Villa Nova Pizzeria - New Buffalo

Adam “Infinius” Lesniewski

2023-11

…More

Carol Pozos

2023-09

We had great service from Lexi. The gluten free pizza is the best around and it's cooked in a separate kitchen!Lexi suggested kettle chips for the spinach artichoke dip so I could share with my husband. Good call! The weather was perfect for the patio. Service was pretty quick considering how busy they were.

Meranda Burkhardt

2023-05

The pizza was very good, cooked well. The fries came out cold from the sandwich, not sure what's up with that. I appreciate them being open on a holiday but pretty much all the servers didn't look like they wanted to be there at all, had to ask for my check and refill and they were just sitting on their phone. I'm not impressed with this kind of service, especially when you're being tipped to serve. (yes I did tip.) was $92 for five people to eat.

Jennifer Haak

2024-04

What a great surprise! I was a little hesitant taking my family here, based on past reviews. I'm so glad we came though, because everything was TERRIFIC! We had the best service and the food was soooo good. All of it. I'm picky and I was super happy.Only issue is the seating. We were on high boys and it made me uneasy with my little ones. There was a private party in the next room, otherwise I'm sure we would have had different seating. I bet the summertime vibe is great! Especially with the outdoor seating.Dietary restrictions: Has gluten free pizza option! Yay!

Robert Rezzardi

2024-02

…More

Nate Weldy

2024-03

Great pizza, the crust is thin and crispy and the spinach artichoke dip was delicious. Also the Bloody Marys were really good and had delicious fixins with it. The main dining area was really cold and I've worked in a pizza joint before and assumed it was because the workers were hot next to the ovens. They graciously asked us if we wanted to move to the other room and told us they cranked the heat. Thank you so much Villa Nova for making our visit great!

Samantha Henry

2024-04

My family came here last night after I read such good reviews. From the moment I walked in it was disappointing. We had never been before so we stood at the front, and were told in a very monotone voice to sit wherever we wanted. The table we chose was near the door, and it was freezing. Our server took our drink order and food order, but that is about all. The person who I am assuming is our host brought our food out, but brought both adult meals out at least 10 minutes before the kids food which if you have kids, you know is just calling for chaos. We also were not brought utensils and had to request them. (We did not all have pizza, I had ravioli) The food was fine, but nothing special honestly. We did not see our server again until we were ready to pay, and I had to ask the hostess for our bill and she had to find our server.

Asli Weil

2023-08

…More

Yumsah's Website Design

2023-05

Thin crust pizza was flavourful for the size, though at $7 I was kind of expecting a more fulfilling slice. There was 5 workers by the register and I had to wait an awkward moment while they finished up their talk so I could place my order.Overall a good place to grab a bite.

Laura Levin

2023-05

Best thin crust pizza I've had in a long time! Big chunks of sausage and if you love cheese they take care of ya! I ordered extra cheese and the cheese is real and the pizza was awesome 👍🏻😎 today we have the combination and a calzone... unbelievably amazing 😍Parking: Plenty of parking

Robert Bugajski

2023-12

Let me just say I have never gave a 5 Star review for a restaurant but at last I have found the perfect place for what I like. The food is absolutely amazing! The quality is top notch. We sampled a few things. The pizza is perfect. Perfect chips, toppings are amazing. Just I can go on and on. This place is the best. Atmosphere is just how I like it. Super chill but a bit upbeat and friendly. The staff are amazing and just service was on point. I will be coming back and thus will be my new go to when I'm in the area.

maddie ryan

2023-12

Had 3 different people at our table but no one checked up or refilled water. Appetizer took about a half hour but they forgot the pizza. After an hour and a half, the waitress told us the pizza would still be 20 minutes. People were sitting on the floor, on their phone while working. More employees than customers. At least spinach artichoke dip never fails me

donna kavanagh

2024-05

We like the atmosphere the food could be a little better but we didn't have the pizza apparently that's their specialty

Noah Roth

2023-05

Breadsticks are amazing! Topped with a delicious Parmesan and garlicky seasoning. Pizza is a thin, crispy, cracker style crust. The outdoor seating area is cute too. I wasn’t a huge fan of the marinara sauce that comes with the breadsticks, it reminded me of Spaghettios sauce, but that’s just personal preference.

Annie 1

2023-10

Fresh ingredients are always on the pizza 🍅 🥓 🧀 🍕.. Don't forget the French fries 🍟 .. Always Great tasting food...Parking: There is parking on both sides of the restaurant..

Samantha Ibarra

2024-05

…More

grant wilson

2024-04

…More

Jeremiah Swift

2024-05

…More

Mid Night

2024-05

…More

Diane Rickert

2023-11

…More

Tori Thompson

2019-05

The BEST restaurant EVER if you want pizza!!!!! This place was so good that we went twice in two days! The staff if so awesome and the food is incredible! If you go you absolutely must get pizza and try the dessert! I'm not even a dessert fan but the waiter talked us into a warm cookie with ice Cream and it was heavenly! When we go back across Michigan next month this place is first on our list!

John Link

2023-12

…More

Valerie Griffin

2023-05

…More

Matt

2023-10

I've been here twice and both times I had a very different experience. The first time I came in close to closing, and we ordered a pizza and some garlic bread. The pizza was amazing. Thin crust, like a cracker. Fresh sausage. It was awesome. Service was great. Came in on Friday night and ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza and some garlic bread again. This time there was literally piles of onion across the whole pizza. They were slammed busy, we didn't get our drinks until our appetizer got there. Our server was wearing print leggings... looked like she didn't want to be there. It was just an absolute let down. We waited 45 bucks on food we barely ate. I think I'll give it one more chance, but I was super excited and now feel very let down.

Stupd Flanders

2023-12

…More

Lisa Kacerovskis

2023-11

…More

Billy Dubbs

2024-04

…More

Cadet Katie

2022-05

Second time I've ordered delivery. Delivery guy was nice. No complaints about him.I ordered the full order of spaghetti with meat sauce. Thought it came with meatballs (which is pictured on the website). No meatballs. No meat sauce. Just a bland tomatoe sauce with chunks of tomatoes. No option to even order meatballs if it doesn't come with them. For 15.00 I would expect more.First time I got the pizza bread appetizer and it's was bad aswell. You're better off going to the gas station and getting the pizza boats in the freezer section.I don't recommend.Goto Barker Pub in Michigan City. Never have had a bad meal there.

Jovi Bahamundi

2024-03

…More

Dave Fournier

2023-05

Ordered Villa Nova pizza for takeout. Pizza was ok not great. Appearance is not appetizing with partially crusty, dry, semi-hardened cheese on top concealing the pepperoni beneath. Texture and flavor reminded me of store-bought frozen pizza. And no napkins available for our to-go order.