Patellie's

Nick Pecora

2024-01

…More

Ryan Kwiecinski

2024-02

This place is SO good. We had a group trip from Chicago for a long weekend and got pizza here from one of the nights. We ordered a few different types and each one was delicious! I wish that it could be local for us, we would get pizza from here frequently. The service was on-point as well. It was ready when we got there and everyone was so friendly. We'll definitely order from here again in the future!

Jason Parke

2024-04

…More

Yumsah's Website Design

2023-05

…More

Jordan Wojdula

2023-11

…More

Mandy Lynn

2023-09

Best pizza seriously I've ever had. All I can say is wow. My whole family loved it. I grew up in three oaks and this is the best pizza I've gotten from that corner spot.We got the HI pizza for the adults and cheese for the kids.My husband also tried the meatballs- fantastic!Will definitely be back

Justin Camer

2024-04

…More

Luna Shotsberger

2023-10

Roasted chicken 10/10!Pizza is a great choice and open later than other places in the area. Gluten free: they don’t have gluten free pizza. The items on their menu that are naturally without gluten are roasted chicken, side of potatoes and house made sausage *sans the bun. As well as any of salads without croutons and the house marinated olives (gluten). Obviously it's a pizza place, so cross contamination is possible. A variety of desserts available. They are all individually labeled for allergies.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free: they don’t have gluten free pizza. The items on their menu that are naturally without gluten are roasted chicken, side of potatoes and house made sausage *sans the bun. As well as any of salads without croutons and the house marinated olives (gluten). Obviously it's a pizza place, so cross contamination is possible.Kid-friendliness: Kid friendlyWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible

Nancie Smith

2024-04

…More

Kimber Chang

2020-05

My favorite pizza. The crust is perfectly crunchy, sauce is simple but delicious, topping are all amazing and high quality. This pizza checks all my boxes. Sides are also amazing especially in the summer, killer local veggies and homemade mozzarella and burrata. We always stop here when passing through, A to the freaking + all around.

Perry Hook

2023-09

…More

Oren Kieth

2023-05

After moving back to three oaks I had to try this place once I heard all the great things about itThe crust is super thin, just the way I like it.The staff is very friendly.Price point is what I expected for a tourist town.I will definitely be back!!!!

Victoria Beck

2023-05

My husband and I just opened a bike shop in Three Oaks and have been eating our way around town and this is hands down one of the best pizza places I have been to. The crust is thin and tasty and the sauce is seasoned just right. We love the Hawaiian!

D Kizer

2023-05

I love this place so much, the food is fabulous! I chose their meat sub to have for my birthday dinner. Their meatballs just melt in your mouth. Their oh so creamy delicious ricotta cheese spread on both sides of the bun is just mouth watering. Try one for yourself, you won't regret it!

Patrick Baker

2023-05

Simple yet excellent pizza. House made ingredients, great service, quick, we tried the sausage, margarita, and veggie and everything was delicious! Order more than you think you need because you can’t stop eating it! While you’re there, visit their wine shop right around the corner. You’ll be glad you did!

Gabe Zarzecki

2024-04

…More

William Rodgers

2020-05

Finally, a pizza parlor worth its weight in gold. Not heavy on the sauce, rich tasting cheese and mild sausage yet full of flavor. Excellent New York style crust. I could live off of this pizza. Nice, friendly and personable. You can tell they pride themselves on quality and reasonable to boot!

Babu Tree

2018-05

Was expecting great Pizza and they exceeded my expectations. Great Pie and great people!

Ben Holt

2023-06

Great pizza! Keep meaning to try their other menu items but I can’t stopping getting their Hawaiian pizza.

Ivan Fedore

2019-05

The pizza, staff, and now bottle shop are great! I'd be embarrassed to have a count of how many times I've been here in the past few months.

Jordan Brackeen

2021-05

The service here is always friendly and fast and the staff is always courteous and pleasant to talk to. Their pizzas are reasonably priced and taste great. I wish they had full time options for different sauces on the pizzas, possibly even a couple specialty pizzas. I definitely recommend this place to anyone who wants a good classic thin pizza with a cozy atmosphere and friendly service.

