Columbus Agway

Anthony's Glass Service, LLC

2023-08

Awesome pricing without out the big chain store pricing actually a much better product to. At more then 50 % less. I remember going here in the 70' and 80s 's with my grandfather. Unfortunately I just started going again. These are trips now I get to drive love you dad remember you letting me sit on your lap. Great people they will direct you to what you need to have the best lawn on the block my grandfather showed me thanks Agway!!!!!!!

Todd Adams

2024-04

Great shop and great staff that work there.They have lots of items for everyone, from seed to feed. Ask about discounts on bulk, that depends on time of year and item. We get the peanuts and corn for animals that like to visit us.Not Big Box. Lots of items specifically for this area.

Bob Zelley

2023-05

Nothing better then the odor of birdseed, fertilizer and grass seed under one roof.Bought 160 pounds of high quality seed for $160., q deer salt block. Q bat house and excellent new feeder . Also 3 50 pound blue bags of large crystal salt . I looked up the definition of farm and country and a picture of an old agway was shown. I appreciated the young guys helping me load my vehicle.

Anna Calaiaro

2023-12

I buy bird food and dog treats flower plants Veggie plants, honey, flower seeds, spider deterent, liquid ant baits, no need for exterminator! Excellent choices, quality, service and pricing, there is even a Bird Seed Club to earn free seed! Amazing place, it began as a farm supply,and you know Farmers don't play,they have chick's to buy in Spring for raising and eggs. They have Farmers Almanac. It's like meeting up with Ling time friends when I stop in wonderful family owned business. If you have a problem - they have a fix. Simply amazing.

Donna Pearce

2024-02

They had exactly what I wanted that I couldn’t find anywhere else- plain clay cat litter- and the man carried the 40 pound bag out to my car for me without my even asking! I love the historic farm building!

Bill Plowman

2023-11

Awesome people there and they ALWAYS have whatever you need!!

Just Vince (Vegan Trucker Su)

2023-05

Small place. Good supply for locals. Plenty of room to pull in with a tractor-trailer. Easy in-and-out. Fairly quick to load. Polite staff.

Glenn Andrew

2024-04

Love that place has everything

richard standish

2023-06

When Tractor Supply doesn't have what you're looking for, you just might find it at Agway, and it may even be cheaper, too. Nice folks

Dave Potts

2021-05

I used to go into this store with my dad, way back in the 60s. The smell of sweet molasses fills the air, even today, if you into the back warehouse. Wes, the manager, runs a happy ship at this Agway,, and it is a real pleasure to step back in time to see what a country feed store was really like.

Terri Taylor

2023-05

I always get salt for my waiter softener from this Agway. Still the best price even though they're the farthest from me. Awesome customer service, too.

Juliana Lykins

2023-06

Best feed store! Helpful, kind staff, most affordable prices on quality products! 10 out of 10!

Michael Kocsis

2019-05

This Agway in Columbus NJ has everything you need for your pet needs. Good pricing on all feeds and seeds. The management is something special too. The manager/owner did me a special on a gift certificate and he will know the good deed he did! I will continue to use this Agway store for all my needs due to his kindness and he knows why. Thank you again and see you soon!

Sharon Ezzo

2021-05

All employees at the store have always been very kind understanding and professional. I've been there a variety of times and each time they listen to my concerns and what I'm trying to do and they always have me leaving satisfied and a very happy customer

Nancy Krangar

2023-05

Very reasonable prices, kind sales people and has the veggies for our Spring Garden including our Scotch Bonnet Peppers, Bell Peppers, Cucumbers and Tomatoes!

Osama Sinan

2022-05

They always seem to have whatever I am looking for. I randomly wanted to buy Alfalfa seeds last week and I called a million places and none of them had it except for agway. They also carry wheat feed which I couldn’t really find anywhere else

James

2021-05

Very knowledgeable and friendly staff. Great prices and selection. take the time to stop by to find for yourself how great this store is.

Jessica Gerbavac

2021-05

Super nice guy who helped me get chicks today. Very friendly. Had a great selection of items for all kinds of animals.

Kathryn Swogger

2018-05

So disappointed. I have bought chickens from the Columbus agway in the past, but this year I called ahead to verify that they had the varieties in that were advertised on the website. The person who answered seemed annoyed that I would ask and named a few, but then said, "and a couple others". I called back to ask about a specific kind and he just yelled "no!" And hung up on me. They just lost a customer today.

Lance Gleco

2021-05

The store takes me back to the late 50's...I think I may run into Barney and Andy coming into the store.. it smells like the farm store...I enjoy visiting and buying the products I need there...the help are always nice and kind...

gina walicki

2018-05

Love the place - Nice staff who are always friendly and helpful - We have recently got a dozen of baby chicks from there in the late spring - All 12 are healthy and thriving - Only place we go to get our supplies

Tammy 333

2020-05

Very helpful and pleasant. Like the warranty on tools/shovels. They stock bag balm and most places don't.

Frank Mirabile

2020-05

I gave five stars to Columbus Agway very good place to shop for Farm equipment and chickens where's the manager that runs the store is a very nice guy helps you with your needs show is John when Wes is not there very nice place very nice people I recommend the store thank you

Bilbo Baggins

2022-05

Very nice place. Small selects but what they do have is high quality.

Alex Mishkovsky

2021-05

Small but pretty well stocked agricultural supply. Friendly and helpful clerk. Large warehouse area for bulkier items.

RA Hensel

2021-05

Nice country style farm store. Friendly people, l will have no problem doing business with them in the future.

Small Fry

2018-05

It's one of those old-fashioned type places. But they have everything in the staff is very nice. Reasonable prices etc.. :)

Erin A.

2019-05

Staff is always helpful and friendly. Order pay and they load. My girls love the non gmo layer feed.

Steven Couitt

2022-05

They have the best selection of birrd seed and all your yard needs as well as live chicks

Sara Buchanan

2019-05

Friendly, nice staff. Prices are much higher than I expected; as a result, I shop at other stores for my horse feed.