Anthony's Sea Isle City

Sam T

2023-09

Our first time here and we'll definitely be back! The veal parm was perfectly crispy and the sauce of the Chicken Stephen was very tasty. Everyone was friendly and the bright decor is inviting.

Patti Williamson

2023-05

Enjoyed our meals at Anthony’s. Service was perfectly timed. The meatball appetizer was huge and so tasty.. it could be a meal. The specialty veal dishes were amazing. We had Veal Saltimbocca and Veal Anthony. The Madeira sauce with the Veal Anthony is earthy and super flavorful. The Saltimbocca sage wine gravy was light with a lot of depth. I would recommend putting these 2 dishes over pasta.

Jimmy Contreras

2023-05

Nice ambiance, definitely a little more luxury than anticipated in Sea Isle City. The service wasn’t great but good. Ava, our waitress seemed a bit overwhelmed. The food was amazing! I was pleasantly surprised. I ordered a special salad of the Peach Caprese Salad, and an entree special that is not on the menu, clams and spaghetti. #IYKYK It was delicious! Other guests in my party had the Veal Parmigiana, Blackened Salmon and a Corn Risotto with Scallops entree special. Overall experience with food was great. Highly recommend, if you’re in Sea Isle City!

Noel Abejo

2023-05

Great location at the heart of Sea Isle. Excellent service and plenty to choose from. Had the lobster bisque soup and sea bass for main course. The Branzino was also cooked to perfection, crispy on the outside and it was tender.

David Martino

2023-05

What a fantastic place... Everything was awesome the food was awesome and everything was delicious! The people there were unbelievable lyrics friendly and cheerful. The entire experience was just better than perfect! Highly recommend for everyone, course, groups and even take out.

Dale Polhemus

2023-09

We dined outside on sidewalk tables, ok but not as nice as indoor, which had no availability. It's also BYOB, but if you forget, you can call , they deliver. We did that, and the bottle of wine arrived within 10 minutes. The food was good and portions plentiful. Deserts sounded good, but we were too full to get. We had a chowder soup appetizer, which was excellent. I suggest walking or taking the Jitney, as parking is limited to street parking. Getting a spot would be like having a winning lottery ticket :)

Michael DuBick

2023-08

Among the best restaurants in Cape May County on the Jersey shore. The inside dining area is comfortable and nicely decorated. The noise level is correct and allows for comfortable conversation. The wait staff is highly professional. Most importantly, the food is delicious. The crab cakes are among the best to be found on the east coast

Stephen Edwards

2021-05

Got a stuffed portabello mushroom for an appetizer, chicken parmesan for the entree, and chocolate cake for dessert. Every plate of food was fantastic, fresh, and original tasting. The service was amazing as well. I will definitely be returning for another meal!

Michael Coront

2023-06

Absolutely a delightful evening. 1st experience dining at Anthony's, and it certainly will be in my top 3 Italian restaurants in South Jersey. The food was impeccable. Our server Alex couldn't have been better. The only negative comment is the noise level and proximity of fellow diners. This certainly is understandable and can easily be overlooked after experiencing the quality of their food. Former resident visiting from new domicile Naples Florida, home of a million Italian restaurants and Anthony's would be at the top of the list there also.Thanks for a great evening.

Ellen Johnston

2023-08

…More

Philip Pinto

2024-05

…More

Anthony Wagner

2023-07

Had a very nice dinner with five others this night. There wasn't a wait for a table, but it was Sunday night before we went. The busy season cranks up here as soon as the kids are out of school up here I believe in about a week, ergo much more crowded on the Isle.If you want to drink alcohol, you must bring your own, for now.

