Ole Tyme Pantry

tasthedingus

2023-09

This place is awesome! Not only is the deli top of the line, the bakery is amazing! In addition to that, they have an obvious presence in the local community with friendly people chatting and eating their sandwiches in their outdoor seating area when I visited on a Tuesday afternoon (I assume this is pretty much an all the time thing). I had a conversation with a very nice older couple outside while we ate our sandwiches, and got to pet their cute dog named Charlie! Great food, great people, and such a nice friendly atmosphere! I'll definitely be back soon!

Laura Cortner

2020-06

What an amazing place! So much to offer-a meat and cheese counter, spices, dips, candies, bakery items, drinks...amazing! While the take and bake pies looked incredible we ended up trying a few of the speciality sodas and mini buckeye candy. Delicious. We will be back to try the soup mixes! Several people seemed to have stopped in to grab a freshly made sandwich for lunch. Will definitely be back!

Margaret Buettner

2024-05

…More

Brandice Huffman

2024-03

…More

Jerry Kokesh

2022-06

Nice little store... super cinnamon rolls, nice selection of Amish cheeses and meats, lots of bulk food and some nice gift ideas. Will no doubt return. Very friendly staff. Highly recommended! New location; higher prices.

Mike DeBusk

2024-05

…More

Stacey Brandt

2022-06

Great variety of products. Friendly staff. Love the deli. Reasonable prices.

Semo Farmgirl

2023-08

Place is scrupulously clean and tidy. Always smells amazing. Has foods available that you can't find anywhere else. Great bulk selection, including bulk meat specials occasionally. Deli is fantastic. I love the Lebanon Bologna.

Adam Yarbrough

2024-05

…More

Sandra Turner

2024-04

…More

Mark Easter The Old Guy Pettus Automotive (The Old Guy at Auto Plaza)

2023-07

There is so much goodness in here. All of the reviews will talk about the sandwiches, which is on fresh baked bread! Their sliced meats of the highest quality. If you like pepper cheese with a "little kick", try theirs! If you are a BBQ/Smoker, you will want to come in for all the bulk spices. If you are into eating healthy, they have a large selection of grains, beans, lentils and etc. The service is impeccable. The sandwiches are the talk of the town. You will receieve a blessing stopping by here.

Jared Degonia

2023-09

I don't think customer service Is their forte when it's close to closing time. Stood in line at the deli for a few minutes. The lady in front of me was placing an order and taking a while. By this time, it was 446. That's when customer service kicked in to turn me away. Was never greeted, never acknowledged. I thought the whole building closed at 5. If they had just greeted me and stated they were closing in a few minutes I would have understood and tried again another time. Guess the other 2 employees were not able to provide service since they stared at me and said nothing. Wanted to try this place but I guess that will never happen. Sure they have a solid customer base and don't need me anyway so thanks for making my mind up for me.

Mike Bowers

2024-03

…More

Debbie Lake

2024-01

I buy all my baked goods from Old Tyme Pantry. My husband loves the homemade rolls !Parking: Plenty of parking

Porcius Schanda

2023-12

…More

Ryan Juntunen

2023-12

…More

Stefanie Rijkse

2023-09

Delicious foods. I always love coming here and finding something new to try. The homemade items in the refrigerated section are so good. The people that run this store are very friendly and welcoming.

Doug B

2023-12

…More

Laura Newman

2024-04

…More

Shelly Rushing

2021-06

The best deli sandwiches in the world. Amazing Assortments of home goods, dairy products, fresh deli meats and cheese! The bakery items and bread are incredible! Wonderful staff. Wonderful place to get quality products for my family. We make the drive from St.Louis.

Crystal DeGrant

2023-08

Love the variety. The sandwiches are so good. Lunchmeat and cheese are delicious. Everyone that works there are so friendly

Samantha Duzinskas

2023-11

Very cute store. Great place to pick up bulk items and get coffee/bakery

Mike

2023-07

Plenty of wonderful foods! Staff if fun and helpful. Gotta try the sandwichs, their amazing! Love the candy too!

Judy Pearson

2022-06

Just incredible! 1st visit will not be my last. Not enough room here to list all the goodness. Bought my daughter her Mother's day present here.Rosebud cremeLemon pound cakeFingerLickin sauceBuying for self would be best as not knowing exactly what another person prefers may make it difficult to choose. SO many good items! Love it!PLUS !! the outdoor furniture is incredible! Will last for generations!AND I had a reuben sandwich. Every bite was scrumptious!

Homer Houses

2023-09

Wonderful selection (love the deli) and friendly knowledgeable staff. Prices a little high but quality makes up for it.

angela buff

2023-06

Lovely place to shop n get my cheese n lunch meat.Is so delicious.The ladies are awesome n so sweet n friendly.My permanent place of shopping.

Valarie Moore

2022-06

Prices were so much less than I anticipated. They also accept EBT which is awesome and they have everything homemade. Pickled powdered gluten-free extra sugar, no sugar thing you can imagine to bake, bake and create anything edible or delicious

Bonnie Moser

2023-07

I recently found this treasure here in Farmington! The sandwiches are the best!! So many unusual treats to choose from. You have to try it out!!!

Missy Gower

2022-06

Wonderful baked goods. The sandwiches are delicious. And I really like the selection of treats and candies. I like to share their prepackaged treats and candies for holidays. Good wholesome atmosphere and I love the Christian theme and music

Mike Siliven

2024-02

…More