Amato Bros

Savannah Pease

2024-04

Seriously, the food quality is unmatched every time. When you’re feeling something easy, THIS IS WHERE TO GO. Easy, but never mediocre, down to the side of cole slaw. Not to mention the affordability and convenience which makes it impossible not to stop in. Unfortunately, I only remembered to take a photo of our appetizer this visit. Our server, Angela is consistently professional, friendly, and extremely efficient. I will continue to bring my friends & family here!

Harriet

2023-08

We wanted an inexpensive dinner and this little place fit the bill, for sure. Denise behind the bar was as nice as she could be, and she'd be one of the reasons we'll come back. I had a Bay Breeze and my handsome dining partner had a Manhattan that was strangely reddish, but he liked it a lot. Piping hot mozzarella sticks started us off, with marinara that was equally hot. Normally we don't eat Cheese Wiz, but it was one of those days today when it was fine on the fries. We both had small steaks, mine with Cooper Sharp and his was a pizza steak with onions. They were not dry even if they looked it. Really nice people at the bar. I definitely recommend this place.

Antonio Kohlenberg

2024-04

Always great food and friendliest faces you can ever meet. Fried foods are cooked perfectly and cold sandwiches are prepared lovingly and even. So many options I can never get bored of the menu! The prices can be a little spicy but always worth it. Every visit is a worthwhile dream~Parking: Very limited parking spots. Try arriving in a few cars as possible or dropped off if you dive in.Wheelchair accessibility: Long ramp but no button for automatic door opening. Parking spot right by the entrance.

Karen Fernandez

2024-03

…More

billgrave

2023-05

…More

Amy R.

2024-03

Came for the first time after getting a recommendation from a Facebook page and the food and service was amazing! We will DEFINITELY be back. We moved to NJ from Philly, so we're harsh cheesesteak critics, but this place is absolutely delicious! I got mine on a seeded roll. It was soft and the meat wel seasoned. The caramelized onions and Cooper sharp made it outstanding. The crinkle fries are crispy, the wings are meaty. Highly recommend their Baton Rouge sauce! Already looking forward to our next visit.

Portia Lowther

2024-04

…More

D M

2024-03

…More

Louise Hollins

2022-05

…More

Edward Voluntad

2023-05

Nice place to meet locals and watch the game and get a great sandwich and fries. The servers are amiable and accommodating.Full bar with daily drink and sandwich specials.Reasonably priced.

Ansar M.

2023-05

Delicious food and excellent service! -Jim and Denise are the best. Let’s talk food - Their hoagies are top notch; I bounce back and forth with their old world Italian and their cheesesteak! Their cheesesteak is one of the best around, with 16oz of rib eye steak... I get it with Cooper, fried onions and long hots! 🌶 😋 🙌🏾🔥

Gregg Proscia Jr

2023-05

I discovered Amato Bros a few months ago, I consider myself a hoagie maniac, I’ve eaten hoagies all over. This is my all time favorite hoagie. I order the “American” it’s unbelievable. Every bite is better than the next and it’s always consistently amazing. Great service, kind staff. This place is old school in the best way possible. Fresh meats, the seeded bread is perfect. Hats off to Amato Bros for putting in the work to deliver an amazing product. Whoever put less than 5 stars here has no clue what they’re saying, look no further then here for the perfect meal.

Allan Crescenzo

2023-12

I should let this out because I might not get a seat next time I go. The chef has come up with these new special sandwiches and apps. They are incredible. The Italian hoagies are my favorite along with the chicken cutlet hoagies. I've gone off them to get these specials I hope they keep on doing them because they been great and something different. Thank you again.

Sheryl Roth

2024-01

As me and myHusband were enjoy our food for the first time here, it was unbelievable that the manager on duty felt the need to berate his employee and embarrass her in front of the entire restaurant. Very unprofessional and uncalled for. Treat ur employees better, she did not deserve to be treated in such an awful manner. Food good, service good, manager treatment of employees, worse I’ve seen. #getbettermanagement

Suzanne Smith

2023-12

…More

tracie beck

2023-05

Wow! Amazing food and incredible service from Jim the bartender. The cheesesteak (with Cooper) was insanely delish and the crinkle fries were perfect. Jim was so fun and extremely attentive, made us feel super welcome. First time here, won’t be the last!

