Attilio's Villagio Restaurant & Pizzeria

Ruben Miller

2024-04

The pizza is par for the shore. The people are all locals, which I appreciate. Keeping the business local is important. The decor is fully Italian, old country. Small place, good atmosphere whether you're looking for quick pizza by the slice or in the back for a sit-down restaurant meal. Not the cheapest prices, but also not cheapest made.

Joseph Montalto

2024-04

…More

Joe Benti

2023-12

…More

John Blackstock

2024-03

popped in around 8:30pm. fresh pie was mid. Crust was not what I remembered coming out of this oven. Surprised to grab a slice to find a huge gaping hole in the crust. I worked as a pizzolaand would have tossed this one. took leftovers home but should have left them at the storeworse yet was it seemed by 8:45 the guy was putting chairs up and we felt pressured to leavewhat happened to this restaurant?

Ken Krall

2023-05

Best pizza in Lincroft. I lived in Jersey my whole life (I’m old), and I know good pizza.

William Funk

2024-02

…More

Siobhan Hansen

2019-05

This place is fantastic. My family has been coming here for years, it's our go to Italian spot. The pizza is top quality and the blackened chicken is to die for. Great service, good atmosphere. Little hole in the wall type place, very casual. Don't underestimate it though, they've got wonderful food.

J E

2021-05

Seriously? I paid 40 dollars for this? Farfalle con Pollo and Rigatoni Romano. Bland is an understatement. Maybe their pizza is good, I dont know. But this is my first impression. Wasted my money tonight.

Sandy Durant

2024-02

…More

Aaron Dirodrico

2023-06

Is very hungry just happened to be driving past this place randomly pulled in just to grab two slices on my way to the next job site and I was pleasantly surprised the pizza was absolutely delicious the toppings on there were very bountiful and there was no grease at all dripping from my pizza that is a clear indication that they do not use cheap ingredients/cheese. I highly recommend

Joe Pascarella

2024-03

…More

M. Kendrick

2019-05

Not thrilled. We purchased a full bottle of white sangria. As they are a BYOB with an option to purchase a bottle there. $25. It took a long time as they poured it into a ceramic pitcher overcut up oranges and apples. 80 % of the bottle. We weren't told they were going to do this until they brought it out. We dont drink that much, we each had a glass with our dinner. As we poured back the leftover wine there were dark crystalized pieces. It was the residue from the last bottle of RED sangria. The pitcher was never washed. The fruit was bitter and left pulp in the bottle that turned the wine rancid very quickly. They should not assume we were going to drink the whole bottle. They need to put fruit in the glasses and let the customer pour their own wine. $25 poured down the drain. Food was just OK, service was slow. They needed more waitresses.

Josh Langenberger

2023-06

Food was decent, but soured with deception. I called ahead and asked about Penne Vodka on the kids menu because it is my daughter's favorite meal. Josh said, it isn't normally on the kids menu, but he could make it for us. When I arrived around 5pm, we asked to sit in back and were the only table. The waitress asked if we knew what we wanted and I ordered a meatball calzone and three kids orders of Penne Vodka; it was a kids and dad night and I called ahead to avoid undo stress. The waitress said that they don't do that, and I said that I had called ahead and that Josh had said it was fine. The waitress asked me to wait and checked with someone in the front and returned to say, they could only offer the lunch portion because Josh thought I only wanted one kids order. The waitress explained that it was exactly the same portion as the kids portion and I agreed. Well, it was the lunch portion at almost twice the price of any kids menu item. I paid $43 for three portions of lunch pasta and a shared sliced hogie roll. In hindsight, I should have split a dinner portion. In the fairness of the review, the food is decent, service (from our waitress), fair, and business honesty low. Restaurant competiton is fierce, and I went out of my way once to visit, but never again.

