Lake Hiawatha Dairy

Jennifer Pickett

2023-08

This is one of the best I’ve cream places in the area! So many different cone portions. A large variety of ice cream options and the most adorable sitting area. I had the NY cheesecake ice cream, my friend got the strawberry with chocolate fudge and my husband got the coffee with chocolate fudge. I normally love denville dairy, but this place was 100% better in that they had more options of ice cream and you can definitely get a large group together for ice cream here. I honestly think this would be great for a party. If you want some amazing ice cream in Morris county or Parsipanny, this is the place to go! Loved it

Sam Deo

2024-02

…More

Cami H

2023-09

Lake Hiawatha Dairy is one of the best ice cream parlors in town. Delicious and interesting flavors, I tried the Blueberry Pie and NY Cheesecake. Also the people running the store are kind and helpful, and made great flavor recommendations. Try them out!

shortroundChris

2024-04

Haven't been here in a LONG time and I grew up here. They have so many new flavors to choose from. Today I got a medium cup whoch gets you 3 scoops. I got the Taco Tuesday, PBnJ, and the Coach. Sooooo delicious. Flavor overload. I taste tested the Bees Knees, which is like a Graham cracker type flavor. That was pretty good too. Definitely will get next time. Medium costed just under $6. Not bad for great quality ice cream. Texture was perfect as well. Nice to come back to my childhood spot. I lived around the corner back then. They expanded the place so there is now more seating which is nice.

Paul Dreifuss

2024-02

…More

Raunak Choudhary

2023-08

We ordered cotton candy and cheesecake one ..Sweeter in taste but freshness achieved.Tried their Sundae too.

styldsteel1

2020-05

This is the best ice cream place in the world. We bought two scoop sundaes, and ice cream cupcakes and they are as delicious as they are beautiful. The service is wonderful. They have many flavors to choose from. They do amazing custom work. Their prices are very reasonable. I would highly recommend them.

Sharon Barbosa

2024-01

…More

s Halstead

2023-10

I visited this establishment yesterday seeking a hot fudge sundae with chopped nuts. I was informed that If I added nuts, it was not considered a sundae?? So, the nuts and hot fudge were charged separately as additional toppings. I have NEVER heard of such a things.Moreover, neither the ice cream or hot fudge were anything spectacular. I would not recommend this place.

Makeda Rose

2023-11

…More

Ajay Sanghvi

2020-05

Awesome. So many varieties of FRESH icecreams. Mouth Watering and delicious. Home made daily preparations. One must enjoy new varieties at least once a week.

Y J Skimelis

2023-12

I got a craving & got 2 items. A cone, filled w/2 flavors: dark chocolate & coconut ice cream, the 2nd item, was a cup w/3 different flavors for someone else. They were delicious & really hit the spot. The team, in there, was super helpful & attentive. You should stop in, take a few minutes of your time to enjoy & savor the sheer pleasure your body feels, as it reacts to that special treat you've just consumed. Enjoy the moments.Parking: Municipal parking nearbyKid-friendliness: Different flavors & decorated to appeal to kids & the kid in the adults. Fun, playful.

Dan Carey

2023-11

This place is great! The products and service are always #1. Stop in and see for yourself.

Hafsa

2021-05

The owner Karen would argue at length with the customer and patronize the customer rather than finding a way to make her customer happy. I’ve been getting ice cream from this place for years and I definitely will not be going back anymore. She is very unprofessional and has zero understanding of what customer service means. If you have an issue with your ice cream the whole world has to come complain about it or else she won’t believe you, because your individual experience is not respected as a customer. She literally told me that something might have been wrong with my taste buds because no one else complained and refused to even exchange my ice cream. She said I can’t expect the ice cream to taste the same every time because its handmade but what she doesn’t understand is that I never complained about it for years because a little bit of difference in flavor makes no difference to me but this time her ice cream was very different and wasn’t even the same color as usual. She refused to understand where I was coming from and just kept on arguing and arguing and refusing to exchange the product for me. She said theres no food place that will exchange food for you if you’re not happy with it and that is wrong. Not everyones customer service is as bad as hers. I used to bring a lot of family and friends here and bought a lot of their holiday cupcakes sadly she thought it was better to lose hundreds of dollars in business instead of exchanging a $10 quart of ice cream.RESPONSE to owners response on Adeel’s review:I feel very sorry to see that you as a business owner doesn’t understand that when a customer isn’t satisfied with your product, you shouldn’t patronize them and be unprofessional with them they deserve a better experience. You mention that you basically gave me a free full quart of ice cream between the CUP of ice cream you gave me to take home for free and the $5 off offer for the $10 quart I bought. Please stop lying. You barely gave me a kiddie scoop in the smallest cup you had. I’ve seen people give samples better than that. Both me and my spouse posted a one star review because that was the experience both of us felt. The ice cream you gave wasn’t consistent with the flavor Ive been tasting for years (without any complaint). I wasn’t planning on returning but it really was that different. You made me feel as though I bought a quart of ice cream only to eat a scoop of it and return to you. I always bought a quart from your place because thats how much I enjoyed your ice cream but thanks to your terrible attitude, we will never step into your place again. You made me feel bad for genuinely asking you for an exchange. Ill post a pic to show how much of the quart I actually consumed before I brought it back to you. The quart I bought clearly only has pink ice cream with lines of blue usually your ice cream has an equal amount of pink and blue. The sample you gave for me to test afterwards was mint green and pink. You said go home taste this and then call me, when i called you and told you that the quart you gave is very different from this, you still said I cant refund or exchange. You kept arguing with me and not wanting to make things right even though I kept hearing someone in the back telling you differently. You seem to have an ego issue and its quite visible in your responses to all your unsatisfied customers. You would rather lose all the business a customer would love to give you instead of respecting their experience and making things right for that one off experience.

