Midwest Rare Coins & Collectibles

Darrell Elliott

2024-03

Super trustworthy. I always have amazing experiences at Midwest Rare Coins and Collectables. The owner took time to educate me and he showed me how he verifies his products. He is extremely knowledgeable and the price is right as well. Thank you for your help Aaron it is a blessing to know I have someone I can trust in your field. You will see me again.

Susan Dryden

2024-03

Buying precious metals is complicated, I have been working with Aaron for almost 10 years, not only has Aaron taken the time to educate me, he has always been fair, honest, and very knowledgeable about the metals market and has really helped me understand and make money!!! He is the "go to" guy that you can TRUST 100% I have read some reviews that I don't agree with, clearly those people have not taken to right approach to the metals market and not listened to Aaron's advice!!

Dallas Jennings

2024-04

Went in to sell some coins after being offered 10% under spot value at Amerigems and Aaron at Midwest Rare Coins & Collectibles didn’t hesitate to offer me spot value. You will be valued and not taken advantage of working with Aaron!

George Batek

2024-05

Nice shop! Nice job Aaron! Fair deals, always trying to get nice inventory for his customers!

Steve and Joni Halpin

2024-04

Good selection. Buzzer to get in but in a safe part of town and business inside an old shopping center. Owner is nice and his dog doesn't bite!

Tim Laws

2024-03

I bought a bunch of silver coins here and was charged nearly $6 OVER spot and was told that is normal rates. I was told not worry bc they “ALWAYS” buy silver back at $2-4 OVER spot. I called them to sell some coins and was offered $.80 UNDER spot. They claim the market has changed. I’m wondering if the definition of ALWAYS also changed. This man 100% said ALWAYS several times. (It’s only reason I made the purchase). He is a liar. He also didn’t offer $2 OVER spot he offered $.80 under. He tried to scam me bc he thought I was not knowledgeable. It’s about keeping your word not unreasonable expectations.

Steve Baumann

2024-04

*** I had to drop them a star. I had a German helmet, a 1937-1938 Normandy tri-color, original and authentic, he offer $50.00 I was interested in a sale or trade, not an insult. :PGood, fun store. Nice selection, they even had some of the towns rare old collectible people hanging around, making it extra special. I'll be back

Jack Bruns

2024-02

This shop and owner are the real deal. Fair,honest,dependable and knowledgeable. Aaron works hard at his craft,does coin shows and is definitely in the loop of collectable coin,gold and silver bullion and is the only real coin shop that is in mid-missouri.Go by and see for yourself and meet all the local other dealers and trusting customers conversing and doing business!

Josh Eichholz

2024-02

I was in a jam and had to sell some coins and for some reason they consider proof coins still junk silver either that or that's how they low ball people so they don't have to pay them very much. Needless to say I don't think I got what I should have as far as value goes. If you're thinking about selling coins I personally would go somewhere else.

Charlie Wise

2024-03

Prices for buying and selling are always fair, and on par with the market! Always been a good visit, and smooth transaction. I drive an hour just to business here!

Matthew Haller

2023-11

Best Guy in the business!!! Fully stocked store, Very Knowledgeable owner, great prices!!!5 stars all the way the way around.If you are looking to buy or sell any precious metals there is no better place!!!

Diana Hatfield

2024-02

Great Fun Store. Very honest, is Veteran owned and he pays fairly.,Diana Hatfield, Columbia, MO

Robert Wathey

2024-01

I called inquiring about a coin I assumed he had listed online, he was very rude and short with me on the telephone, and practically hung up in my ear, with customer service skills (Or lack there of) of this nature I wouldn't do business with this person if he was giving them away for free!

sarah donley

2024-03

Super honest, Aaron is the only guy I would trust in the industry.

Ryan Blackburn

2024-04

ALWAYS CLOSED!! my goodness my friend. But always been fair and a VERY NICE GUY

Serena Bailey

2024-03

Great place for the best coins - Customer Service is top tier 👌 Simply the BEST in the Midwest

MIKE LASHER

2024-05

Great coin shops, lots of inventory, and stuff to check out.

