American House & Hotel

Mik B

2024-03

…More

Denise Laraiso

2023-10

This is my third time in here, twice we’ve had the fish fry, and it’s been really good! Ask for extra crispy, we didn’t, and it was crispy, but our dining guest said the previous week that hers was super crispy. I could not finish all my food. They give you salad and soup bar first and you could fill up just on that. So plan on taking a lot of your food home, unless you’re a big eater. I love to come right when they open so that the salad bar is super fresh. They start serving dinners at 4 PM. If you happen to be in the area early you can stop in to the bar and get a drink, then go sit at four p.m. Their soups tend to be really good. Both times I’ve tried both of the soups. Their salad is just iceberg, would love some different greens in there; hint, hint, hint.

Lynn Spillane

2024-04

Just had an amazing meal withJamison salmon and all the sides. Salad bar and potatoes..I usually have something to take home. Not tonight. Just so good! We have been going to the Angelica Hotel for over 40 years..never had a bad meal there and Stephanie and her staff are so nice and caring.

Amanda Thornton

2023-12

Drove from Buffalo and it was WONDERFUL! Highly recommend the Sunday Brunch. We had such a nice time and all of the food was phenomenal. (No pictures- it was that good!!) The fresh carved roast beef was a favorite of ours. One person in our group is gluten free and she was able to find plenty to eat (fine with cross contamination/etc. nothing was advertised as GF.) Service was friendly and attentive. This place is a hidden gem! Highly recommend taking a drive down if you are from out of town. The antique shop down the road was a must see!Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp access to get to the restaurant.

Amanda Calkins

2024-01

Food was good. LOVE the salad bar.Service was a little slow due to some holiday parties, which is frustrating but understandable. Thankfully they have a cute little area for children to play so our son was occupied, which is a huge plus.The owner was there and she is super sweet, you can tell she cares for her customers.Parking: Extra parking lot across the streetKid-friendliness: Kid's play area

Lunker Pond

2024-04

A bartender named Niomi took my call and was rather rude. Sounded as if placing an order was inconvenient for her and she didn't want the business. Her attitude was even worse in person when I picked up my food. Not too mention she charged me full price instead of the deal on wing night.Worst customer service I've ever experienced. That's probably why there was only two people in the place and they were shooting pool.

Duane Andrew

2024-04

…More

Danielle Hobbs

2023-12

Not the best food I've ever had, they have a very nice, small salad bar, and same with the dessert table, there was definitely something for everyone... they also have a toast and bagels statuon... the Beef was very rare, and they dont really have a way to offer it more well done... I personally wasnt a big fan if the ham, it was a little sweet for my liking, I prefer a regular smoked butt or shank ham... they have a wonderful egg bar, with many options for omelets and fried eggs. Several fruit options for waffles and pancakes... Table service was good, staff was very friendly and they kept our drinks filled and plates cleared quickly... all in all, it was worth the price for the amount of options and friendly service alone! At this current time November of 2023 the price for Adults is $17.99 each, and drink (other then juice offering at the bar) was $3.00 each

Sue S

2023-09

I really liked this establishment. The poor bartender was by herself on a wing night and she tried her best to keep up with the customers. I got a burger and fries and it was great. Prepared exactly how I wanted. My best friend had a chicken tender sandwich and she was very pleased with it. I had great interactions with some regulars and I had a great time. I would go back.

Craig Colburn

2024-03

…More

David Geary

2023-09

…More

Paul Clemente

2023-06

Extremely Disappointed Mother's Day Experience at American House & Hotel⭐️☆☆☆☆I recently visited American House & Hotel for a special Mother's Day celebration, and I must say, my experience left much to be desired. While the service and our server were commendable, I was thoroughly disappointed by the quality of the food served.Firstly, I want to highlight the positive aspects of our visit. The service we received was exceptional, with our server being attentive, friendly, and accommodating. They did their best to ensure our comfort and satisfaction throughout the meal, and for that, I am grateful.However, when it came to the food, I was left utterly disappointed. The dishes we ordered were not only lacking in taste but also poorly executed. It felt as though little care and attention went into the preparation of the meals. The flavors were bland, and the presentation was lackluster, failing to meet even the most basic expectations.Considering the significance of the occasion, I expected a memorable culinary experience that would make my mother feel special and appreciated. Unfortunately, the subpar quality of the food detracted from what should have been a joyful and satisfying celebration.As a customer, I believe it is essential to provide honest feedback, particularly when it comes to dining experiences. While the service and server were commendable, the overall experience was marred by the lackluster and unappetizing food.I hope this review serves as constructive criticism for American House & Hotel, urging them to improve the quality of their culinary offerings and ensure that future guests have a more enjoyable dining experience.

Laurie Hatmaker

2023-06

The food is excellent!! My compliments to the chefs, the staff and the owner. I have enjoyed their food for years. Especially the yearly holiday menu's that are offered. Whether it be Thanksgiving or Mother's Day, etc... the food and service are the best. I have worked in a restaurant, so I can appreciate all the hard work they put into ensuring that the best food and service are presented to their customers.

R. B.

2023-05

We had the Buffet and everything was pretty decent especially for a buffet in a small town. The tomato spinach soup, delicious, and chicken and biscuits very flavorful, and meatloaf and cornbread tasty and the carrot cake and cheesecake both were so good 😋We are actually looking forward to trying Sunday brunch sometime. Our waitress was the lady that has helped run the place I guess for many years she was fantastic.I apologize,I can't remember her name. But she is wonderful and I'll definitely get her name next time. I gave a 4 star just because I do believe some things could have been a little better but overall is a fantastic place to get a great meal. We definitely will go back.Vegetarian options: Theres a salad bar.Wheelchair accessibility: There's a wheelchair ramp.

