Mike's Toys and Collectibles

Andrew Leighton

2023-11

Best collection of single card and booster pack Pokémon cards I’ve ever seen. Owner is extremely knowledgeable.

RJ Katz

2023-09

Good store with accurate prices, everyone leaving poor reviews is expecting to walk in and get a great deal. It's not an estate sale or a flea market. The owners obviously know what they have, and have researched to have their prices as such.Cool store with lots of nostalgia and toys from yesteryear.

Taylor Simons

2023-07

They had a lot of Pokémon cards but not priced as advertised. “Lowest prices in OCNJ” Cards should be priced at market price and I would get a couple dollars above, gotta keep the lights on, but the cards are set at “ebay prices”. lol Kinda silly

Chris Pierce

2023-05

Creepy dude follows kids around the store while browsing. keep an eye out for this guy. My son was looking at Star Wars toys and creeper followed him waiting for a accident. Creeper tells his business to the whole boardwalk, family prison stories, eats on the ground like a hobo. Creeper was caught giving my son a hard time about browsing the shut his mouth when I approached. He’s a big goof like the shirt he wears everyday.

Allison Cook

2020-05

Amazing find and a place I would not have expected to find while on the Ocean City board walk! Has a huge selection of Pokemon cards, figurines from all different genres and toys. There's stuff in there for kids and adults alike. Mike is also super friendly and seemed willing to talk with anyone about any of the merchandise. If he does know something specific, he was willing to look it up.

Greg Wheeldon

2022-05

Very nice staff. Very patient with my 10 and 6 year old. I appreciate the work that goes onto finding these items. I will tell all my friends to check this place out! Thank you for a great shopping experience.

Truther

2023-05

Store said it opened at 10am on Fridays and was not opened when I made a special trip just to go there. It was an inconvenience. Also, the guy working at the desk wasn't very welcoming or friendly

Jack Lottier

2023-05

Love to check things out but when they say they buy other collectables they don't. But in the odd occurrence they do they will offer you basically nothing.

G Roma

2018-05

This place is better than ToysRus. The owner has a great G1 Transformers collection that he is selling. They are pricey, but it's worth it because most of them are in the ORIGINAL packaging!

Alec Signorile

2019-05

It has a variety of collectibles and it is my go-to spot every single time I vacation in OC. Nice dudes work here and prices are very fair. Great shop, looking forward to next time.

Steve Brey

2022-05

I go here every year when I'm in Ocean City, New Jersey and it's always a neat little shop to look around in.If you don't get a nostalgia trip looking at all this toys then you better check your pulse!

Howard Marquette

2021-05

Visited this shop couple times. The man behind the counter is very knowledgeable about the collectibles he sells. Little bit pricey but he’s got the goods.

Eric Krieg

2023-09

really cool stuff here, they have stuff there for smart people

Rich Kolka

2023-07

Don't sell your stuff here. I watched them give a seller a quarter of what the resell value would be.

Pete Klabe

2017-05

Had a ton of stuff even though it's a pretty small tight place. Clean and well organized. We were looking for some role playing and strategy games but only had collectables.

Deuce Loosely ptcg

2021-05

Went here for pokemon cards, great prices and mike is really nice with very fair deals and he knows what hes talking about!

Eric Mace

2022-05

I am a good long term customer with Mike and he is very nice to my kid who is his most loyal customer who comes every year.

Eevee Kawaii

2020-05

I have been coming here for years and it is always the same great staff and good selection of collectibles!

Massimo Maceri

2017-05

I've been going to this store for at least 5 years. I just love walking around the store and looking at new stuff and old stuff. If you are a collector, you should go to this place!

Hycupson _

2022-05

They have tons of action figures, play sets, and collectibles from many decades. they have an especially great star wars select

RJsmangit (RJsmangit)

2023-08

Pokemon card boosters are astronomically overpriced.

Mike Battista

2022-05

Great store. Lots of great products for pretty fair prices.

Johnny Kopack

2018-05

Went in looking for some gameboy stuff, but this store doesn't really have anything like that. Most of the stuff you can find at any other store.

Brian Hilton

2017-05

A good spot for collectors in the action figure genre. Prices are not bad and selection is good.

Akuma Nozumu

2020-05

Accusing of steeling and cursing out little kids and getting in their face even though the things they accused us of stealing were right in their hands do not go to this store everything is a knock off

Darth Donohue

2018-05

Good items, great staff. Fair prices.

Jacob Sundied

2022-05

Good stuff just some of it is a little pricey.

Lose end45

2019-05

DO NOT BUY HIS “legos” THEY ARE FAKE CHINESE KNOCK OFFS!!!!! I REPEAT DO NOT BUY HIS LEGOS THEY ARE CHEAP KNOCK OFFS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Amanda Ames

2019-05

Great place. Always visit when we go to the beach.

Austin

2023-05

Fun store to walkthrough. Memory lane!