Waretown Bakery

Marisa Stachelski, Realtor

2024-03

As soon as we entered Waretown Bakery we were greeted with the happiest "good morning" and the biggest smile. The staff is always so friendly and welcoming! The food is delicious every time and the prices are great! When we were finishing up our order the woman offered my 6 year old a cookie for the road. What a sweet gesture! This bakery is everything old school feel and consistently amazing!

Richard Dow

2024-04

Clearly visible from the road.Parking available.Outside seating available.Good selection of cakes, cookies and pastries.All baking done on premises.Cannolis are especially good and the Irish Soda Bread is to die for.For whatever reason eggs are available for sale.Coffee counter is also available.

Stephanie Tyler

2023-12

We only had the donuts and coffee but we were happy. We’ll gladly come back and try other baked goods. They looked and smelled great. Donuts were delicious and fresh. A good variety with some classics and seasonal. Coffee was simple, nothing fancy but nothing to complain about.We will be back.

Daniel Peterson

2024-04

…More

Ashley Solomon

2024-02

I love that they support Lacey cheerleaders and football and probably other local youth sports. I have never had a better doughnut and the price is unbeatable. Why send your kids to school with Dunkin’ for the their bday when youHave this at a much better price and way better quality?! The woman who takes my phone orders is very nice and accommodating.

JJ Setaro

2023-11

Delicious small bakery on Route 9 in Waretown. Better get there early so you have plenty of choices. We got there at 8am and all of their donuts were gone already. They were making more, but we decided on the baked goods instead.

Pete C

2023-10

Great staff..the baked goods are delightful 😊. The ruggalah's are the best I have ever had. I can literally just sit and eat these all day. With the different variety of them, just fantastic. The doughnuts are so fresh and airy. Jelly doughnuts 🍩 are FILLED with Jelly, not just a drop. This is a must try location!

Kay Morris

2024-03

…More

MELBA WALSH

2024-03

…More

Shawn Zakar

2024-04

…More

Brianna Fernandez-Gumenik

2024-02

3rd time getting a custom birthday cake from them. They always do an amazing job and replicate exactly what I ask for and the cake is always delicious so satisfied with them I will always use them for cakes!

Matthew Latif

2023-05

We’ve now had 3 custom birthday cake made and each one has been amazing. We’d certainly recommend this bakery if you need a custom cake made. I needed to update this review to share the most recent for our son’s 2nd birthday this week.Just had to update the review with photos from our latest cake from here.

Renae Nodine

2024-03

We ordered a full sheet cake for my dad's 80th birthday party. I gave them a picture of what I wanted and it was EXACTLY like the pic!! The cake and filling (cherry mousse with vanilla buttercream icing) was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!! Everyone at the party raved over it!! Thank you Waretown Bakery!!!♥️🎂 You will definitely be our go-to when ordering cake in the future!!!

Seth Lapriore

2024-03

…More

Mian Sta Cruz

2023-05

There was a line when I visited but it was fast moving. Great assortment of breads, donuts are good and reasonably priced. I particularly like the donuts & danishes.

Eleonora Carr

2024-02

They pick up when you call and no matter how busy, they are so friendly, patient and kind! The baked goods are excellent!! My favorites are the seeded rye and chocolate chip cookies and the donuts and the pastries and the cakes and the pies….Kid-friendliness: What kid doesn’t like a bakery? And they love kids

Kelsey

2021-05

This bakery is great! I have ordered two custom Birthday cakes from them within the past month and have been so pleased with the customer service. The ordering process was so easy and seamless. She took the time to answer my questions and go over my options. Every request I had was addressed and accommodated. I love that they are a family owned local business. The cakes were phenomenal! Looked better then I imagined and no complaints on the taste! Will be using them for every Birthday...

Donna C

2023-08

Thank you so much for the beautiful cake!!!! You nailed the decorations and the cake was delicious!!! My daughter is moving to Texas and we celebrated her birthday early!!! I almost hated to cut into that’s how awesome it was❤️❤️❤️❤️

Lisa Fortunato

2023-05

This has to be the most absolute beautiful cake Ive ever seen!!! When I was little, my parents always had a Raggedy Ann cake for my birthdays. To my surprise, they gave this one to me for my 50th!Thank you for your beautiful work and care of this gorgeous cake !!!!!

Dawn B

2023-05

This is they best Bakery I have been in. In years!!Shout out to everyone working hard so we can all have a little taste heaven.

Christine brown

2022-05

I grew up with a family of cooks. My dad was a Baker so I know what's good and not. The doughnuts taste like dirty oil and as you can see the krohller was soaked in oil. I highly do not recommend this bakery. I was very disappointed. It's basically the only bakery around where I live. Save your money. I spent allot and it all went in the garbage. If I could make my own I would. I would give 0 stars but you can't.

Rosemari White

2024-04

…More

chuck taylor

2024-04

Every holiday the place is always pack they do a good job there a lot of people think so as well and a very niceWheelchair accessibility: It's ground floor

John Signorelli

2024-02

…More

Nancy Jones

2024-04

…More

Steve Nagy

2023-07

We had purchased rye bread, hard rolls, donuts, and a cup of coffee. It was the best rye breads that I've had in a long time. Both seeded and plain were very good! The hard rolls were great! The donuts are to die for! The filled ones were really filled, not skimpy! They had banana cream filled donuts the first time we were there. They were so good. When we returned a couple of weeks later, we were told that they took them off the menu. They would make them but at an additional 50 cents. The regular price is $1. A cup of coffee is $1. Couldn't complain about that! And it tasted good too! The place was very busy too! Loved it! It was worth driving 45 minutes each way.

Amy H

2023-05

We can’t thank you enough for creating such a beautiful cake for our granddaughter’s 1st birthday. Not only was it beautiful but it was absolutely delicious!

Victoria Cecere

2023-05

Cannot say enough about the cake we had for a Baby Shower celebration today! I struggled with the design so the baker took the time to discuss my ideas then she took it from there! The cake was a huge hit not only to look at but to taste! Buttercream frosting with Vanilla cake and fresh strawberries with custard filling!

Scott Jenkins

2023-05

By far the best donuts, we have been trying different donut places and this is by far the best so far. Also their black and white cookies are amazing!

Ashley Siegle

2024-04

…More