chris kay

2023-08

If I could give less than one star I would. We have for many years been regulars at Anthony’s…. Until tonight. We have multiple properties in Sea Isle city since 1970 and have never been treated the way we were tonight. I made reservations (2 weeks prior) for 10 people, 9 and a high chair- to which we were told, “ok 10 people”… we ended up being 9. Upon our arrival we were seated at a table for 10. Within 5 minutes we were asked to move our party. We were more than willing to move until they tried to squeeze us into a table meant for 6. We informed the waitress that sitting at such a small table would be very uncomfortable being that we were 9 people. We were told not to worry they would remove tableware not being used to make more room Ridiculous! The hostess then came to our table and tried to justify our move. She was rude, loud and extremely unpleasant. She kept saying that we were mistakenly seated at the original table because that was reserved for 10 and we were only nine…. I’m pretty sure that a table for 10 would would better accommodate 9 than a table for 6. She wouldn’t listen to reason and we ended up walking out. Maybe because there were a couple of kids in our party she figured there would be a bigger bill with 10 adults in a party. Needless to say, as long as that woman is working there, we will not be returning.

Mike Lista

2023-10

…More

Jim Davis

2023-05

We sat outside, so I can't comment on the indoor ambiance or atmosphere. I got the crab cakes which were very generously sized and excellent. The lobster bisque was excellent as well, although it was a special and not a regular menu item. Reasonably priced for a nice restaurant at the store. Five stars!

Joelle Martorano

2023-09

…More

Tommy Balne

2023-08

…More

Sara Mahan

2023-05

Appetizers were very good, especially the fried tomatoes. Staff is excellent. Don't order the crab cakes, not jumbo lump crab as the description says. My son's fish dinner was very good. It's pricey.

Bri

2023-05

We were really excited to go here during our trip. They were able to hold our wine for us while we went to grab a drink elsewhere before our reservation which was great. The hostess was attentive and uncorked our wine as soon as we were sat. Our server was very nice. The food was unfortunately really bland. The seafood diavolo didn't have any flavor which was surprising. The clams were full of sand and the scallops were rubbery. The lobster tail was ok and our oyster app was fine. The lobster bisque didn't actually have much lobster in it at all. One guest got the chicken stephen which she enjoyed. Otherwise, we left unsatisfied with our food for the price point and may look elsewhere in the future.

Mike M

2023-05

We ordered the salmon and crab cakes. The salmon with scallops was cooked just right. The cook staff seemed to be having a great time when I picked up our food. The food was delicious and priced right. We will go again.

Kevin Gallagher

2023-07

…More

Brett Schreyer

2023-09

…More

Mark Laliberte

2023-05

As usual, the two meals we enjoyed with our group inside the restaurant and the one takeout, were phenomenal. My wife and I have been following and enjoying Anthony's since their days on Haverford Ave 29 years ago.

Mike Wolff

2021-05

Anthony’s is absolutely excellent! The Florida Grouper was amazing and the Risotto was great too. We are out in Landis Ave due to the Covits but the waitresses hustled and made sure all was good at our table at all times! I highly recommend eating here for the great food, service & music playing outside! We love having this addition in our town!

Rosanne Menzel

2023-09

…More

Jeffrey Brummel

2021-05

Run by a wonderful family, who go out of their way to make you feel like part of the family. Sounds cliche, but try the veal chops!!!

Christian Whiteman

2022-05

Didn't realize it was a byob, but that didn't take away from the fantastic experience. The service was friendly and attentive. Great detail was taken to each individual order- no overcooked pasta, no bland flavor, no skimpy portions. I will definitely be back again soon!

Calvin Roach

2021-05

I completely agree with the previous review. Food was good and atmosphere was nice. Our waitress Mackenzie was amazing. However the hostess was wearing her mask around her chin as she greeted guests and sat them and walked around to tables. Then a man who I am assuming is the owner or manager was walking in and out of the restaurant repeatedly with no mask at all. This was all done while they have a sign on their door stating you must wear a mask to go inside. And half of the other staff were wearing their masks over their mouths but not noses. Seeing all of this left me feeling a little uneasy as a customer.

Annie

2021-05

Amazing BYOB addition to Sea Isle. If you have been the Delaware County locations the same quality of food can be found at the Sea Isle location. Don't leave without trying the eggplant parmesan as an appetizer or entree. Flounder special a generous serving and delicious.Outside seating was accommodating and tables were no too close to each other.I would only suggest staff to appropriately wear masks when working.

Ariana Patro

2023-07

…More