New Haven Ice Cream Shoppe

Nicole Rice

2023-06

Quaint ice cream shop in New Haven that offers both food and cold treats. We had the hot fudge sundae, cookie dough concrete, and mint chocolate chip ice cream and it was all delish!

Douglas Grindstaff

2023-05

My first visit. Friends said to order the Deluxe Banana Split. Egad....a monster. Loved every bite. Then found out that Weds.'s were 1/2 price burgers. Gotta try that on the next visit. Friendly worker(s) and nice quaint little place. We'll be back. KOOL!

Nora Winters

2023-05

Had lunch with my BFF. Cheese burger and friesThen I had the very best marshmallow/hot fudge Sunday. I love this place it is home spun.

Cynthia Day

2023-08

We were in town at Astral Glass and stopped in for ice cream. My husband and I got a Carmel sundae with Reese's and they were one of the best sundaes I have ever had. My only issue was the bathroom toilet was pretty gross and there were dirty tables. We were the only people there. Just need to clean a little more.

Tracy Evans

2024-02

…More

Ninett Falkenrath

2023-08

The bacon cheeseburger was so yummy my husband had to order a second! The cheese balls were so crunchy and delicious. And the ice cream... Wow!!! Definitely coming back again!!!

Aaron Montgomery

2023-10

Service was fast and friendly. And you can't beat the prices. What a hidden gem for anyone heading back to St. Louis from Pin Oak Pumpkin Patch.

Randy Mueller

2024-02

…More

Mel Dragon

2021-05

really though new haven has always been really bad for me I don't even recommend staying here for very long

Patricia Blair

2018-05

Great food! You have to have their mozzarella sticks! Ooeygooey goodness!Burgers and salads fill you up!If in New Haven you have to stop in.Oh my goodness... I forgot to tell you that they have the best eggnog ice cream during the holidays!!!

Sarah B

2021-05

I came in with my mom and dad for some ice cream after we ate at the Mexican restaurant. We are not from the area and wanted to try the ice cream. I understand this is a small town joint and may not have the same type of requirements of their employees as a larger city, but there should be respect for the customer. We ordered hand dipped ice cream and there were quite a few families eating in the establishment. The little boy started scooping the ice cream and my dad said to me, I didn’t think you ordered that flavor, I looked and said I didn’t, thinking there was someone possibly in front of me and the little disrespectful boy said “uh NO this isn’t yours, your order is way down the line, there are a lot of other people ahead of you, I have it taken care of”. 30 minutes later, the girl that was working in the back looked out and saw how many tickets he had up and told him he had to scoop all the ice cream before he could take any more orders and was clearly irritated that she had to tell him how to do his job. While he was making a hot fudge sundae the fudge got out of the cup and he used the rag that he wipes the counters with to wipe the fudge back onto the ice cream, WOW!!!! 2 groups of people walked out while we were waiting and rightly so because they weren’t even greeted or told that it would be a few minutes before they could put in their order. I was finally handed ice cream but it was in a cup and then the boy asked what my friend wanted and it was what he handed me in the cup but was supposed to be in a cone. He proceeded to look at me like I told him wrong and was asking what he should do because he had just scooped the last of the ice cream we ordered. The other ice cream I was handed that made it in the cone, we were told was fresh and new and soft and it was melting all over the place. What we tasted was good, but unfortunately we won’t be back again.

Justin Noble

2022-05

Pretty tasty ice cream and the food smelled delicious. Just one glaring issue.....You have a young girl working hard, doing everything up front, a young boy taking money and chatting and another boy doing whatever in the back of the building beyond sight. 1 by 1 the orders got accomplished BECAUSE OF HER! The boys did near zero, save for briskly wiping down a table here and there. While they all were polite, this style of work is not efficient or effective. Many hands make light work and the girl is the star here. I'll be in again soon. Let's see if this changes....

Kristin Hagedorn

2023-05

Love their grilled cheese! Hamburgers and cheese balls are delicious too. And of course, you can't go wrong with ice cream.

Kerry Dilks

2017-05

Great food, we had a meal and I can't wait to go back for some ice cream!🍦🍧I had the grilled cheese and homemade chili, my husband had a salad (pictured). The chili was delicious and the salad was huge and super fresh!

Amanda Rothschild

2019-05

The shoppe was a great addition to our small town when it first opened. However the last several times I came in with my family the shoppe has been in disarray. The floors are black from the lack of cleaning and the bathroom is a total disaster. I would be embarrassed if this is how my restaurant was being represented. I don’t let my children use the bathroom here anymore! I’m afraid of how the kitchen is kept if the front of the store is so badly in the need of cleaning. It is truly sad the lack of care the teen workers put forth, especially when you walk in and they are just sitting at a table playing on their phone and so much cleaning needs to be done!

Jason

2023-12

…More

Tom Douglas

2022-05

Ordered 2 Oreo cyclones and there was zero Oreos in them like completely no Oreos just vanilla ice cream. The rest of the food was good that’s why I gave 2 stars and not 1 but how can you not put Oreos in a Oreo cyclone.

Paula McMullen-Davis

2017-05

I eat here frequently. I usually eat here every Wednesday. I have had nothing bad here. The food is good, reasonable prices and the ice cream is very good! You get a lot of food for the price too!

Gabe Buckner

2019-05

Stopped for ice cream and ended up getting a flat top grilled burger. Just like momma makes them. So so so good. The ice cream was amazing also.

J.R. Sedivy

2017-05

Friendly and efficient service. Fair pricing with a basic selection of ice cream cones, shakes/malts, and blizzard equivalents. No frills casual fast food type items.

Ruth Walters

2019-05

We took Larry's mom for her birthday. She wanted a hot dog for supper. We all was very glad we came to the ice cream shop.

Skyler Griffin

2021-05

Ordered bacon cheese burger with onions, lettuce, and tomato.. it didn't have cheese or bacon on it at all. I wouldn't recommend the food. Maybe the ice cream is good i don't know.

Carl Thomas

2022-05

Website says one price when you order. When u pick up they jack the price up almost double. They say they can't change menu's on line. This is a scam they running.

Kathy David

2021-05

This is a great addition to New Haven, from a full lunch menu to any kind of ice cream u want , you wont be disappointed

Jon Diaz

2023-05

Monday patty melt and club sandwiches were awesome!

Kevin Carwile

2021-05

Great selection and friendly service. Burger's are good as the ice cream.

Mandi Mcdaris

2018-05

Great food, friendly service, awesome staff-if you haven't tried it you're missing out!!

Jessica Underwood

2022-05

i personally love it here. it’s a good place to hang out with friends. everyone is also very friendly.

Marie Annette

2018-05

Always friendly, affordable and delicious! You definitely get your money's worth!

Angie Carlin

2020-05

Always good food and great service ! Small town favorite 😍