Alyssa Moreno

2023-10

I luckily came across this spot after shopping for a new table across the street and was looking for some dinner after. Super friendly staff. Clean dining area and the food was affordable and tasty. It was a bonus that they had a full bar as well. The takeout area also seems really cool and also has some liquor to go options. I will for sure be back and stop for take out soon!

Melissa Evangelista

2024-04

…More

Er H

2023-07

…More

Jim “The Cheesesteak Guy” Pappas

2020-05

Thank Goodness I spent most of my adult life in New Jersey!! Another top cheesesteak is in New Jersey!! The seeded roll, too die for. The meat is easily top 5. Ordering off the menu has been working well for me lately so I went with the ‘Garlic Mushroom Cheesesteak.’ I was very happy I did. I still smell like garlic but that is the price I will pay to taste greatness!! Cape May Brewing 'the Bog' was the perfect accessories for this Cheesesteak.

Darryl Turner

2024-01

…More

Lundon Powell

2023-09

Tried a few weeks ago to order .. phone kept ringing and ringing .. not abnormal for this place , everyone kinda knows you gotta keep calling to you get someone . Cool no problem . Got picked up and hung up on twice .. when I finally got someone ( John ) I said hey I’m not sure what happened but I got hung up on twice .. “ we’ll you got us now what do you want “ . I didn’t order that night and just said never mind and hung up .Tried again tonight , everyone has bad days right ?Ordered over the phone - girl was blah on the phone and rushed but when your busy your busy I didn’t mind that .. expect when I went in to pick up the food . The girl couldn’t hear a customer on the phone and just put her on hold and asked John ( manager ) for help hearing her . His answer was just “ hang up on her “ . I should have known better than to pay for my food with that attitude towards customers but I did anyways since I already ordered it .While waiting John yelled at two employees over something stupid . I asked for a refund at this point .Remaining calm I said I didn’t like the way he treats employees and his response was what do you want . I said a refund , his answer was “ good “ .I love the food and sad we won’t be having it till John gets his attitude in check .

South

2023-05

Yummy chili but slightly too cold. I have tried 4 other soups at different times and they all could stand to be warmer. All the soups are yummy.

Lanena915

2023-12

…More

Vincent Bucolo

2023-08

…More

Jen Widrig

2023-10

I truly enjoy heading to this place it's a great relaxing experience.Great music, GREAT FOOD AND I MEAN DELICIOUS FOOD.The service is excellent from the waitresses(kelly) to the Bar- tenders. Dont pass on this place.Parking: I park at Dunkin Donuts

Zachary Smith

2024-03

…More

Rob A

2023-05

Really glad we swung in here for a bite tonight. Perfect spot for a family with a young baby since it's not the kind of spot where a kid who makes a bit of noise will ruin the experience of the others around. But it's still plenty nice enough so you don't feel like you're bringing your kid into a dive bar. The chicken cutlet hoagie I had was one of the best I've ever had. Clearly a fresh cutlet. Perfectly soft seeded roll. Ample portion size. Also, don't sleep on the side of meatballs. They were incredible. Service was top notch too. Our waitress was pleasant and attentive.We live right around the corner and have wanted to try this spot for a while. I can already tell we're going to be regulars.Vegetarian options: Plenty of meatless hoagie options.Parking: Not a huge parking lot

Nicole Lynne

2023-06

I got a Buffalo chicken quesadilla and it tasted like straight nail polish. I thought it was just me but had somebody else try it and they said it tasted and smelled like chemicals. I’m anticipating a trip to the hospital tonight because I genuinely don’t know what I just ingested. To be completely honest it was a disgrace.

silveo1

2024-05

…More