Mike Whitney

2021-05

For those of you who don't know, the American House and Hotel in Angelica had it's grand reopening last night... I was unable to go due to work but, I made sure that I was available tonight! Upon entering wearing my mask as per NYSDOH I was quickly seated and my drink order taken. As I looked around, it was different but still the same in ways. Gone is the famous salad bar, a big no no according to NYS, the tables were spread out giving the mandated six degrees of separation, a plastic shield separated me from the cashier, large red white and blue curtains separated the middle dining room from the back room, but other than that is was as grand as I remember.I knew what I wanted before I arrived and had placed a reservation. I ordered a “special” dinner... A king cut prime rib, but I also wanted seafood... I requested a seafood platter sans fish. Not a problem for the Hotel (as we in Angelica lovingly refer to it). I wasn't sure what was to be with the absence of the salad bar, but I should not have worried... They have replaced the salad bar with a fresh garden salad, (I ordered the house made Blu Cheese which they are famous for) and your choice of mac salad, cottage cheese or coleslaw. I ordered the mac salad knowing that it also was house made. I have had better, BUT only from my grandmother who passed many years ago, so needless to say, it was fantastic, bringing back fond memories! My king cut prime rib arrived along with four jumbo beer battered shrimp and four large scallops, and by jumbo, I am not talking about those tiny shrimps they pass off as jumbo in the supermarkets around here... They were huge, yet as tender as could be as were the scallops. My prime rib was as ordered medium rare and a polite masked waitress sat down in front of me a wonderful looking piece of meat, just the right amount of cap fat with a huge eye! The rib was Black Angus and melted in my mouth with a fantastic beefy taste accompanied with the house aujus.I was lucky enough to have a long chat with the owner Stephanie Coombes, who I have had the pleasure of both working for and called my friend for many years now. We talked about the difference in the way business is being done and impact that it has had on the bottom line... I have known Steph long enough to see the worry and exhaustion in her manor, even after being closed for 14 days due to testing positive for covid 19... The restaurant business has NEVER been easy no matter what people think. It is not a get rich quick business, just the opposite. And today's world has been hard on all fine dining establishments. The American House being one of the finest in the area! But as always, she was upbeat about the future... Steph is a fighter, always has been and will be for a long time, I am sure of that! She grew up in the business, having bought it from her father, and her heart shows in every aspect of the American house and Hotel!If you're looking for a way to support local business, and have a meal you will not soon forget, I urge you to check out the “Hotel” In Angelica NY! I have been in the business for over 40 years and, believe me this is one of the finest dining experiences you will have!Oh, and the final bill for all this, including a 30% tip, UNDER $50.00!!!A huge thanks to Steph and all who made this again, a fantastic meal!

Mike Virgil

2023-05

Typically arrive here by motorcycle and it's always a good time. Food is excellent and the atmosphere is nice.Parking: Parking right out front

Terry Baker

2023-05

I've eaten at many restaurants Stateside and abroad. I'm happily surprised with the detail that has been spent on the food. It is fresh and delicious. You don't normally get such good food in a small town. Our server was excellent and the dining area was clean and pleasant. I would suggest that if you're looking for a good dining experience take the ride it will be worth it.

Alice Vanik

2023-07

…More

Robert Hoffarth

2023-05

…More

Cindy Brown

2023-05

Like no other rural restaurant anywhere! Incredible variety in the menu, every meal made to perfection, fabulous atmosphere and staff that goes above and beyond! My first time there was a Thursday night dinner buffet and I was hooked even before I finished dinner!

matthew mcdonald

2024-03

…More

crystal warheit

2023-07

…More

Faith Gatke

2019-05

My boyfriend and I visited this place on a whim- we're from Rochester and had planned to go to Cartwright's, but their line was crazy and not budging after 20 mins and we were starving and freezing. I googled nearby breakfast places and found American House & Hotel, and we are SO glad we did! The decor is cute and small town Americana, as well as cozy and clean. We were seated immediately, and told about the brunch buffet. Our waitress (as well as the rest of the staff we encountered) was very friendly, personable and attentive. The buffet was so good- comfort food at its best, with a ton of options. It was also reasonably priced! The atmosphere was comfortable, relaxed and quiet. We really wish we didn't live so far, because we'd definitely be frequenting. Thank you all so much for a wonderful experience!

Timothy Ryan

2024-04

…More

Deborah Lyn

2018-05

The Brunch is AMAZING! The best Roast Beef I’ve had in ages. The staff was so kind and accommodating. The owner was such a doll. She made sure everyone had what they needed and even switched out choices at the buffet to accommodate family members who don’t eat pork. Thanks a million for making today awesome. You will see us at Brunch again!!

THE GAMZER

2023-06

…More

Marie Ripton

2023-09

…More

Rene Bechard

2018-05

The restaurant seating area is more like a VFW than a comfortable dining place. As our waitress was nice and the staff friendly, I was very taken aback with their food portion. I ordered fried sea scallops for $18.99 and received 7 scallops and a tiny sprig of parsley on the plate. The accompanying salad bar was very small and appeared to be better suited in a fast food restaurant. When it was time to leave, I was shocked that the waitress asked each member of our party how many beers we each had. There was only four of us! The food tasted okay, no wow factor though. I surely won't dine there again.

Jeanne Whiteside

2023-05

…More

Mary Maryanski

2023-11

…More