Seitter's Market

Robert McClain

2024-01

I recommend Save a Lot if you're grocery shopping in New Haven.Seitter's has a reasonably adequate selection, slightly higher prices than I expected, and a mostly friendly staff... one problem.I entered the store with bags from another local business and put them in my cart. I was maybe 20 feet inside the store before I was approached and asked to leave my CART at the register... My response was "I intend to use my cart for shopping". I was asked to remove the bags and leave them at register 3. What I wanted to say was "Do I look like a thief? No, I don't." I would suggest a revision of your store policy, or perhaps criminal profiling courses for your employees.Personally, I won't be returning to this store. I do not appreciate being humiliated and treated like a thief.

Lauren Crockett

2023-12

Lisa and her team with Front Street Catering out of Seitter's Market are amazing! We got so many compliments on our wedding food. Guest's said that it was the best wedding food they've had, and we agree! My husband and I want to make the trip just to get a plate at the market soon. 10/10 recommend.

Abigail Shipley

2023-10

We used Seitter's Market for our wedding catering as well as cake and everything was amazing. We received countless compliments on the food and the pricing was very affordable. Lisa and her team were wonderful to work with throughout the process and on the day of the event.

David L Kelley (Dave)

2023-05

Awesome place. They always have hometown exclusives no one else has. Staff always friendly and helpful. Beautiful store. Got to go see them. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Linda Kleinheider

2024-04

Great Store !!!! Friendly

Shauna O'Toole

2017-05

Great customer service. Clean, nice store. This company supports local non-profit efforts too.

Ryan traughber

2023-08

A great family owned store in rural New Haven, nice compact quick friendlyNeat and clean actual check out lane and no do it yourself check outUser-friendly

Linda Cherry

2024-01

Absolutely wonderful family community grocery.

Scot Gingerich

2020-05

These people are amazing! They recently catered our daughter's wedding, made the cake and the flowers. Most of the arrangements were made online or by phone since we are out-of-town. They are extremely nice and helpful and the prices very reasonable. We had many comments of, "Best wedding food ever!"Thank you so much, Seitters Market, for helping our event to go so well!

Michael Lane

2023-05

Very nice market clean well stocked prices are just as good as anywhere else. People are friendly too. Just wish they would stock some carton milk, milk taste better in the carton.

Lauren Cobb

2021-05

I used Seitter's Market for my florist and baker for my wedding and they were wonderful!! Paula, was amazing to work with. She was quick to respond to emails and would send picture updates along the way. My bouquets were absolutely beautiful and exactly what I was wanting. And my cupcakes were so good, I got so many compliments! I would highly recommend Seitter's!!

Laura German

2019-05

Had a great experience working with Lisa today she was very helpful with helping my niece Beth to pick out her wedding cake. Thank you get much Lisa!!! And Thank you Patty Hudson for helping us getting things setup.

T Jay

2023-05

I used to like this place but there has been alot brown meat and some I bought and opened was clearly bad. I wouldn't recommend buying meat from here. I should have taken pics .

Elizabeth Armstrong

2022-05

Such nice people here! Always greeting me when I come in and just live the store for what it has to offer. Especially the fresh chicken in the back!

Jeff Kohler

2019-05

Absolutely love this store they are very friendly and very helpful always with smiles and a great attitudes they have made us very happy every time we have done business with themKEEP UP THE GREAT WORK !!!Jeff & Sheryl Kohler

Marie Annette

2022-05

I can always find what I need from fresh produce to beautiful flower arrangements.They really have some great treats for Valentines Say and the Flower arrangements are 😍

K D

2022-05

An excellent small town market with plenty of selection and helpful employees who care about their customers needs.Still going strong even after all the difficulties presented by Covid.

lisa harms

2018-05

I am from Illinois and it is Father's day. My Father lives near Seiters ..Paula was so helpful to make my Father special and loved today when I couldn't do it personally . Thank you Paula for making the doggie bouquet. You did an awesome job matching my envision. It meant so much to me and my Father! 5🌟🐶

Curt Weaver

2017-05

Thank you Randy and Karen for allowing our Goodman Flavors on your shelf!! Baking season!! The best thing is that our product is made right here in Missouri. Thanks again.

James Gleason

2022-05

Not a bad store but have gotten past expiration goods from this store more than one time

Joni Spurgeon

2019-05

Great store, but the staff are always, always so sweet to me and my daughter. I have WIC, which is time consuming, and they never make me feel weird about it.

Brandy Donner

2023-06

Great owners and employees are all very friendly!

Patricia Warren

2022-05

Love this store! Small town friendliness, helpful staff, great sales!!!

Paula McMullen-Davis

2021-05

Nice place to shop. Every one there is really nice. This is also where I rented the U-Haul Truck to move.

ruby bunge

2022-05

Love my local store with the awesome family owners.

Ed Mcnew

2019-05

You can get in and out fast. Allot better than going to Walmart and waisting 2 hours of my life and spending way more money than I needed to at walmart.

Lynda Jones

2018-05

Very friendly place! I always feel welcomed and for a smaller grocery store it has decent prices!

John Grady

2020-05

Great selection and the produce and meat is so much better than the big box grocers.

Patricia Blair

2019-05

Friendly staff! Turkey Hill ice cream is available here! Great chicken and BBQ.

Tammy Nichols

2021-05

My favorite store around!! Staff is amazing always a small town feel