Schooley's Mountain General Store

Jonathan

2024-04

…More

frank

2024-04

…More

Des KF

2023-05

So my clients picked this spot to get lunch and I ordered and picked up the food. I ordered tuna fish and french fries. The man that took my order was nice and when I arrived I parked in their lot. I walked in and it was a deli/post office. The nice lady asked if I was picking up and I said yes. The food was ready and I paid and left. I dropped off the food and took mine back with me which is kind of far. When I open the sandwich if looked good. I turned it over and found a huge hair in my food 🤢. Needless to say I threw everything away. Not a good experience for me.

Maria Marione

2023-12

This is a historic General Store in Long Valley. There is a full service deli with a pizza oven and homemade baked goods. The sandwiches are fresh and generous. The pizza and calzones are great. We get the calzones and slice them to bring to parties. There is also a post office here and a small market with the basics. The bread pudding muffins are a favorite.

William Poole

2024-04

…More

Chris Woll

2024-03

…More

Greg M

2023-05

It was my first visit here but I loved it. There is a post office inside. I ordered the eggplant mozzarella and roasted red pepper with balsamic sandwich and it was delicious. Can't wait to go back and try their Pizza. It was a nice ride there and the place is such a step back in time. I believe it's been there since 1830. It really is worth the trip.

wills co

2023-12

…More

Daniel Castellanos

2023-05

Honestly the best pizza you will find in all of Morris county. Seriously, call in and ask them to make you a fresh pizza, better than any Italian restaurant in the area and even better than the dedicated pizza parlors in the area. The deli sandwiches are also really good and the specials are fun every time. The lemon bar desserts are my favorite, and all the other options they have for teas and convenience items are very good. The staff is amazing and Carlos is a genius chef. This place has my patronage for life, it gets a little busy around lunch time with all the local workers going to get their favorite sandwich, but if there's a line make sure you wait. It is totally worth it.

Lauri-Sophia Rose

2023-10

…More

David Nicholais

2023-05

We were coming off a road trip from PA and needed to make a pit stop! they couldn't have been more nicer or accommodating to us, also pick up some breakfast sandwiches for the rest of the trip home. So if stepping back in time to a nostalgic place were the general store and post office operated in the same space, well you'll love this littel jem!✨️Enjoy, Dave

Keith Arentowicz

2023-10

…More

Ed

2023-05

15+ dollars for a drink and a daily special sub. Should have known they have no idea what they're doing when I read the ingredients for a Cuban sandwich. Sounded like a trainwreck but took a chance figuring maybe it would be a surprise its good type of thing. Well, it wasn't. So alot of money and 1 NASTY sandwich later I regretted my choice. Never coming back.

Anthony Defabritis

2023-07

…More

Anne Nadel-Walbridge

2022-05

The only reason to go in is to get the mail. It used to be a great and real general store. Now it's just another place to get mediocre pizza, served by people who act like they're doing you a favor by helping you, and can usually be overheard talking about either sports, conservative politics, or previous customers. It's anything but a friendly place.On the other hand, the post office is very cool, and very old. One of the oldest in the state.

Kurt J

2023-05

Pete and Lisa serve up great food, whether it's pizza or a sub sandwich. Lucky to find this place in rural West Jersey. Going to be a regular stop when I'm out that way!

Dennis Suler

2023-05

…More

John Dios

2024-04

…More

Bondo Zafa

2022-05

Friendly service, excellent variety of foods. and very tasty no matter what you order. Cool historic atmosphere and charm. Inside you will find a USPS hub that is very convenient. Definitely recommend 👍😁

Amy Bandel

2023-05

…More

David Marchese

2020-05

This place has been around forever and has done a great job keeping up with the times. From the outside it looks like you typical general store. On the inside they have a post office, a pizza kitchen, a sandwich shop, and really good empanadas.

Jon Calhoun

2019-05

The food is always good. But today on 8/9/18 the woman behind the counter was just an absolute b word. The woman with blondish hair and a cheap tattoo on her forearm of some saying or what not. She was not just nasty to me but to everyone that walked through the door. I'll go back again soon this time il be ready to deal with an a hole

Alex Friedland

2019-05

Great place. If you don't travel those roads you might miss it. They have great deli sandwiches and specials. They even have a decent pizza and calzone. Everything I have ordered there has come out right. It's not expensive and the people working there have always been pleasent.

Jeru King

2023-05

Great food and people. Everything fresh always good. Take my guys from work there often. One of our favorite spots.

Dom Bastello

2023-05

…More

Kelly HK Lee

2020-05

This place offers an array of food items (pizza, sandwiches and beverages). If you feel lucky, you can purchase a lottery ticket. The facility also serve as a local Post Office. Repairs are very much needed (front porch).

gary pastirik

2022-05

The food is amazing, the staff was friendly, a great family owned, eat in take out little slice of heaven in New Jersey, a welcome site after a long bike ride or stopping in to pick up a few things for dinner, lunch or breakfast!!!

Mike Altieri

2023-05

Great food and excellent service! Like all other places prices have increased - but I'll still keep going!

loads loads

2022-05

I ordered a turkey and cheddar sandwich, I watched the guy open up some Reynolds wrap with a few slices of left over chesses, when I opened the sandwich later for lunch, the cheese was hard. It was NOT good.

Thomas Lotito

2019-05

Oldest General store still in operation in NJ. Step back in time and enjoy the all their food, the specials, soup and sandwiches. Pizza and ltalian subs. There is an operating post office there too and much more.