Pegasus I Restaurant

Tom Costroff

2024-02

…More

William Cassidy

2024-01

…More

Jenny

2024-04

…More

Dan the Man

2023-12

…More

terry visalli

2023-05

It’s my first time here at Pegasus and WOW 🤩 I’m very impressed the food was amazing!!! The service was very very good. The hospitality is like no other. The food was exactly what you ordered. The portions are super big. Come with an appetite. You will need it. The dessert was out of this world. You need to try their Jamaican chocolate moose cheesecake or maybe I have the name wrong but I know the server said Jamaican. And the cherry pie was good and the milkshake was awesome and very big too. The bathrooms are very clean and the dinning area very clean too. I will go back there again. If you never have gone I will recommend that you go and give it a try you will not regret it. I had a chicken lemon soup and it was good also. Everything that we eat there was awesome. The food was very tasty. They have a big selection of desserts. You want to eat everything that is there if you have a sweet tooth like I do. 😂 Thank you Pegasus for your wonderful service and food. I will come back with my family again.

Michelle Jost

2023-08

So Pegasus has been around since I was a kid and it has unfortunately taken a turn for the worst. We were here on a Sunday at 10am and we placed a breakfast order that took FOREVER to come out to our table. Our server Jenn was unkempt and not very enthusiastic - she never came back to our table to check on our food and I had to grab the hostess to let her know there was a problem with my meal. I ordered the Tuscany Benedict and asked to sub the sausage out with avocado. The poached eggs were hard boiled, the avocado was browning, and the basil was spoiled and rancid. It took so long that we had to leave and all I ended up having for breakfast was coffee. The breakfasts are completely overpriced. We ended up spending $20 on an omelette and coffee with a tip. The best part about our experience was the kind young man who was efficient and kept our coffees filled. We will not be returning.

Joi Dorr

2023-11

…More

Mackenzie Waldman

2024-04

…More

Elizabeth Toscano

2024-05

I maybe write one review a year, and I literally just left this diner. We got the worst table in the restaurant even though many were open, we were the very first table when you walk in the door, practically sitting with the register. Fine, we didn't ask to move, it was only a little drafty even though it's wet and rainy out. We were planning to be quick. The waitress (who was very, VERY sweet) saw that we were in a hurry and that I didn't look at the menu I just ordered buffalo chicken tenders and fries. My husband ordered a breakfast platter. When our meals came his was not hot, not cold but just kind of warm like it had been sitting out a while. And it had a small hair in which we didnt bother to mention be ause hed alreafy eaten half his meal anyeay. My meal? I got a plate of fries and a separate plate of 11 PIECES of chicken tenders. This was easily enough chicken for 3 people, maybe 4. And on top of that I don't know what kind of Buffalo sauce they used to toss the tenders in but it tasted terrible. I ate 3/4 of the smallest piece on the plate and realized if I don't send this back I'm paying for these, taking most of it home and eating these gross chicken tenders for the next 3 days as leftovers because I don't waste money or food. I HATE sending food back, I NEVER do it but in this instance I had to. When I said they were not good I also asked why is the portion so big and our waitress admitted that because it's dinner time she does not bother asking if you want the dinner size or the appetizer size, she just puts in the dinner size which is this enormous platter. Check padding??? She asked if I wanted anything else and I said no, I just ate the fries. They did take the chicken tenders off my bill, as they should have because I didn't eat them. Then my husband asked for an orange juice and she left to get it AGAIN without asking what size he wanted and when she returned he asked what size it was and she said a medium. Check padding #2. When I went to the register to pay I was feeling depressed and kind of gross after only eating fries so I got 3 chocolate covered strawberries to go. It's a treat and it's also fruit, so win-win. The person at the register asked if I'd like to tip on the card and since I only had large bills on me I said yes, she asked me how much I'd like to leave and saw me think about the tip for a second and she suggested that 20% would be $7 or $8. I nearly said yes when I realized she was trying to get me to tip on the strawberries I had gotten to go. CHECK PADDING #3. Beware of this place, be careful what you order, be specific about menu items and sizes and don't expect them to ask you, they will automatically try to upcharge you.

