Marita's Homemade Ice Cream

Lisa Desmarais

2023-08

Fantastic!! We ordered two pints of vanilla to bring home for dessert and had two cones of soft serve for the ride home. We also got ice cream here last summer vacation, exactly what we look for in a ice cream shop. Plenty of choices, clean, friendly with real ice cream that is not sugar forward. The parking is lacking but we’ve never had an issue. We will definitely be back.

Daniel Schurman

2020-05

Favorite Ice Cream spot in Sea Isle. Tons of flavor varieties, quick service even when lines are long. This is our go-to spot every single night we are at the beach.

Miles LG

2022-05

Great ice cream! But a warning to anyone going here they only except cash so make sure you have it in you before leaving. Also they have dole whip(thought I’d say that)

Matthew hose

2023-05

Sent my daughter and her friend with $20 to get some ice cream. We've never been here before, as the lines are always ridiculously long, but they wanted to wait, so they walked over. I assumed $10 per kid would be enough to get something decent, even with prices being what they are nowadays.Turns out, this is one the many places down here that is switching to the "we won't tell you the price until you're hooked in" type of doing business. No prices anywhere. Even after they ordered, the woman said she would give them the price AFTER she makes everything.Of course it came out to be $3 over After the food was made, so my daughter had to change her order and the original just thrown out(I assume).At this point, it's completely their fault that the prices aren't listed and I feel should have just given it to them anyway.How is this a good way to do business?

Stacie B

2021-05

I really enjoyed the ice cream and think they did a great job with dealing with pandemic response. The lines were busy but felt far enough to be safe. The line moved efficiently. The ice cream was awesome. We had a large group and I tried quite a few different treats. I personally enjoyed the splendid blended with hot fudge and marshmallow. It was almost like an extra thick black and white shake and it was perfect. It was thick enough to need a spoon but I did use a straw after the walk home for the last melted bit. Can't wait to visit again.

Karley Hall

2023-05

Very poor customer service…We went to get water ice. While ordering we were told they were out of a majority of the flavors they had listed on their display windows. The staff noted out of the 8 flavors of water ice displayed they only had bubble gum. We hadn’t tried bubble gum before, and considering we were the only ones in line at the time, I asked to sample a little bit before purchase. Our intentions were to sample bubble gum, and then make a selection on what to get from there.We left empty handed. We were told they don’t do samples, even though this was an error of signage on their part. The demeanor of staff was extremely stand offish, and not accommodating at all.Won’t be back.

Mike

2022-05

I loved it. I go here every day when in Sea Isle! Great ice cream and service. Currently opens at 6 PM due to staffing issues, which is unfortunate. Nevertheless, the variety of flavors still taste amazing and are completely worth it.

Susan Sawi

2023-07

Always great service and ice cream! We come every year when we are renting, hit Marita's a few times through the week, always a big hit!

Keith Thompson

2023-05

They have less parking than before, but a lot more room for people, this is absolutely better. They also have a single feeder line to multiple windows so no more jockeying for the best line. Ideal if you are in walking distance. Per Steven Wright, you are always within walking distance :).

Beth Kemmery

2023-07

Hey, we love you but what’s up with the secret pricing? If prices aren’t visible we can’t give our kids money for your cash only business that is a summer family tradition :)

Harold Villegas

2023-07

Hundred and different flavors outside beaches.

Sara S-G

2023-09

Dairy free sorbet available and lots of fun games to play while waiting for the kids. A good time had by all

SnekuL_Xfire11

2018-05

Great ice cream. Friendly staff. Fair prices. Would love to come again.

Dante DeAnnuntis

2019-05

Marita's is hands down the best ice cream place in Sea Isle and is a town treasure. During the summer, they are always busy but it is worth the wait. They have a large menu and selection of ice cream to choose from and everything is delicious!

Harry B.

2018-05

Marita's has a great selection of hand dipped and soft serve ice cream from over a dozen flavors. The staff is very fast and friendly on orders as well. Unfortunately, the portion sizes are rather small. I got a large vanilla custard in a cup. The ice cream was filled maybe half way to the top. I am too afraid to see how small the 'small' size is. The place can get busy in the evening and parking is difficult.

JJ Cutuli

2018-05

A Sea Isle landmark, Marita's has been serving ice cream during the summer season since the late 80s. Homemade ice cream is delicious and a large menu has options for most everyone. Not cheap, but my favorite is this's milkshakes that come extra thick by default. Most nights there are long lines. Wait outside. Cash only.

Don Brovero

2021-05

Very good ice cream and water ice. Always busy so expect to wait in a line but it moves fast. Open late every night. I had a coffee malt and it was good. Great portions at a good price.

Jeanine Ferrick

2021-05

We love Marita's! In 14 nights, we had their ice cream 11 times. Yikes for my waist but so yummy! And yes, the doggie buddy bowl is a nice touch for my fuzzy kids.

Monica Berghold

2022-05

We have gone a few times this week and I can see us going every night till we leave. Seems to get very crowded, but able to distance from others in line. Ice cream is AMAZING!

S. D. Good

2020-05

There are no words to adequately describe how amazing Marita's ice cream is. Everything is fresh, delicious and satisfying. There is a reason why the lines are always long: it's well worth the wait.