Ashley Franck

2020-05

We always order our summer birthday cakes from here and they are always great! You can select whatever combination of ice creams and fillings you want. We ordered a Baby Shark themed cake this weekend and they did an amazing job.

Irene M. Candelaria

2023-10

Better than the denville dairy! All staff are always super nice and friendly even during busy hours in the summer. Their ice cream cakes are to die for!

samir Mahmoud

2020-05

I had the gram crunch and chocolate brownie on a waffle cone. It's really good ice cream. The service was friendly and quick. Good food, good service I'll be back again.

Victoria Judware

2023-05

Such a cute little ice cream shop! I'm from out of town and had a craving for ice cream so decided to stop here and the amount of flavors they had were incredible! Would recommend anyone to stop by for a visit. I had the brownie batter and it was so good!

Jonathan Hannah

2023-06

Beautiful place. They have a public bathroom and tons of great ice cream.

Molly Hines

2022-05

Great ice cream at a fair price! I love their unique flavors, such as Mother Earth (pictured here) 🌎

Harry Patel

2023-05

I am living nearby and tried ice cream of this shop with my family. We had mix feelings about the place. Although the shop looks nice with nice small town setting in the lap of Lake Hiawatha, the eatery offers low range of flavors and somewhat I would say overly sweetened ice cream flavors. We tried three different flavors among which we only liked Vanilla which is not much to go on for any ice cream parlor. It’s also bit more pricey when compared to other local shops.

Sid Johnston

2023-07

One of the few mom and pops you see in the area. There's a place to sit and take selfies, but I never see anyone doing that. It's mostly staffed by teenagers, a rare sight in this economy. And yeah, they have ice cream, which gives it a default five stars.

Melissa Gencarelli

2023-05

They do wonderful ice cream cakes for special occasions, their homemade ice cream is delicious, the employees are nice, the business supports local children's sporting events and similar events, and their new expanded parlor and seating area is lovely, spacious, clean and decorated for the specific season. 5 stars all around, I highly recommend this ice cream shop without hesitation!

Tara N

2023-10

The most underrated ice cream spot in Morris county. They make the best ice cream cakes in the area hands down

Jeffrey Shortway

2023-07

Always amazing ice cream and great cakes too!

Kinjal Shah

2023-09

BAD EXPERIENCE! VERY RUDE STAFFS AND SLOW SERVICES. THE STAFF IS NOT TRAINED PROPERLY TO SERVE WITH MANNERS. The girl taking long time to make SPLIT banana dish. And after tht we want to tryout flavors since we have been 1st time.since they got crowded, they can't handle and started yelling at me and my son.VERY DISAPPOINTED WITH THEIR RUDE BEHAVIOR. THEY TOTALLY INSTULTED US.

Dan Matarazzo

2023-05

Great ice cream, friendly staff, and a wide selection of flavors make this small ice cream shop stand out. They are one of the few places to get dole whip in this area, so stop by and try some.They've recently doubled their size and added an indoor seating area.

sally zidan

2021-05

Honestly, I was looking for a place to get an ice cream cake from last minute for mothers day and I saw this place across from my favorite restaurant and I said let me give it a try. Little pricey for 8 inch ice cream cake 24.99 dollar but It is worth it. Nice rich flavor and beautiful colors. The owner and his staff were very friendly. I will be considering going back for different occasions.

Daria Bailey

2023-05

Go to Curly's in Boonton, only 10 minutes away. The customer service here is horrible. I asked for a small cup and to buy a larger separate cup as I knew my toppings would spill over. They gave me such a hard time about it. They didn't smile once from the time I walked in with my 6 year old daughter. Ice cream is supposed to be fun. When we go to Curly's, there are more flavors, smiles from start to finish, and the prices are cheaper and the portions larger.

Shawn Ashley

2023-10

Really kind staff. Excellent flavors of ice cream. Will come back 1000 more times