fresh country air" with the farms near by. That takes away from the overall experience.