William Reynolds

2018-05

Perfect pizza...thin crust but strong enough to hold the toppings. Crisp delicious crust with just enough tomato sauce and cheese to compliment the freshly made sausage, mushrooms and bell peppers we added.Good selection of soft drinks including three ginger sodas ( my favorite). Great addition to three oaks and run by the same couple who made local so successful. Highly recommend

Blake Strefling

2022-05

super thin and just not that great in my honest opinion.For a $25 pie I expected much better. Little Caesars has you beat for less then half the price and no wait.Staff was nice though.

Carmen Aiello Schmidt

2022-05

I'm from Naples, Italy. There is no need to tell you how much I miss my pizza. Well, Patellie's help a lot. It's not exactly the same, of course, but among the pizzerie (pizzerie is the plural of pizzeria in Italian) in the area, this is the one that makes the closest margherita to the Neapolitan one. Good quality ingredients, you can tell from the milky flavor of the mozzarella. Original simple tomato sauce and not the classic pizza sauce that you find everywhere else (and that we never use in Italy). The only little flaw I found is that when pizza gets cold, the crust becomes very tough and kind of rubbery. Anyway, thank you Patellie's, for giving me a little taste of Naples when I'm not in the mood to make my own pizza at home. Another positive note: the nice outdoor patio during summertime!

Valentina Kniess

2021-05

This is one of the best pizzas in Southwest Michigan! I moved up here from NY/NJ, and was having a difficult time finding pizza that was as good as what they make back east - BUT THEN I FOUND PATELLIE'S!!! Just as good as the pizzerias in Brooklyn (forgive me, but dare I say even better than some...). They would do well on 18th Avenue 😁The crust is close to Brooklyn style, but just slightly thicker - yet still bubbly and crisp! Ask about their weekly specials. These creative pies are unbelievably delicious! My only critique is for their margarita pie. In my opinion it needs more fresh basil and perhaps some fresh tomato chunks or slices - but it's not a deal breaker.

Colin Hayes

2019-05

Shoo wee that's good pizza! Awesome crust and great fresh ingredients on the specials.

Paul Smith

2023-08

…More

Bryce WithRice (BryceWithRice)

2023-05

If you are in New Buffalo drive over here for pizza and skip Villa Nova (terrible pizza for more expensive)Best New York style pizza in the Midwest and better than any pizza you’ll get over in South Bend.A true gem for a small town

Preston Stell

2018-05

If you ever enjoyed food from LOCAL in New Buffalo, then you know the skill of the two folks who operate this pizzeria. I walked in to Patellie's with plenty of presuppositions, I walked out with a happy belly and with all those presuppositions affirmed. These folks know food. Better still, they care where the food they serve comes from. I can't think of a place in Berrien County that I could enjoy sausage on a pizza, because pigs are tradition treated horribly. However, Patellie's sources happy pigs that live a fantastic life, and as Ellie says, "with just one bad day." I can always expect to have sustainably raised veggies and meat at Patellie's which is why we can't wait to go back. In addition the pizza is thin with a crust that needs to be savored. The meatballs were perfect. It's been almost two weeks since I've gone and I'm still having dreams about them. The salad was a delight too and the dressing were incredible. The staff....Pat and Ellie are a great addition to Three Oaks food, not just because they make great food, but because they are friendly people. That friendliness seems to draw other friendly staff to their business. Abby and Jessica were working up front when we went in and you find yourself talking to them instead of ordering your food sometimes because they have such inviting personalities. The price actually seemed low considering the quality of food you are getting. Did I mention I can't wait to go back!? Thanks for doing the hard work of bringing great food to Southwest Michigan's people!

Dawson Kegley

2023-05

Truthfully a weird place. 1 size pizza, zero appetizers, some of the strangest hours, and yes it’s good pizza, but I’m not losing my mind over it. The price doesn’t sit well with the restaurant.