Orrington Pizza

Teresa Littlejohn

2024-04

Welcome to Orrington!! We ordered a small Supreme pizza (minus the black olive due to food allergies) and a small cheese pizza on a Monday night. My call went through on the 1st try. Staff was VERY friendly. Our special order was accurate! The pizza was delicious! Classic fresh dough! 🍕 The sausage was thin sliced, "cupped" sausage, which I'd never had, but loved it that way! It had a nice crunch on the edges the way cupped pepperoni does. They did not skimp on the toppings! Surprisingly, all 3 of us preferred the classic cheese pizza to the Supreme! It was exactly what you'd expect a classic fresh dough cheese pizza to taste like! Even though it was only cheese, it holds its own as a great pizza! We will be back to try other toppings soon! 😋Dietary restrictions: Staff had no issue with omitting the ingredients we are allergic to!

Tom M

2024-05

Got myself a large pie, and the wife a gluten free pepperoni. Both were very good. The crust has good flavor, it had the right amount of toppings cheese and sauce. The wife was also very happy with her special crust pizza. Folks were nice inside. This is a good addition to the area.Dietary restrictions: Wife loved the gluten free crust.

Eric & Parise Perkins

2024-04

We were very excited to try this new establishment and we were not disappointed. The food was delicious! We ordered a steak and cheese sandwich, veggie pizza, and a side of onion rings. While all of our choices were fantastic, we agreed that the onion rings were the best we’ve ever had. Just the right amount of crisp without being over done! The pizza and steak and cheese were both cooked perfectly and so flavorful. Lastly, the staff was friendly and inviting. Welcome Orrington Pizza! We will be making you a weekly stop.Parking: Large parking lot with plenty of spaces.

Sharon Pelkey

2024-04

I am so happy to welcome Orrington Pizza to our little town! Owned and operated by an Orrington family, Orrington Pizza has so much to offer. The pizza is SO GOOD, as are the mozzarella wedges! Online ordering makes it easy to place an order, customer service is top notch, and the dining area is clean, bright, and welcoming. My family is definitely going to make this a regular dining option, and I cannot wait to try more menu items!

Joseph

2024-04

Food was ok wasn't great and wasn't bad.the pizza dough need a bit of adjustment for my taste no crunch big flop.the steak and cheese was 5.5 out of 10, also it was hard to order called and called kept getting a robot voice that said mailbox was full with no indication that i had reached Orrington pizzas answering service. The place looks great and the folks were nice. I think if they are willing to keep working on it and improving they will do fine

Kenneth Nason

2024-05

…More

T Law

2024-04

The people are nice, great customer service. Where my problem lies is the food. The pizza I got was overcooked, the toppings were burnt, and everything was overall flavorless. I have a feeling very bland cheap products are being used, and for the price you just aren't getting the quality you would expect. I hope to eventually give them another shot, but for now I will be avoiding them.

Erick Kennard

2024-04

After a long day on the road, we decided to have pizza for dinner. Given the area, we had many choices. Having heard about a new place in Orrington, we decided to give it a try.DEFINITELY A GREAT CHOICE!We ordered 3 large pizzas, and some breadsticks, to feed 12 people (most being children with hollow legs and big appetites).Let me tell you... a large pizza, is definitely a LARGE pizza! We wound up having an entire pizza and a couple slices left over because the slices were huge and filling!The pizzas were cooked perfectly, not gummy, with the perfect amount of toppings and sauce, not slimy with the cheese sliding off it, like you get at some other places.The breadsticks had a great garlic taste and the right amount of cheese, also cooked perfectly. I had a faithful fan of another pizza place try them and say his favorite had just lost their "best breadstick" title to Orrington Pizza.... I'd say that's a win.Great price, great service. You can order online, by phone, or eat in. Either way, you won't regret your next slice at Orrington Pizza.

Jessica Simmons

2024-04

…More

Marcia Lizotte

2024-05

…More

Jill Hurd

2024-04

Wicked good! Can't wait to try more! Not sure if it's good or bad we live so close. :)Kid-friendliness: Family friendly atmosphereWheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible, clear path right in, parking very close

Lakersfan42

2024-04

…More

C0le Harriman

2024-04

…More

Amy Faro

2024-05

I'm sorry!Wayyy toooo undercooked.Bummer

Jared Willey

2024-04

…More

jayden richards

2024-05

More

Sharon Knapp

2024-04

More

Steven Youngs

2024-04

More

Zarlord24

2024-04

More

thomaz11

2024-04

More