The Nerd Mall

4.8 (493)

164 S Broad St, Woodbury, NJ 08096
(856) 202-5103
nerdmall.com

Claimed
Game store
Board game club
Collectibles store
Comic book store
Fortress
Toy store
Used game store
Video game store

From the business

  • Small business

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Tori Giaquinto

2024-04

I'm a huge board game fan. And I love coming here when I'm starting to feel stale of games that I have. Or when I just want to explore games (new and old). The workers are knowledgeable about what they have, and can help to suggest things based on your interests. You can also buy online from them which helps to support their small local business.

Chris Estrada

2024-03

Not really a place quite like this anywhere in the area. Great selection of old and new video games and hardware. My son loves this place. You can also play or watch some head-to-head D&D games in the back of the store! Get your 18-sided dice on!

Eddie Edgerton

2024-04

Reposting a proper review. Top notch can not begin to describe the level of care this place has for the customers. I have built a very large collection of retro video games with their help. Their prices are not only fair for both trade in and buying, but if you are not happy they will go out of their way to make you happy. I will forever be a customer to them.I hope they one day let me do a review in their store for my TikTok/Youtube page.

Summer Simpson

2024-03

I really love nerd mall. I've only ordered online but everything has come to me in perfect condition. They are my first choice to buy video games and comic books from and I would love to visit one day!!

Nick

2024-05

I stumbled upon this gem while waiting for my wife and child attending a bday party.I could have spent hours in this place.The staff is awesome and friendly not your typical comic book store. Highly recommended…

Tim Graff

2022-05

This place is great! Tiki Tiki Board games is a great place to find different board games to play and even rent! There is a lot of different things here like yo-yo supplies (and group), some Lego, figures, flags, a few books, old video games & systems, and board games. There are also tables for people to play the board games. They also have some great staff!

Rob Bridal

2024-03

Neat store - beware the yoyo suggestions. After asking for recommendations for a beginner (they have a yoyo club, after all) I was pointed towards a neat looking one, purchased, and went home. I’ve spent a lot of time restringing, learning, researching, testing, etc - but yet have still never gotten it to actually come back up. Turns out, they recommended an “unresponsive”, advanced style yoyo that as a beginner I didn’t even know existed, and everyone not at this store adamantly recommends not starting with. I wasted a lot of time, experienced a lot of frustration, and have given up on yoyo and this store.

Fred Yevich Photography By Matthew Jurewicz

2023-05

Great Atmosphere, Great Customer Service, and a HUGE selection of collectibles of all kinds. Pokémon of course to Original Nintendos, Magic Cards, Hockey, Baseball, etc... Xbox 360's, Comics, and the list continues!!!

Anthony Wopadante

2024-03

Called from out of town to ask about an item I saw on the online store page. Carolanne (sp?) responded with awesome customer service, finding the item and identifying it, answering questions with a most excellent cheerful disposition - an excellent representative for your business.I immediately placed my order following the excellent service provided.Carolanne rocks.

Joe

2024-02

Store has a decent selection of board games new and used. I stopped in to check out some games and didnt see any i was looking for. I asked the gentleman who was working if they could order specific games and i was told no. I was told they only get in "New Releases" or whatever they take in trade. Kinda disappointing.

travis mcivor

2024-01

First I would like to state that I live in California. I was searching far and wide for a NES Arakanoid Controller. Nerd Mall was the only place I could find one at a reasonable price ($65.00). I was a little nervous when I purchased my item from a store I knew nothing about. But, this store proved to be trustworthy, efficient, and well priced. Not only did I get the controller I requested in great working order, it came quickly. They even added a box of complementary Nerd Candy LOL. I was impressed with this transaction and highly recommend. Thank you Nerd Mall.

kenneth wilford

2023-06

I am a nerd and even I was overwhelmed by the amount of nerd items in this place. It is like your basement and attic had a party, got drunk and threw up everywhere. So many things.

Christine Stewart

2024-03

Greatest place evvvverrr. Great selection of both video games and board games. The guy with the red beard is always helpful and friendly.

lisalat7

2024-03

Nate was amazing!!! He found everything we needed!!! Highly recommend this place!

Isaiah

2024-01

Had been looking for a guitar hero controller at a decent price for DAYS!!! They actually saved my life lol. Had to admit, I was a bit worried since I've never shopped from these guys but, I'm glad everything worked out. Also thanks for the nerds candy hehe

PNAM

2021-05

Great place for the nerd inside. Just about everything but getting a bite to eat. That's why I only gave 5 stars not 6. Hmmpf!

Kyle Jakubowski

2024-04

By “Nerd” they mean anyone with good taste. The used board games are awesome.

Collin Rettig

2023-11

Extensive store with plenty of options for board games and old books. Has a nice play area and a kiosk to browse through all their cards digitally. Staff seemed friendly and knowledgeable

michael magliano

2024-02

Great store. They have comics, video games, board games and collectibles.Love the people

Bob Fina

2019-05

Awesome gaming store that has modern board games as well as used older board games. Additionally, they sell parts for many board games and have a rental service. Decent gaming area to try out games and partake in weekly tournaments. Vintage toys can found along side of new Funko Pop toys. There is even a section for yo-yos. This is a fun store that has found its niche over other gaming stores.

sean niblic

2024-03

First time there but definitely not my last. They have everything nerd. Staff was way cool tooo!!

