Bay Head Cheese Shop & Bottles Too

Windsor Terrace

2024-02

Newly rearranged so clerk had some trouble finding cheeses. An old school cheese shop! Saw some arrangements that were going out that looked really lovely too.

Brian Shore

2024-01

Can't say enough great things about this place! Great selection of everything you need for a cocktail party! Super nice folks, family run!

Heather Mershon

2023-09

Great selection. What brought me back in was the INDIAN DIP! So tasty!

Patty Oneill

2023-05

Have loved this store since 1975 when I was 16, and purchased cheese spreads and crackers , my favorite. They expanded but wine is too expensive. I love the fig,and ginger spread the best on bread or crackers.

Stef C

2023-05

Shop owners were so pleasant, patient, and helpful to us as we tried to decide which cheeses to buy for our new cheese board. We were offered tastes of many different cheeses. Cheeses we purchased were well-wrapped and labeled so we knew which cheeses were which. We will visit again soon. Good learning experience for us with yummy reward.

Austin Jennings

2022-05

I had an excellent pimento cheese spread and refreshing watermelon gazpacho! Top of line quality in their homemade creations. The owners are amazing people, very helpful and kind. I love the atmosphere in this place. After you select your delicious cheese, the next room holds a number of top rated wines to compliment! A one stop shop for cheese, wine, and lots of other goodies. Check them out! Prices are reasonable.

J T

2023-05

I love this little cheese shop! It's small and quaint but definitely packs a punch! Everything charcuterie is in this place! Do yourself a favor and get the apricot cheese spread! It's one of my favorite things to get and is now a staple at family gatherings.

Karen Peters

2023-09

Lovely shop and owners. Nice selection of cheeses, wines and nibbles for your charcuterie board. Try the cheese spreads too!

Breanna Poinsett

2023-05

The owner was very knowledgeable and made sure we had a great experience. The shop was adorable and clean. Homemade soup was amazing- will definitely be back again soon. Thank you!

Jon Burns

2020-05

This place is WONDERFUL! These guys treated us so well and the food was put of this world. I highly recommend the mac and cheese and the quishe!

Dr Stephanie Huth Lipnicki, DACM, LAc

2020-05

Such an amazing selection. My sister is a chef and I often lament over trying to give her the perfect gift. At Christmas, they put together a beautiful basket with a cheese that my chef sister (who is a Cheese Monger) loved, along with a wine and some other goodies. Cannot recommend their shop enough. Love your local!

Richard Tobin

2023-05

I didn’t know that they made quiche and cheesecake until recently. Last night for dessert we had the cheesecake. I highly recommend the cheesecake! Very good

Clarke Thomas

2023-05

Large selection of wine & crackers/chips. Small selection of liquor (behind register) & beer. Delicious soups. Many cheese dips & eclectic cheese selection

Rosemary McC

2022-05

I drove 30 minutes to check out this cheese shop. Disappointed in the knowledge of the ladies behind the counter when asked about selections, specifically their Bleu cheeses. Perhaps they should offer small tastes to entice customers to purchase more.

michelle gourley

2019-05

Cute little store that has cheese and quiche too. A small wine and beer selection. And also bottles of booze as well. The people that work there are very friendly. And we were there on a saturday late afternoon and were able to taste a blend wine, which was very nice too.

Tiffany R

2023-05

Lovely shop with good wine, and good cheese. It also has spirits, and other things that go with cheese and wine! Great service as well!

Kristin Kearns

2022-05

The most original, authentic, gourmet cheese and specialty shop in the ocean county area. One of a kind, family owned, passionate and fresh. Please keep this amazing family in mind as they pour their hearts into the industry, Covid sucks but they rule! Also, they have wine and beer! Yay thank you guys!

Mary Ann Belliveau

2016-05

Lovely store. Owner does excellent home made quiche, soups and apps. Cheese selection is wonderful. She also carries a nice selection of wine, etc. Great to bring home or to a party!

Trevor Raimann

2023-05

Fantastic shop for the finest wines and cheeses in the area. Be sure to stop in! Very friendly staff and terrific selections.

Jane Lance White

2022-05

Everyone at the store knows what cheese goes with what cracker and they have suggestions if you are confused. Delicious homemade soups, quiches and hors d'oeuvres. Beautiful gift baskets too.

mary ellen jacobs

2023-05

Lovely store!! Wonderful owners. Best cheese monger in NJ. home made quiche it a real show stopper

Valentino B Borrelli Jr.

2022-05

Great little shop. Wine, Beer, Liquor,. All kinds of cheese, crackers, cheese baskets for presents. Cutting boards and cheese spread knives. Jellies and spreads also.

Katheryn Tibok

2019-05

This is not the Bay Head Cheese Shop that it once was. I found the shop to be lacking in variety and learned that they no longer carried certain items because they were too perishable. Sounds to me as though these products are not selling quickly. I imagine sales must slow considerably in the off season.

Brian Buck

2020-05

Great products, only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because the man who works there doesn't know much about cheese, or seem really that interested, I spent about 140 dollars on this and that, will come back, came 2 times before since it changes hands.

Pamela White

2019-05

Excellent wine selection, wonderful assortment of cheeses and gourmet items .Amazing homemade quiches and soups.

Kim Jasaitis

2019-05

Very nice clean wonderful selection of cheese, quiche and wines. Nice place to stop if your having company!

Tonya Pizzuro

2020-05

Great place to shop for cheese. The owner knows a lot about cheese and wine pairing and is very helpful.

Suzy Marshall

2019-05

Always a great spot to pick up a nice gift to take to someone house. All cheeses are delcious!

Matt Rampone

2017-05

Great wine and cheese selections. Best place around for this type of stuff

Jean Barclay Mastrangelo

2018-05

Cute little place in a little beach town. Great cheeses both traditional and creative mixes.