Sidney Market

Lauri Zimmerman

2024-01

I’m not sure who made our pizza today but it was absolutely delicious! They’re always very good , but today it was truly the best we’ve ever had!

Vivian Brys

2022-05

Don’t listen to any bad reviews. I would give 100 stars if I could. Amazing pizza! Super cheesy and filled with toppings! They also have stuffed crust! Yum! Great service. Very friendly faces and SO helpful. I would spend my money here 100% of the time.

Becky B

2022-05

Pizza was dry and didn’t taste good. The gentleman said that I could bring it back and they would make a new one, but tasting it didn’t make me want to go back for more and I explained that to him. He said that there should have been ranch on the top which there wasn’t. I guess not the place to go for pizza. One little sauce for big cheese bread isn’t cool either.

Cat 15

2021-05

$27.55 for 1 large pizza, excuse me I ordered 1 not 2. Wasn't even very good. Hardly any sauce and way too much sausage. Supposed to be deluxe, not meat lovers. I like shopping local and American, but can't afford this place. Employees are nice but I would not want to work there and rob people. I know it is a small town, but even Main Street pizza, which is way better, is less than $20 for one. Last sale you will get from me. Good luck.

Ken Miller

2022-05

The pizza slices are huge for the price. The pizza is equally delicious. Anything they cook here seems to be a good quality. They have liquor too which is a bonus

Ron Corwin

2021-05

Everyone seems to be friendly, courteous, and kind. I ordered pizza several times and they always seem to be delicious. There's subs should be served with pickles!!!! The subs are Very good as well.

Heather Nichols

2022-05

Its a small store in a small town. The prices are a little high, which can be expected in this situation. A package of muddy buddies that costs 2.44 at walmart and aprox 2.50 on amazon cost 2.95 here.Aside from that, they are very clean, and have a public bathroom (for customers only)... The bathroom may change, as they are threatening to lock the doors because a costomer has been smoking in thier bathroom. There is a sign posted on the bathroom door with this info.Almost nothing in the store has a price on it. Which makes it extremely difficult when you take a child wanting to spend thier own money on a snack, or you have a limited snack budget and you can't make an informed decisions without taking each item up and asking for a price check. They are quite busy at times and having to wait in line to get a price check is frustrating. They are pretty fast at the check out, so that helps elevate that frustration a little.The last issue I ran into was, I ended up having to use my card, (my children wanted to buy thier own snacks but couldn't because we didn't know any prices. When we went up to price check, there were 5+ people in line behind us and more shopping. So when we realized the kids could not afford what they chose, I told them they could pay me half and I would cover it on my card.) And when I told the cashier this, my price went up by $3. It was a frustrating expensive snack run.The people seem very nice. And there were a couple good things going for them. That is why I gave them a 3 star. Being pleasant and clean isn't quite enough for us though, we do not plan to go back to this store.

Wes Shoen

2022-05

Been working in the area for several weeks stopped in to get lunch between 12 and 12:30 many times to either no food being told a 20 or 30 min wait. And when there is food is so old you have to scrape it out of the cardboard container. Use to be a great place for lunch now very disappointing.

Felicia H.

2020-05

Ordered pizza and breadsticks. Pizza was good. Not the best but still topping the list of pizza around the area. I was less than impressed with the breadsticks. The bottom is burned and they are way smaller than what i was expecting. The guy who delivered and took my order was great though.

Kameron Carnes

2022-05

The Nevins lake, now known as the magnum sports pizza is probably the best pizza if you want just the right amount of heat, flavor, and crunchy crust. Very well done!

Narissa Sigafoose

2014-05

I ordered their pizza and breadsticks on sunday May 4th. Took a half an hr to get an answer. An older lady made the pizza and breadsticks and were still doughy in the center but it was still good pizza. They need to turn their oven down some more or not be in such a rush. I had their pizza before (last year) and their pizza was better than Mr. T's but a younger lady made it then.

B

2021-05

I work as a sales rep and I encounter a lot of owners. Gary, is by far the nicest and most open minded owner I've met. The store has come along ways since his ownership. I look forward to working with him and seeing his growth.

mistey diamond

2021-05

Do not listen to any negative reviews this place really gives home town store the meaning of kind hospitality. The ladies that work here are so kind and courteous......the food is very good. Truly love this little store

Ginger Evans

2023-09

I worked at this store years ago.... It's nice to see it still going strong.

Matthew Diamond

2021-05

The true meaning of a hometown genral store, they make you feel like family. Employees go out of their way to make you feel like you belong there. Food is great to top it off.

Leo Bannen

2021-05

service was awesome ladys were all super nice and my pizza was awesome surcharge on my gas with card was lil bummed but worth it for experience.

Michael Vaivada

2022-05

Really good subs, and they don't skimp on toppings for your pizza. Well worth the stop.

Tiger Pilkinton

2021-05

The new owner is awesome and they have later hours and offer delivery for their great pizza and other items in their store.

Debbi Phipps

2021-05

Pizza was delicious. great staff friendly they were patient with my 89 year old friend

Dennis B -Trains

2022-05

Nice to see it open again. Friendly service. They sell Gas and Diesel now for awhile. Always pretty busy around lunch.

Rhob Bauer

2021-05

Great homemade everything, I just finished a sub and YUMM, you have to visit to believe it. They have a fun selection of produce, beer, alcohol, cigarettes, odds and ends you need, and more!!

Jeffrey Jackiewicz

2023-06

Great for a quick stop and food delicious pizza and subs

Connie Small

2020-05

Great store pizza and subs are awesome love all the selection they have the staff is very helpful

Tom

2021-05

Friendly staff, great pizza, nice liquor selection, good coffee/cappuccino for a convenience store with quality cups

Faith McKenna

2023-05

Step back in time kinda building , typical general store and gas station. Deli active, I tried the chicken salad and it was awesome.

Cheyenne Kelly

2022-05

Pizza was great. The crew working tonight was working extra hard! Nice job

Gary Cole

2021-05

Awesome place to grab a drink or something warm or cold from the deli! Have awesome pizza and calzones!!!

Dennis Casey

2022-05

So happy to see the Sidney General Store survive through the pandemic! Love stopping here omw to MCC for a quick drink or an ice cream cone!!

C C

2021-05

The pizza is wonderful the subs are wonderful and the ladies that work here are just beautiful peopleStop on in

Brian Allen

2021-05

Pizza is delicious was wanting to try this for awhile. Pricey but quality is worth it.