Eileen's Colossal Cookies

Andrea Nevermind

2023-09

STOP HERE AND BUY COOKIES!! Holy Good God, biting into a frosted sugar cookie was heaven. Soft, but not doughy. Firm and not dry, but sort of delicate. The icing has Almond extract, and that is the secret to any GOOD frosting or icing in my book!! I could eat these until I make myself sick. And I would be happy doing it. That's how good they are. Oatmeal scotchies were amazing, too!

Jeanette Rovito

2024-04

…More

Brittany

2024-04

…More

Alan Grimes

2021-05

I am very pleased with Eileen's Cookies. The price is incredible for the quality and quantity received. In addition, the staff is always friendly and helpful. They offer a discount on day old cookies (which are always still of excellent quality) and a great fundraising program for groups.

C.C.

2024-04

…More

Amanda Below

2021-05

Great variety of delicious cookies!! Customer service is top notch. Ordered custom cookies for a birthday party and was very impressed with the results. They will be my go to for custom orders from now on. Can't recommend enough!!

Keyare V

2022-05

Me and my boys love Eileens Cookies. They always do an amazing job with our unusal requests. We order cookies 1 - 2 times a month. And everyone is always so nice. If you know the character cookies I posted you know these cookies are perfectly made. Thank you Eileens Cookies staff we truly appreciate all of you.

Mary Manning

2024-04

Excellent cookies. Excellent staff. You can't go wrong here. Went in this business today, awesome peanut butter cookies, and the young man at the registry is a doll. Great job!!!!

Amy Linton

2020-05

Omg.....the cookies are soooooo soft and delicious! We got fresh sugar cookies and they do not disappoint! They have decorated cookies too. Super cute and reasonably priced. We also got day old cookies to try and they were fantastic too!They name says it all.....colossal!

Maggie Crain

2023-09

We ordered cookies for a work event. They were decorated super cute, and as we ordered in under 24 hours!!!!Delicious to boot.Not to sweet, even with all the colored icing required for the decorations. Super impressed. Thank you.

Cassi

2019-05

Huge variety of cookies. Super fresh, soft cookies. Friendly staff. In the Summer they have a Cherry Kool-Aid cookie. It is hands down my favorite. Sad it's only seasonal. I will be back!

Bob Jedd

2023-08

These cookies looked and tasted amazing! I was also shocked by the price, I got 4 cookies for what I would have expected to pay for 1!

Daniel Ferguson

2019-05

We went in to grab a dozen of their Halloween themed cookies for my daughter's dance class. I was not ready for these beauties! What an unbelievable group of talented decoraters in this store! We ended up leaving with way more than the dozen we went for! These will surely be a hit!

Dory Gray

2021-05

Discovered this shop last week! Been already 3 times and I keep coming back! Love their cookies so much! Haven't tried anything like it before! They even sell their cookie dough! Heavenly place!

Sara Brisky

2022-05

We stopped in here while waiting for our table at a nearby restaurant and ended up buying a huge box of cookies. They were delicious and the staff was lovely!

Melony Clark

2024-03

…More

Aubrey G

2023-06

These cookies are so good, especially if you like almond flavored icing. I always request a cookie cake for my birthday. They have a variety of sizes and can do custom designs for every occasion.

Kristin Kandt

2023-05

How could you not like this store? They will give you samples and have giant cookies. Some are better than others. As someone who cannot have a lot of sugar - I can't come here as often as I want and would love some sugar free options available. But they have good, fresh product always.

Sammi Liotta

2020-05

Love this place. Definitely hooked. The frosted sugar cookies are AMAZING! Not to overly outrageously expensive like some other places. Definitely a fan!Go Chiefs!

Sarah Phillips

2023-05

The price is good and the service staff is excellent!The cookies, however, are too sweet, greasy, and about a third of them were under baked by a couple of minutes- had that hallmark dark sunken spot in the middle. I was excited for the white chocolate chip macadamia cookie, but could taste neither over just how super sweet the dough is.

Kaui Samson

2023-05

Okay...these are the best damn cookies I've ever had! Normally I'm not one for frosting or sprinkles, especially sprinkles however it tasted freshly made these guys bake cookies the way it should be baked because they are surprisingly phenomenal!

Sarah Kill

2021-05

Definitely recommend! We ordered a chocolate chip cookie cake for my son’s birthday... it was so good! I don’t typically eat frosting, but theirs is delicious. Ordering process was very easy and thorough. Also, very affordable!

C C

2019-05

Friendly staff and great location. These weren't the best cookies that I have ever tasted but they were certainly pretty decent. My son didn't like the chocolate chip but I fell in love with the double lemon (lemon cookie with lemon frosting). I was pleasantly surprised because I would think that the frosting on top of the cookie would be too much and too sweet but they were delicious! Also the prices were extremely reasonable. The large cookies go for $1.25 each. I'll definitely be going back.

Evin Sprague

2022-05

My sister recommended this place as she just moved to Smithville. I live far away, but had to run some parts to a crew so I stopped and grabbed a few cookies for my kid and I. I love them! They are very good! There’s some almond flavoring which is how I make sugar cookies.

Lauren Jennings

2022-05

Our favorite cookies of all time! The icing is fantastic and everything is fresh and the store is clean. We bring these cookies to every event and order for birthdays and things as well. I highly recommend!

Samantha Priddy

2023-09

Really impressed by the quality, price and how they had so many options. The lady helping me on the Barry Road location was so nice and helpful. I love that they are a local company.

Lisa Cerutti

2023-05

Always delicious. Their sugar cookies are definitely the stars of the snow. Loaded with delicious frosting and constantly changing fun designs. They do a great job with custom orders too!

Devin Gragg

2020-05

We ordered a yummy cookie kit from Eileen's Colossal Cookies off Barry Rd a few weeks ago. My girls loved decorating the cookies. It was something different to break up the monotony of our day AND I didn't have to bake anything. Everything was ready to go and super fresh! While I was there I picked up some cute cookies to deliver to the girls' wonderful teachers. 🍪

F ST

2022-05

My 5yo and I stumbled upon this place yesterday! She loved the emoji icing on her cookie and I truly enjoyed the large snicker doodle cookie and the PB Chocolate Chip cookie! In fact, I even bought some "Day Old" cookies to devour later. They have just the amount of "crisp" on the outside and the chewiness on the inside. Simply delicious without the sweetness twerking my jaws!

Stephanie

2018-05

Man.. I really wanted to like this place. It's location is great (right by Dollar Tree, Hobby Lobby, and post office). I went in the other day with my two kids to check it out and got two sugar cookies to take home for a treat. My oldest took a bite and immediately spit it back out (which NEVER happens), and sadly I did the same when I tried it. The icing/frosting was funky tasting. Later, a friend of mine told me that Eileens' uses almond extract and that's what gives it that weird taste. Maybe we'll try a non-frosted cookie next time, but we will definitely not be buying any more cookies with icing.