John “Matt” Rasse

2023-05

Very professional, an knowledgeable on old, and rare coins. Also, they have a abundant variety of items. From ancient "First Nation's" relics, to raw cut, or un-cut raw gemstones, to Precious Metals bullion, coinage, to ancient cull. You will find a wide variety of graded coins as well.All in all, a very fun place to get started in stacking Precious Metal's, or for someone who has a variety of historical artifacts, an wishes to add to their collection.I highly recommend to stop by, an visit this store. You will be greeted with a smile, an the professionalism of a knowledgeable team. Not to mention, a beautiful four legged team member, that fits right in, an a excellent guard.Five star's!!!

Droopy G

2023-05

What I love about this place is that they will show and help you understand what you have and the value. They also show you why it's valued as such, so that you will know what you have when you are ready to sell or buy anything they have in their store..It is just satisfying just to look at the amazing and old coins..It's the bullion's that catch my eyes everytime!Stop on in and look around!

George Arnold

2023-05

I found the prices at this establishment to be very fair and reasonable. Aaron also has a lot of neat wall and display case items that are good talking points for his patrons. Last but not least, he has a very adorable dog!

Angie Swedeen

2023-05

I spoke with a guy named Aaron. His attitude was horrible. He seemed extremely rude and wasn't very helpful at all. Even if he didn't have any knowledge on the topic, he could have at least been polite in explaining so. I won't ever go back as there's many other places more deserving of my business.

Kate De.

2024-01

Place is amazing! Has the coolest stuff and the NICEST staff!

Gen Obvious

2020-05

He's a fair and helpful owner. I've been here many times over the past few recent months. Love the items he has, and prices are pretty fair. Interesting items he has. I wish he'd smile more though and more talkative. Guess he just has to get too know someone better first. :)

Sikander 79

2018-05

This shop is one of the coolest shops I've visited in Columbia. Not only is the owner and those who work with him extremely knowledgeable, but they have always been friendly and patiently willing to share their knowledge or answer questions. Whether you are a novice or a long time collector don't be surprised to find that even if you were to have come into the store alone, you will certainly leave the store having experienced a strong sense of respect and a newfound friendship. Now should you arrive and they are really busy, DON'T be discouraged by having to wait. Each customer they are with are in that moment, their most important customer, and they want nothing more than to show the proper respect and give each person their undivided attention. It IS WORTH the wait. I have been fortunate to be a long time customer there and also now have the privilege of being on a first name bases with the owner. He has repeatedly went out of his way to show that I am welcome and I appreciate the day that my curiosity brought me in that first day.Go check them out! There isn't a chance that you'll regret it!-TJ KENNEDY Columbia MO

Eric L

2018-05

I have bought and sold coins and bullion off and on for years with Dean at Midwest Rare Coins and Jewelry. I have received good advice and fair prices for both buying and selling. His service is always top-notch and I plan to continue to use this establishment.

Cindy Bell

2020-05

I met Aaron today at his shop because a relative had collected some coins and we knew nothing about their value. Aaron could not have been nicer. He patiently went through them, explaining things as he went along. I could not have been more pleased with his customer service and knowledge.

Mark Hollandsworth

2018-05

Visited Dean and his shop this morning, and had the most pleasant experience. Informative with a sense of humor...I felt right at home browsing his vast collection of coins and products relating to the hobby. Cannot wait to go back. Thanks Dean!

Steven Snow

2019-05

I have seen some shops try to really low-ball people when they come in to sell stuff. My experience with Aaron can best be summed up in one word. He was “fair.” “Fair” works for me. I would recommend his shop to others.

Tony Burruss

2023-12

If you don't have anything good to say don't say nothing I am saying nothing

Mumbleocalypse

2019-05

I am new to the hobby and was treated as if I had been in the hobby for years. That's a big deal for me! The guy that helped me was friendly and has a wealth of knowledge that he shared generously. This is my coin shop, no need to go anywhere else.