Evetts Cafe

Kayla Berber

2023-06

Evetts is a great place to stop by for a fresh and savory sandwich. I love ordering there affogato. It’s strong and sweet! I have no idea where he purchases his pickles but they are crunchy and delicious! I have always disliked pickles in till Evetts Cafe.

Tom Lohr

2022-05

Excellent local coffee shop that also offers art by local artists. Food is good, milkshakes are unbelievable. Great friendly service. Magdalena needed a coffee shop like this for a long time. It also sports a view of Magdalena Mountain.

Kate Connely

2023-05

Excellent little Cafe’! The owner, Willie is sweet and makes a mean Mocha Latte and Green Chile breakfast Croissant! Well worth a stop.

Joan Cartales

2023-09

We were delighted when this place finally opened. Great sandwiches and the espresso milkshake really is to die for. Top quality ingredients in their food, friendly service, a bathroom that works. They have it all. Plus, nice collection of local art and books for sale. Stop in, you won't be disappointed. Free street parking. Highly recommend.

Camille mansell

2023-12

…More

Jordan Duggan

2023-11

…More

Eva Hennig

2023-05

A wonderful surprise on our long drive to the Very Large Array. The Latte Macchiato was perfectly prepared and tasted like from an Espresso bar in Italy. The sandwiches also looked yummy. And all this with a good Jazz music in the background.

Osiris Navarro

2022-05

I am obsessed with Evetts! My morning routine is a 20 oz mocha with a green egg breakfast sandwich on a croissant with bacon, green chile, and Tillamook cheddar. Then in the afternoons I get an espresso milkshake which is the perfect pick me uppper. Cafe is in a pristine and historic building. Love the preservation put into the place.

Feliz Romero

2023-05

Stopped into Evett's for the first time for lunch today, I had a great chicken salad sandwich made with fresh ingredients, and listen to the guys inside rave that Willie's coffee is the real deal! I'll definitely be back!

Maja Hawkes

2022-05

Really delicious lunch sandwiches and muffins. Local art on display inside the Cafe. Owner is a cool Dude.

Johnathan Archer

2024-02

Delicious food made with care. Wholesome ingredients. Wholesome atmosphere.

Phoebe S.

2022-05

Best breakfast sandwich I have ever had. Soft buttery croissant, delicious over easy egg with cheese and green chiles. Paired with an Americano, it's the best way to start the morning. Willie the guy behind the bar is super kind and helpful. He was patient while I asked questions and never made me feel rushed. 10/10 great place!

Mary

2022-05

The espresso poured over a scoop of ice cream was so good and just right!The egg sandwich and the BLT were amazing and perfect portions, we weren't stuffed but definitely weren't hungry. Even the kids enjoyed the food!

Dave Alexander

2022-05

Well worth the stop! Awesome art, jewelry, minerals & crystals, postcards for sale. The Expresso milkshake is a MUST! Ham sandwich was excellent! Friendly and excellent service!

Angela Pechau

2022-05

Superfriendly people! Great coffee and a stunning location! We will be back!

Kitty Pokorny

2020-05

We stopped by the new cafe/coffee shop in Magdalena on Sunday afternoon, and it was a nice surprise. We had a turkey sandwich with thick bacon, green chile and onion served panini style with chips and a pickle. Nothing fancy, but quite tasty. My husband had a cappuccino and I had tea and sampled a strawberry shake. Perfect. The shop sells art and crafts from local artists. The owner, Willie, was very friendly and welcoming. I definitely recommend a stop at this new cafe on an old corner in Magdalena.

Carol Brackman

2023-05

Love the historic building and had the chicken salad sandwich which was a weekend special - hope they add it to the menu since it was wonderful :)

Marie-Soleil Blais

2022-05

The best turkey sandwich on planet earth! Very pleased with my visit. Worth the stop!

Lorenzo Ruiz

2023-05

Excellent quality ingredients served in simple sandwiches and real delicious shakes. Stop for lunch.

Devon Gordon

2023-07

…More

Gretchen Bremer

2022-05

Eat here!! Crew is super friendly and cheerful! Muffins are 😍 amazing!! Don't miss this place!!

Vicki Schaevitz

2023-05

Great sandwiches and coffee in anOld west bank building on Main street.Parking: Quiet town with lots of parking.Kid-friendliness: Old fashioned counter or tables.

Roland J Gutierrez

2022-05

Nice place to go and have the best cup a joe best food and the best New Mexico hospitality service around frequent customer and I highly recommend that you try Evetts Cafe i love it service is tops and you'll love it too.

Nelda Davis

2023-05

Old time soda shop feel!!! Staff were super nice. Food is beyond great!!!

John Wilson

2020-05

I have found the latte at this spot just as good as the latte served at Es•Press•O across the street and a little further west.

Alexis Chateau

2023-05

Friendly, accommodating staff. Delish oatmeal cookies!

Patricia Soto

2022-05

Teeny tiny little cafe in a little town. Loved our Milkshakes.

Jennifer Upton

2022-05

Delicious chocolate shake made with Blue Bell ice cream!

Donald Gallegos

2022-05

Slow but worth the wait, small menu but fantastic

Ryan Crow

2020-05

Cool old building, tasty sandwiches, and a super friendly staff