Ye Olde Antique & Curiosity Shop

Sanjay Gupta

2023-11

an antique shop that buys and sells antiques and curiosities.my first question was: how did you get all this stuff...Owner Susie Nerger told us - that they are going to houses that are moving and buy their stuff or people come and drop their stuff and they sell at suitable prices. You will find a treasure trove of high-quality antiques, collectibles, and curiosities that they procure daily!Dolls, toys, figurines, paintings, kitchen items, typewriters, hookahs, college stationery, old books, means you name it and you shall find it here - it is definitely fun while exploring the shopDefinitely keep this place as a regular stop on the "hunting" trail. The owners are super friendly, welcoming, and knowledgeable.

Justin Rogers-Cooper

2024-02

Fun and diverse collection of antiques, including toys, signs, pictures, vinyl, glassware, bottles, and curios of all kinds. Generally high quality items and collectibles, from branded vintage products to personal photos and family relics. Friendly ownership. Nice spot.

Christopher Brady

2023-12

Absolute amazing store with so much to find all at a reasonable price and authentic. The owner works super hard with her family to provide a great and wide selection of items you wouldn’t find elsewhere. Last year I bought a snurfer antique snowboard that my family had for generations but was lost in the shuffle of life. Reasonably priced and able to work with the owner.10/10 would recommend the shop and feeling good about supporting a local family owned and operated business.

Heather Kilduff

2024-03

Came in looking for wedding decor and came away a 4life customer. Most definitely my favorite antique shop I have been too. Could spend hours upon hours exploring this place. Owners are lovely and add to the charm of their shop. Their deep appreciation for unique historical items is reflected through wonderful conversation. I already know I will be purchasing items from their store for my future home and for many more occasions.

Peter Deane

2024-04

First, I should come clean... I've never been to Ye Olde Antique & Curiosity Shop in Flemington NJ. I mean, I have been to Flemington NJ... several times. I live nearby and I can safely say there are several shops in Flemington that are worthy of enjoyment.However at the moment I am in a craft brewery in New Orleans, where I was encouraged to violate the sacred tenets of Google Reviewing by the sibilant whisper of a long-absent ballpoint pen on the age-darkened flank of a Giant Jenga Piece.Whoever you are, long-lost Google Review Cheater of Flemington New Jersey, your ploy has finally worked. Someone is finally writing the review you demanded so long ago, when you stabbed your demands into toy blocks on your trip to the City That Care Forgot, and I hope it is everything you wanted it to be.Because now I know where you are from. And I'm coming home to you.

Robert From NY

2023-05

Ye Olde Antique shop is filled to the brim with items to look through.. toys, glassware, pins, garden items .. you name it it might be in there!

Jonathan Fadok

2024-01

Bought an 18th century Jenga set here! Came with a free Chewbacca record and body wax

Susan Crossley

2023-05

We love Susie and her shop! My 10-year-old boy thinks this store is heaven on earth. Last year for Christmas he got an incredible collection of World War II model airplanes. For this year’s birthday he got a dozen vintage GI Joe figures with accessories. Shopping here is so much better than buying new plastic junk. Susie is so kind to him.

Lukas Faering

2024-03

A little bit of just about everything. Old toys, tools, jewelry, bottles-- lots of old trinkets and general home+hobby goods.

ken nerger

2023-05

This shop is simply incredible! Featuring all authentic antiques and vintage items it is definitely a destination point that is well worth the visit.

Linda Greene

2023-05

Ken Nerger helped clean out my co-op prior to placing it for sale. During the stressful process of disposing of a lifetime of memories, he worked to deadline and his upbeat personality was a real asset. Ken is conscientious and a pleasure to know. I highly recommend him.

Kelly Hobson

2022-05

We always find something unique every time we go. This place really takes me back to my childhood. My toddler loves the Barbie collection and my teenager loves the vintage watches. Great prices and selection.

Thomas Visicaro

2022-05

My wife and I visited this past weekend. The owner is very nice and really knows his stuff! The shop is filled with a wide variety of antiques. We will definitely be going back!

James Robinson

2018-05

Ken helped me with the final stage of a home sale. He and Susie bought several items from me based on my LetGo ads (that's how we met). He took away a lot of items, donated whatever he could to Habitat for Humanity (and got me a receipt for tax purposes), and he did several repairs that made the walk-through at closing a breeze. Haven't been to their store, so cannot review that. Reliable, prompt and communicative.

Steve W

2023-05

Okay. This is a must visit. It is one of the best organized and curated shops of it's kind. It has lots of pop culture collectibles, glass and hard to find items. It's worth a trip, if you are anywhere near it or passing through.

Linda Guadagnino

2022-05

We had some family heirlooms thar we wanted to sell. We went to the shop and Suzie and Ken were very knowledgeable and helpful. After Ken did extensive research on our items they offered us what we felt was a fair value. Would certainly recommend visiting the store and seeking their advice and service

Adam Cox

2023-07

Really incredible shop! Quality pilsners, and great ambience. I take every opportunity I have to visit :)

Marten Sjoquist

2021-05

Very friendly owners and great selection. Can’t recommend highly enough!

Tom Mulhern

2018-05

I found ken and Susie to provide excellent service in the conduct of an estate sale.Both are well informed in a wide array of items and operate the sale in a professional, efficient and courteous mannner. They are honest,hard working,high energy people who executed all aspects of the sale from publicizing it,organizing and pricing items ,selling the merchandise and cleaning afterwards and disposing of unsold and unwanted items.....all the while they were pleasant and engaging to work with.I highly recommend them.Tom mulhern,ph.d.

Jess D

2019-05

It’s a small shop but it has nice and interesting things inside! Really liked the variety of items and it was cool to see the unique things they were selling. Had a nice visit coming here during the flea market event that was going on in town!

Marta Williams

2021-05

An absolute treasure of an antiques store! Excellent selection of items, from old tools to holiday decor to Disneyana and toys. Looks small from the outside, but expect to spend some time here, there’s so much to see!

Craig Eckstein

2022-05

This is one of the better antique stores in New Jersey. They are extremely helpful and friendly. They work with a small great staff if anybody is looking to an estate sale.

Sp3cTre 5iVe

2023-05

Really nice place, nice staff and lots of odds and ends, only problem is that many of the old tools are incredibly overpriced

Lucy Contegiacomo

2022-05

Susie made my day found some fabulous finds at great prices…super sweet and kind love her will be visiting again in the spring!!!

Bill Ward

2023-10

nice items, but just too high priced....i guess it is "the area" - lady is friendly, now come down to earth with prices and MOVE PRODUCT

qspawnq

2021-05

I cannot visit Galloway without visiting Ye Old!!! So much for the eye to see and the mind to learn. It’s like disney land for antique fans!!!

Kelly Kulmatycky

2022-05

Wonderful shop filled with beautiful antiques. Owner was a pleasure to talk to. Can’t wait to visit again

Lee West

2023-05

A lot of cool collections to look through. The lady working there was very helpful showing me where to look through things.

Michael Randazzo

2018-05

Very interesting, get lost in time great shop!

Sabol Rodgers

2023-06

From New Orleans