Brian Carlton

2023-05

My daughter and I love it here! Restaurant has been here for a long time and they’ve managed to keep the menu varied but tasty with a large list of specials. My daughter loves their chicken parmigiana which is a HUGE portion. I went with the surf n turf (prime rib cooked a perfect medium rare and seasoned just right, broiled stuffed shrimp which was fresh and delicious and a stuffed mushroom. For my sides, pickled beets and sweet potatoes). The staff is all friendly, our waitress tonight was terrific.

Rick B.

2023-11

Dinner atmosphere, great service, very good food.See my videos for the visuals. Tasted like it looks.Enjoy!

David King

2024-04

…More

Joanie Bada

2023-09

…More

Gerald Furniss

2024-04

…More

Jason Kinner

2018-05

One of the best diners around! The service here is always above and beyond! The food is excellent, the prices are very good, and the selection of menu items is plenty. During my most recent visit, the waitresses were so friendly and helpful that I can't wait to come back again! If ever in the area, be sure to stop in!

Nicholas Storozuk

2024-01

I am updating my review from 3 years ago. I had a bad experience there regarding my server disappearing several times and being short with me verbally. I genuinely didn't want to go back until my grandmom mentioned it's her favorite restaurant.Thankfully, that experience with her was made out to be much more enjoyable than before. The past three times I have gone, the Server named Tim makes sure my experience is better than before.He's always asking what my 17-month-old son needs to go with his meal. He has made a great meal suggestion for us every time. Most importantly, he corrected the mistakes that your other servers and cooks tainted my life with years ago. He took responsibility for something he didn't even do, which to me is a sign that he takes pride in his career when the one who made the mistake disappeared.Top notch food! And now I can finally say top notch service!

Janet Cohen

2023-11

…More

Ab Boo

2024-03

I was there for a seminar. The room we were in was nice, spacious, NOONE was sitting in another's space (like others I've been to). The food tho was not 'special'. The "roast beef w gravy & mashed potatoes"- roast beef was tender, plentiful but very bland. The gravy was 'canned" and the potatoes, several folks felt they tasted like instant. I had the shrimp Caesar salad. Had a few bits of "old very brown & wilted lettuce to remove, & another at our table had HAIR in hers and it was nowhere near a color match to her own hair. I had to ask for my water & raspberry tea several times before even water came out. Yes, they had a lot of folks to serve, and for the most part, kept all the orders correct. So it was 'just ok". That being said, they get A LOT of business....we don't know why, but they are fairly busy all the time. The chicken dish at our table was 'eh' - he picked it apart because the breading was very soggy.

Julie Silva

2024-01

My family had been going here for a decade and this past visit will be our last. The staff was rude, the food was cold and bland and when we apoke our feelings of the experience to management, she yelled at the server making it very awkward for us and to make this worse, the server confronted us tableside to ask us why we didnt speak to her personally. How uncomfortable for a holiday family brunch!

Brian

2023-05

Best restaurant in the area, good prices and specials. Very clean and nice decor. You will get your money's worth and have an enjoyable meal.

Terry Biauce

2024-03

…More

Sandy Phillips

2020-05

Food was awesome. Mussels slightly overcooked but everything else was terrific. Huge portions. Waitress was friendly and very attentive. If I lived locally this would be a weekly visit for me! Cheesecake is light but rich! Crab bisque was top notch!

Kimberly Klaitz

2024-02

Ordered a black and blue salad rare. The steak was cooked well done and I asked for extra blue cheese crumbles instead of mushroom and olives. There was barely any blue cheese crumbles. I went in my car to check the steak. Gave my dog a tiny piece of the steak went back in and was screamed at by some guy and he told me to never come back. First of all yelling at a customer is despicable to say the least and very embarrassing. Screaming at me in front of employees and other people waiting to get their food is just disgusting. And he said to never come back. Well no worries there. I will never go there again. Be warned people. This is going on every social media outlet I can find to warn others. He should be ashamed of himself!!!!! 0 stars if I could !

jodi Rodriguez

2024-02

…More

Kali Zoumas

2023-12

…More

Joseph McCullough

2023-11

…More

Tammy D.

2023-09

…More

E Baby

2024-04

Food is always good and prices are reasonable. One of the only places in the area that I order from!

The most Interesting man in the world

2024-04

…More

Hilary Shaud

2024-02

…More