Maureen Neely

2023-11

My son wanted to stop in to see what it was all about. I personally remember this as Polskys, happy to see the sign still on it. They had a ton of stuff...video games, board games, action figures. The day we went there was some people playing with yo yo's cool to see it.

Khalil Bailey

2024-04

Carolan was so cool and really helpful so two thumbs up and five stars for her

Steve Skripek

2023-05

I've been a loyal customer of The Nerd Mall for years now, and I can honestly say it's one of the best gaming stores I've ever been to. The store has a welcoming and inclusive atmosphere, which makes it perfect for all gamers, whether you're a seasoned pro or a newcomer to the scene. I love the fact that they have a huge selection of games, consoles, and accessories. Whether you're looking for the latest releases or hard-to-find classics, you're sure to find it here.What sets The Nerd Mall apart from other game stores is their attention to detail. They keep the store clean, organized, and well-lit, which makes shopping a breeze. The staff are always available to help and offer recommendations, so you're never left feeling lost or unsure about what to buy.Another thing I love about The Nerd Mall is their prices. They offer some of the best deals in the area, and their sales are not to be missed. I've saved so much money shopping here, and I always leave feeling like I got more than my money's worth.And let's not forget about their social media! The Nerd Mall does an excellent job of keeping their followers up-to-date on the newest trade-ins and additions to their inventory. They also post about upcoming events, sales, and special promotions, so you never miss out on a great opportunity to save even more. Following them on social media is a must for any gaming enthusiast looking to stay in the loop. I've been able to get some rare games just by following and making a call to grab the games.

Shadow Realm

2023-10

I went in to view the case with some of the higher rarity Yugioh cards. I noticed that multiple lower end cards (super rares or ultra rares that go for about $2) were listed as starlight rares with starlight prices (annywhere from $100 - $300) although there was an example of a starlight rare currently in the case. I walked to the front to inform the sales associate about the discrepancy and he shrugged it off.

Susannah Cronin

2023-07

Never buy Anything at this store. They sold my husband a switch with a giant scratch on it that was used, he charged him 300 dollars which you can by a brand new one for 299 at Walmart, but he took advantage of the fact that my husband didn’t know what the price of a new one was, and we had wanted to return it after only having it for 24 hours, hadn’t even played it-only turned it on and saw a giant scratch- and they wouldn’t take it back!You guys couldn’t just take it back? You really are going to do that to brand new costumers? And you know what? WE STILL WANTED TO BUY THE GAME TO STILL GIVE You BUSINESS! Now we have to get the screen replaced and like at that point we will end up spending 350 dollars for something that is used.Please don’t buy from this store. Trust was so unfair. They could have gave him the money back and got an excellent review. But I’m telling you all that they will offer you is store credit-bad deal, bad store. 24 hours is hardly any time at all. I will never ever shop here ever again.Go to game alley instead! They are amazing! Game alley has never done me wrong and would never take advantage of a person who doesn’t know the pricing of things. And they have never been over priced at game alley. So yeah. I will be sharing my experience with every person I know on Facebook and all the people who follow all the YouTube channels. Thanks for stealing money from us.

kdb6214

2023-08

I’ve visited 7 different comic shops in south Jersey, Philly area, and even a few in the Lehigh Valley. Most of them are very similar, a few stand out. I would have to say that what separates the Nerdmall from all these other guys is their back issues are available at a very reasonable price, they have a knowledgeable staff ( not just one guy behind the counter), the #1 thing about this location is the website and email newsletter. They offer a discount on top of the pre-sale price which is awesome. You can order everything you want and pick it up at the store or have it mailed to your house. It’s easy to get the books you like without ever having to miss an issue. I can’t wait for them to start doing store exclusives. oh and if your looking for any Prophet back issues here don’t bother because I think I bought them all. Lol

pyrolee17

2023-09

The #1 place in South Jersey for all things Nerd,Geek and Gamer. With a massive selection to choose from, one can easly get lost in the treasure trove of games,comics and more. Luckily the world class staff is on hand to track down just what fits your niche.

Jon Mundle

2023-09

They have some anime figures but only for a select few series because they're bought second hand, mainly being Demon Slayer, One Piece, and some Fate Grand Order. Staff was still helpful and they had a ton of available pop funko figures and board games to look through.

Eric Jordan

2023-05

Amazing store with lots of gift items. Has pokémon ,magic the gathering ,board games,Legos, skate boards

Opening Hours

Monday 11 AM-7 PM
Tuesday 11 AM-7 PM
Wednesday 11 AM-7 PM
Thursday 11 AM-7 PM
Friday 11 AM-8 PM
Saturday 11 AM-8 PM
Sunday 11 AM-6 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet