Angelo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Crazy Gamer

2021-05

I was very impressed with Angelo's Pizza! They only have out door seating right now due to Covid-19 but sitting outside was very nice. They have plastic tables and chair with umbrellas and the seats were comfortable enough to have a nice dinner. The tables and chairs were nice a clean which can be difficult with outdoor dining.The service was absolutely excellent. The waitress wore a mask and kept her distance to avoid the potential spread of Covid-19. She check on us frequently and provided excellent service.The pizza was Italian style and was delicious. I highly reccomend stopping in for dinner or for picking up some pizza togo!

Alena Ruggeri

2024-04

…More

Matt

2023-05

My girlfriend and I come here every year we visit Sea Isle. Not an understatement when I say it has some of the best pizza on the east coast. Along with a very tasty assortment of other items like cheesesteaks, rice balls , and more. Also some of the most friendliest staff I had ever met, I strongly recommend visiting here and getting a pie, is well worth your money and a good price compared to the rest of the overcharging stores here. Cheers.Thanks Angelo -matt

ava

2022-05

i dont write reviews often but the low reviews on this place are ridiculous! i had such a good experience here and i will definitely be back. service is so friendly and so accommodating; can get very busy at times but nevertheless food and service is always great. seeing the people they have to deal late at night the people here handle it with grace. and the white pizza is definitely worth the drive to come back :)

1354424

2015-05

We used to love Angelo's for their cheese steaks and pizza. They must have changed suppliers or found cheaper ingredients and recently their food has been terrible. We ordered a pizza to be delivered, had to return it because of being undercooked and little cheese. The manager said to keep it and they would send out another. The excuse was they were training a new cook. Why didn't they check on what was going out the door? Second pizza a little better but not much. They had their chance, never again. Sorry Angelo. In the summer you can feed the 2:00am drunks anything. Can you make your living off of the drunk college kids?????

Ian Lazarus,CRS

2020-05

We shared a house salad that was fresh and crisp. I had a very good calzone with sausage that was very good and very filling. My friend ordered something which wasn't good. They took it off the bill and were very gracious about it. The service was good and I will be back for a causal late night meal.

jose tellez

2018-05

I decided to take a chance with the mediocre rating on this establishment, I wish I hadnt. The wings were nothing special, they were simply fried pieces of chicken with a bland cup of sauce. I was hoping the pizza would prove more appetizing then the chicken, once again I was wrong the cheese was really chewy, and the pizza was just a bland and greasy mess. For a large pizza and 24 wings expected to pay around 40ish dollars however the bill came to 60! The receipt stated that the 24 wings came to about 30 dollars! 12 bland wings for 15 dollars??!?! This place is just a tourist trap I recommend heading over to the burger joint down the block much more tastier and... BETTER WINGS!!! Some friends ordered the pasta and it looked like a sad pile of spaghetti with a glob of tomato sauce on top. It didn't taste that good either according to them

Clare Palazzo

2020-05

The absolute worst impression of an Italian restaurant ever. I took 20 family members there for dinner and each and every one of us had the most disgusting food brought out. I am so sorry I didn’t take pictures. The cheese steak had stale rolls and a pinch of beef, no fried onion or pickles, the salad was brown tip iceberg lettuce. Can’t even describe how disgusted we were. Should have known by the fact the restaurant was empty at 6pm.Get help owner or get out of the businessPure filth in bathroom, you g kids running the place. Can’t say enough of how sick we all were when we got out of there

Pete Malone

2020-05

Worst service and food. Our server didn’t seem to understand what we wanted to order. Pizza for the kids came out about 25 minutes before the rest of our 10 person party received their food. Two people In our party never received their food.Meatball sandwiches were flavorless and almost inedible. Another family near our tables was experiencing the same thing. We won’t be back.

Slainte1975

2020-05

Went all the way to Sea Isle from a small town in Idaho. Ate at Angelo's our first night there. Ya, it was really busy and we waited a bit for our pizza, but guess what? We went back a second time because we enjoyed the pizza so much the first time around. So many people just want to complain in these reviews. Get over yourselves.

Josiah Zulauf

2021-05

Worst pizza place ever. Waitresses were teenagers in the front messing around. I just wanted to buy a few slices and the lady told me I could only buy a whole pizza and said it would only take 10 minutes. I’ve been waiting here for almost 25 minutes. Then another customer came in and she let her buy just three slices. Go anywhere else than here. The service is horrible.

Stephen “Stevie Coachella” Humbert

2016-05

I wanna start by saying I've never left a review like this before but i don't want anyone else to waste their money here until something changes....The service was fine, but the calamari was the worst by far that I've EVER had. Soggy and gross..& $9.25...get a life....so i figured the slice of cheese pizza would be fine...NO! SO BAD! how do you mess up a slice of pizza that bad in south Jersey? Seriously used to love this place... Peace

chelsea k

2018-05

Angelo's pizza is the most fantastic restaurant I've ever eaten at. When I eat at Angelo's it makes me feel the most happy person ever. The pizza is heavenly and I would die for the pizza. I love the pizza it is so amazing it makes me emotional every time I take a bite I feel amazing. Angelo's thank you for your service thank you for how amazing your restaurant is.

Nick Wackes

2019-05

Slow/terrible service with unprofessional staff. Ordered a cheese steak pizza with fries which I thought was pretty straight forward. Instead received a regular cheese pizza, though not overcharged, was not what I ordered. The part that bothered me was what the girl that answered the phone had to say when I called back. With me on the phone proceeded to say she knows for a fact I didn't order a cheese steak pizza with other unnecessary remarks. Coupled with their delivery driver telling me the wait was so long becuase they were under staffed. Highly unprofessional and will never order from here again.

Rosa Osorio

2017-05

Bro, my mom's, my sister's, and my $20+ pasta dishes were actually disgusting. The waitresses showed absolutely no emotion and awkwardly watched us eat. The sauce on each dish pooled at the bottom leaving the top dry and soggy. The portions were way too large and my favorite part of this experience was leaving. Don't eat here.

lizzie hough

2019-05

the low ratings for this restaurante confuse me. Since i’ve been born I have visited Sea Isle City annually. It has become a tradition to visit Angelo’s and order the white pizza. It is to die for and the service is great, all of the employees seem so genuine and sweet. Thank u Angelos, Sea Isle wouldn’t be the same without you.

greenmugaudition

2018-05

Angelo's pizza is nothing short of fantastic. People may say that it sucks, sure. But, most of those people came to this restaurant with burgers in mind and money in their wallets. Of course the burgers aren't going to be great, it's a PIZZA restaurant originally. If you are sane and came here for pizza, I personally recommend the White Pizza. If you are mentally ill and came here for burgers, go to the nearest diner. Thank you for your service, Angelo's! I hope your restaurant continues for as long as possible, and I hope that you get better ratings-this restaurant deserves it's hard-earned stars.

ashley snyder

2022-05

Jackie S. was our server and she was the absolute best!!! She started great conversations and got our food out quickly! She made sure we were served and all of our needs were taken care of! Love it!

Andrew MS

2014-05

I hated the restaurant for several reasons. One, when we got to our table, our waiter had an extremely thick ascent, we could barely understand her. Two, my family and I waited at least 45 minutes for our food to arrive. Three, my food had very little taste to it and I ordered a cheesesteak with peppers and I assumed it was sweet peppers like any other places that would put them on cheesesteaks but instead it had way too much jalapeño peppers and I had heartburn for a couple hours. I would never go back to that restaurant again.

Liz Carroll

2020-05

First time here and in sea isle. We will visit sea isle again, but will Absoluely never visit Angelos pizza again. From the moment we walked in the door the service was so rude and dare I say snobby. The pizza was OK, but not worth the rude service.

Jacquelyn Steelman

2021-05

Honestly I’ve been to a fair share of Italian joints in my area, and Angelos is my favorite one! They definitely keep the Italian in their entrees. The food isn’t just the best part, the staff is friendly and will accommodate to your needs. During the crisis called COVID-19 they are doing a wonderful job to satisfy their customers. Keep up the good work angelos staff!

Paula Neely

2019-05

Ordered an antipasto , Caesar salad with chicken and garlic bread. The Caesar salad came with no dressing , so I called and they said they would send it right over. I expected an anti pasta salad and just got an oily plate of thick meat and cheeses. A day later and still no dressing. Garlic breadtasted rancid. Never again

Justin B

2021-05

Experience with Angelo’s was smooth and seamless. They were very accommodating with my large order of 24 pies and chicken. Ready within 40 minutes on a Friday Night. Very Professional.

Edward H

2020-05

Food is good, a solid go-to at JFK & Landis. You should expect shore/resort town prices, and a level of service commensurate with how busy they are. College kids man the counters and tables, be sure to tip accordingly. 🤙🏼

Troy Black

2020-05

Camping at lake and shore. Craving pizza. Drove to Angelo's had 2 slices order of fries and a Coke. Couldn't get any better. I'll drive back again next trip. Everyone was friendly

Matt Gardner

2022-05

This place is an icon of sea isle city. The owner is one of the kindest most personable guy you will ever meet. The staff was great and the food was delicious. Always a pleasure visiting here.

Rick McMullen

2013-05

One of the worst pizza's I have ever eaten. I should have known there was a problem when we walked in on Thursday night at 7:00 and the place was empty. Our pizza was so under cooked, that the cheese wasn't even completely melted on the raw dough. Avoid this place.

Paige Dadi

2022-05

They don’t offer individual slices of any speciality pizzas which is ridiculous for a pizza place and if you order a plain slice with a topping they just throw it on top. My friend was given plain when she ordered pepperoni and was then given a stack of pepperoni to put on herself. I did not even get one of the items I ordered but after tasting the pizza I was thankful that I would not have to pay any more for absolutely terrible food. Then of course our bill was wrong because why not?

Mike Materio

2020-05

Overpriced bland pizza. I order 2 slices the girl puts them on top each other cheese stuck to paper plate. So I had a $4 slice of dough

Shafi Styx

2020-05

Awesome place to get food, the level of care they put in to their customer service is amazing. Giving you that true Italian hospitality. Recommend the breaded chicken fettuccine Alfredo 😋