Veronica CS

2023-05

Walked in for dinner at 9:10pm today and we were advised that the kitchen would be closing in 15-20min. We were waiting for the girl to come over and take our order but she never did. I went up to the counter to place my order and after ordering she asked if it was to go or dine in. I stated that it was for dine In, she then went on to say that they were closing by 9:30 and it would need to be to go. I told her that if we didn’t have a choice of dining in that we would need to take it even though we had 30min-1hr ride home and we had 3 kids with us that would need to wait to have dinner now. I then asked what pizza they had for us to be able to just dine in. The girl said that the slices that were out, which really didn’t give us much choice. She then went on to ask if I just wanted to cancel our order. By then I told her to just cancel due to the fact that she was very rude because she just wanted to close early. There were two women having dinner and the one woman confirmed that they were supposed to be open until 10pm. As I was leaving, I asked for the owners phone number to make him aware of this situation. The girl then stated that the owner was her father. She should be ashamed of how she’s treating customers and how she’s handling her fathers business. I never post anything negative about a business but this treatment was unacceptable.

Andrew Stavish

2023-05

First time trying this place. Ordered delivery and the pizza arrived a complete mess, with all of the cheese and toppings on one side and the rest of the pizza completely bare. The pizza was totally inedible. Restaurant owner blamed the driver, didn't apologize, and didn't offer any recourse. Told me not to order again if I wasn't happy. Absolutely horrible quality pizza and even worse customer service.Oh, and for the record, it almost certainly wasn’t (only) the driver’s fault. For the one or two slices that were somewhat intact, the cheese and toppings immediately slid off when I picked the slices up.

Jim Otto

2024-03

…More

Deirdre 디어드라 McKPrice

2023-05

…More

Ciro Ascione

2024-02

…More

Matthew Shoukas

2023-07

…More

Christin Anfibio

2023-05

If I could leave zero stars I would. Probably the worst food at a pizzeria I have ever experienced. Had a chic parm Stromboli and my husband had a plain slice and a chicken slice. The chicken was like rubber and the food had zero taste to it. Awful. If you're headed here turn around.

George S

2022-05

Medium pizza was delicious. Didn't realize we ordered in the wrong place. Ordered up front, but wantet the dining room. They were very accomodating, and allowed us to pick up the rest of the meal in the dining room where the servers were fantastic. The home made desserts were fantastic! I highly recommend this place!

Greg B.

2023-05

We live locally and have tried this place about 5 or 6 times to give it a chance - their pizza is not very good. Gave it many chances, tried different slices and pies. Their customer service is not very good either. Many better options for good pizza in the area.

Ethan Werrlein

2023-05

Delicious Italian meals and a wide variety of selections. There is also a pizzeria. The restaurant seating area has an interior design in the style of a village of Italy. Fantastic meats with fresh bread. Tons of pasta choices plus salads and sandwiches.Wheelchair accessibility: Restaurant is getting level with double wide storefront doors.

Paul Dawson

2023-05

…More

Doug Ward

2020-05

Stopped in for lunch, great atmosphere. The aroma of fresh pizza in the air stop you in you tracks. There is a large dining area for large groups. I picked up 2 chicken parmigiana slices, very satisfying. I came in starving, full & relieved. The white pizza & the granny pizza looked great, I will have to try next time.

Amy Palma

2023-05

Ordered the Rigatoni a la vodka from here for years. Even when I moved away, I would go out of my way for it. Now it doesn't taste the same. Chicken tastes rubbery, sauce is watered down and has no taste. Bring back the old and better recipe!

Thomas Yacullo

2023-09

…More

W Barcliffe

2021-05

Was the easiest place to grab some food to go while in the area. Darn glad I did. Best slice I've had since the 90s. Perfect crust, perfect ratio of sauce to cheese to crust. And the price wasnt so bad either. Wish I had more time, would have picked up pie to bring home. At 11/10 would recommend.

Jimmy Wen

2019-05

I had an amazing first experience here! The food was great, as were the portions and prices for burgers. The staff were very responsive and continuously checked up on me even during the rush. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, while the lighting and decorations really give it a quaint, relaxing mood. Definitely going to come back!

Michael Kozuch

2023-11

…More